Posts belonging to Category 'asthma treatment'

apology

Question:

>From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net >Date: 4/20/03 1:10 PM Pacific Daylight Time >Tell it all, Sharon – it wasn’t the money, it was the buzz! :-)

Oh all right ;-p Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

>From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net >Date: 4/20/03 1:13 PM Pacific Daylight Time >LOL……..Sharon, as long as you are ok now, that is the important >thing….sue

I sometimes wonder about my heart. I don’t seem to get as many skipped beats since I quit,but I’m not sure about that. I honestly didn’t know,or didn’t pay attention to the fact that, they can cause heart damage. I am coming off a night where I had nightmares all night long. I woke from one and wished it were daylight. I haven’t had a night like that for a long time. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

In article <7Vyoa.70034$ja4.4655…@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>, – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text - "Eva" <EvaDStru…@NOatt.net> wrote: > "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > news:3EA2B782.70703@comcast.net… > > Eva wrote: > > > "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > > > news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… > > >>I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in > > >>the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. > > > ————- > > > Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? > > > Eva (worried about teenager) > > I didn’t even think about that, don’t know if you could get high or not. > >   I was thinking more of a person with breathing problems, using an OTC > > inhaler and not seeing their doctor. Also of a person using an OTC > > inhaler more often then it should be used, causing many side effects. Of > > course this could be done with a prescription inhaler also. > ———- > Sorry, I saw the word "abuse" and that was what I thought of.  Kids will do > all kinds of things if they think it will get them high.  Good God, we used > to sniff Carbona!  (A spot remover, very toxic.)  Airplane glue, Krylon > spray paint….it’s very scary.  Thanks for the explanation.

The thing is, though, not all kids do this or want to do this.  Kids abuse substances because of other stuff.  If your kid’s basically OK and getting what they need at home, chances are extremely good they won’t get into substance abuse.  Substance abuse is a symptom. Priscilla — "I don’t feel comfortable with a boot with my name on it on the throat of the rest of the world."  – Alan Winston in rec.arts.sf.fandom

Response:

Eva wrote: > "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > news:3EA2BE04.3090709@comcast.net… >>Did you see my other post about side effects? When I have used my >>inhaler more then prescribed, I get very jittery, my heart races and I >>get palpetations(sp). > ———- > That doesn’t sound too pleasant at all!  I’m glad you found a doctor that is > helping you.

A Doctor like my ex-doctor, who needed to be in complete control, is the reason I wound up in the hospital a couple of times. Since moving and getting a new doctor, who believes in teaching me how to handle an attack, I have never had to go to the ER or the hospital. I have had bad attacks, but know how to handle them, untill I can see the doctor. sue

Response:

"Priscilla Ballou" <vze23…@verizon.net> wrote in message

news:vze23t8n-379BB3.11035520042003@news.verizon.net… > In article > <Azyoa.70007$ja4.4654…@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>, >  "Eva" <EvaDStru…@NOatt.net> wrote: > > "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > > news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… > > > I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in > > > the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. > > ————- > > Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? > *Can* you get high off inhaler meds?  I mean those for asthma.

A lot of asthma inhalers contain steroids.  They can have a similar effect to "anabolic steroids" if you are into weight training.  You should see my brother’s physique!  (kung fu muscles however <g>) — Jette "Work for Peace and remain Fiercely Loving" – Jim Byrnes je…@blueyonder.co.uk http://www.jette.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->From: "Jette Goldie" j…@blueyonder.com.uk >Date: 4/20/03 6:34 AM Pacific Daylight Time >"Frankenmel" <franken…@aol.comnospam> wrote >> Now I do apologize to Jette for urging her to at least carry an inhaler. I >was >> quite alarmed when she described the (can’t remember how she said it) >bronchial >> reaction because to me that *is* a symptom of asthma,regardless of what a >> doctor might say. It’s a simple matter over here to at least get an OTC >> inhaler. I don’t see anything scary about it at all. BUT…if you >> believe,Jette,that you don’t have asthma or can control it,that’s up to >you. >Whereas here there is no such thing as an "over the counter >inhaler".  They’re all prescription drugs.

I wondered about that. I still question your doctor. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

>From: "Eva" EvaDStru…@NOatt.net >Date: 4/20/03 7:57 AM Pacific Daylight Time >"Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message >news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… >> I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in >> the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. >————- >Abuse them?  You mean, to get high?

Yes,I think they use them in addition to crack or something. I heard once and forgot. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

In article <vze23t8n-88BEE3.11464720042…@news.verizon.net>,  Priscilla Ballou <vze23…@verizon.net> wrote: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> In article > <7Vyoa.70034$ja4.4655…@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>, >  "Eva" <EvaDStru…@NOatt.net> wrote: > > "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > > news:3EA2B782.70703@comcast.net… > > > Eva wrote: > > > > "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > > > > news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… > > > >>I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in > > > >>the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. > > > > ————- > > > > Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? > > > > Eva (worried about teenager) > > > I didn’t even think about that, don’t know if you could get high or not. > > >   I was thinking more of a person with breathing problems, using an OTC > > > inhaler and not seeing their doctor. Also of a person using an OTC > > > inhaler more often then it should be used, causing many side effects. Of > > > course this could be done with a prescription inhaler also. > > ———- > > Sorry, I saw the word "abuse" and that was what I thought of.  Kids will do > > all kinds of things if they think it will get them high.  Good God, we used > > to sniff Carbona!  (A spot remover, very toxic.)  Airplane glue, Krylon > > spray paint….it’s very scary.  Thanks for the explanation. > The thing is, though, not all kids do this or want to do this.  Kids > abuse substances because of other stuff.  If your kid’s basically OK and > getting what they need at home, chances are extremely good they won’t > get into substance abuse.  Substance abuse is a symptom.

That "you" is a general "you" not a specific "you." Priscilla — "I don’t feel comfortable with a boot with my name on it on the throat of the rest of the world."  – Alan Winston in rec.arts.sf.fandom

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Jette Goldie wrote: > "Priscilla Ballou" <vze23…@verizon.net> wrote in message > news:vze23t8n-379BB3.11035520042003@news.verizon.net… >>In article >><Azyoa.70007$ja4.4654…@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>, >> "Eva" <EvaDStru…@NOatt.net> wrote: >>>"Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message >>>news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… >>>>I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here > in >>>>the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. >>>————- >>>Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? >>*Can* you get high off inhaler meds?  I mean those for asthma. > A lot of asthma inhalers contain steroids.  They can have > a similar effect to "anabolic steroids" if you are into weight > training.  You should see my brother’s physique!  (kung fu > muscles however <g>)

The steroids used for asthma are corticosteroids and as far as I have know they do not have the same effect as anabolic steroids. I am not a medical person, but have either been told this by my doctor or read it somewhere, don’t remember which. sue

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Frankenmel wrote: >>From: "Eva" EvaDStru…@NOatt.net >>Date: 4/20/03 7:57 AM Pacific Daylight Time >>"Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message >>news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… >>>I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in >>>the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. >>————- >>Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? > Yes,I think they use them in addition to crack or something. I heard once and > forgot.

I didn’t know that. sue

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->From: Kevin and Sue Mullen kjmul…@comcast.net >Date: 4/20/03 11:54 AM Pacific Daylight Time >Frankenmel wrote: >>>From: "Eva" EvaDStru…@NOatt.net >>>Date: 4/20/03 7:57 AM Pacific Daylight Time >>>"Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message >>>news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… >>>>I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in >>>>the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. >>>————- >>>Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? >> Yes,I think they use them in addition to crack or something. I heard once >and >> forgot. >I didn’t know that.

That’s what the pharmacies told us. They are even considering putting them behind the counter. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

Kevin and Sue Mullen wrote: > Jette Goldie wrote: >> A lot of asthma inhalers contain steroids.  They can have >> a similar effect to "anabolic steroids" if you are into weight >> training.  You should see my brother’s physique!  (kung fu >> muscles however <g>) > The steroids used for asthma are corticosteroids and as far as I have > know they do not have the same effect as anabolic steroids. I am not a > medical person, but have either been told this by my doctor or read it > somewhere, don’t remember which.

AFAICT, you are correct, Sue. The steroids used to treat asthma are corticosteroids, not anabolic steroids.  Corticosteroids are chemically related to a steroid released by the adrenal glands, cortisol. Anabolic steroids are chemically related to androgens, male sex hormones, which are mostly produced in the testes, a bit in the adrenal glands (in both sexes).  AFAIK, they don’t have similar effects on the body.  If anyone doubts this, read up on the side effects of prednisone, a corticosteroid.   You won’t find "big muscles" – muscle weakness is a common side effect.  Inhaled corticosteroids are given in tiny doses, so they don’t have most of the side effects of oral or injected steroids, but they’re not going to promote muscle growth, either. And Primatene, an OTC rescue inhaler available in the US, contains epinephrine (aka adrenaline), which certainly can give you a buzz – increased heart rate, alertness, sweating, dry mouth, etc.  Not a pleasant buzz, from my point of view, but some might like it. Most prescription rescue inhalers contain albuterol or levalbuterol, which has effects similar to taking adrenaline, by changes it induces in some nerves and bronchial muscle. FurPaw — They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety – B. Franklin To reply, unleash the dog.

Response:

>From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net >Date: 4/20/03 12:33 PM Pacific Daylight Time >And Primatene, an OTC rescue inhaler available in the US, >contains epinephrine (aka adrenaline), which certainly can >give you a buzz – increased heart rate, alertness, sweating, >dry mouth, etc.  Not a pleasant buzz, from my point of view, >but some might like it.

Okay…I’m going to confess. For years,I used Primatene…to save money. I know it was dumb. I regret it. I found the prescription ones didn’t even cost much more,if at all,through drugstore.com. It did give me a sort of buzz and heart race,which I didn’t like. I wish I could turn back the clock,but I can’t. Ah…I feel much better. Bring on the host and the grape juice. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Frankenmel wrote: >>From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net >>Date: 4/20/03 12:33 PM Pacific Daylight Time >>And Primatene, an OTC rescue inhaler available in the US, >>contains epinephrine (aka adrenaline), which certainly can >>give you a buzz – increased heart rate, alertness, sweating, >>dry mouth, etc.  Not a pleasant buzz, from my point of view, >>but some might like it. > Okay…I’m going to confess. For years,I used Primatene…to save money. I know > it was dumb. I regret it. I found the prescription ones didn’t even cost much > more,if at all,through drugstore.com. It did give me a sort of buzz and heart > race,which I didn’t like. I wish I could turn back the clock,but I can’t. > Ah…I feel much better. Bring on the host and the grape juice.

Tell it all, Sharon – it wasn’t the money, it was the buzz! :-) FurPaw — They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety – B. Franklin To reply, unleash the dog.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -FurPaw wrote: > Frankenmel wrote: >>> From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net Date: 4/20/03 12:33 PM Pacific >>> Daylight Time >>> And Primatene, an OTC rescue inhaler available in the US, contains >>> epinephrine (aka adrenaline), which certainly can give you a buzz – >>> increased heart rate, alertness, sweating, dry mouth, etc.  Not a >>> pleasant buzz, from my point of view, but some might like it. >> Okay…I’m going to confess. For years,I used Primatene…to save >> money. I know >> it was dumb. I regret it. I found the prescription ones didn’t even >> cost much >> more,if at all,through drugstore.com. It did give me a sort of buzz >> and heart >> race,which I didn’t like. I wish I could turn back the clock,but I can’t. >> Ah…I feel much better. Bring on the host and the grape juice. > Tell it all, Sharon – it wasn’t the money, it was the buzz! :-)

LOL……..Sharon, as long as you are ok now, that is the important thing….sue

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Priscilla Ballou wrote: > In article > <Azyoa.70007$ja4.4654…@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>, >  "Eva" <EvaDStru…@NOatt.net> wrote: >>"Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message >>news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… >>>I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in >>>the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. >>————- >>Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? > *Can* you get high off inhaler meds?  I mean those for asthma.

I don’t know. In the past when I have use my prescription inhaler more often then prescribed, I have not gotten high. I just got very jittery and my heart started to race. I am talking about broncodilaters(sp), such as ventolin, not steroid inhalers. sue

Response:

Kevin and Sue Mullen wrote: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Eva wrote: >> "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message >> news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… >>> I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in >>> the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. >> ————- >> Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? >> Eva (worried about teenager) > I didn’t even think about that, don’t know if you could get high or not. >  I was thinking more of a person with breathing problems, using an OTC > inhaler and not seeing their doctor. Also of a person using an OTC > inhaler more often then it should be used, causing many side effects. Of > course this could be done with a prescription inhaler also.

I used a nonprescription inhaler (Primatene) *once* – I thought I was having a heart attack afterwards, my chest hurt so badly.  It went directly into the trash.  (oops, should I have recycled it?)  From my experience, it makes it difficult to see how anyone would use nonprescription inhalers, much less abuse them. But maybe I was just lucky that I had such an adverse reaction to it. Sumbitch!  I just looked it up, it is still being sold in the US, and it is made by our old friend, Wyeth. FurPaw — They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety – B. Franklin To reply, unleash the dog.

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Eva wrote: > "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > news:3EA2B782.70703@comcast.net… >>Eva wrote: >>>"Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message >>>news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… >>>>I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in >>>>the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. >>>————- >>>Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? >>>Eva (worried about teenager) >>I didn’t even think about that, don’t know if you could get high or not. >>  I was thinking more of a person with breathing problems, using an OTC >>inhaler and not seeing their doctor. Also of a person using an OTC >>inhaler more often then it should be used, causing many side effects. Of >>course this could be done with a prescription inhaler also. > ———- > Sorry, I saw the word "abuse" and that was what I thought of.  Kids will do > all kinds of things if they think it will get them high.  Good God, we used > to sniff Carbona!  (A spot remover, very toxic.)  Airplane glue, Krylon > spray paint….it’s very scary.  Thanks for the explanation.

Did you see my other post about side effects? When I have used my inhaler more then prescribed, I get very jittery, my heart races and I get palpetations(sp). Now I have a great doctor, who has taught me how to manage my asthma, without having to abuse my inhalers. sue – who used to love Carbona for spots!!

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->From: "Eva" EvaDStru…@NOatt.net >Date: 4/19/03 2:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time >I hadn’t been following the original thread, since GERD doesn’t affect me >(knock wood). >Reading this now, I can’t help but remember the time we were talking about >my cat getting a stuck turd!  You warned me that it could be the first >symptom of kidney failure, based on your personal experience with your cat. >I protested that it was a one-time thing.  You urged me to check with the >vet.  I said I would, but that I didn’t think there was any urgency since it >was a one-time thing.  I said I’d ask the vet at Rosie’s next checkup, which >at that point was a month or two away. >So this must have happened last summer or late spring, and it hasn’t >happened again.  I disagreed with you that it was cause for immediate >concern, but I’m still glad you posted the warning, because if it *had* >continued I don’t think I would otherwise have taken it seriously enough. >Is there a valid analogy here?  Or should I have stayed out of this >altogether?! >Eva

Yes,it is a valid analogy. I hesitated to say it before,but with all the back and forth going on about this controversy,I must say that it was Mary Beth’s (to me) extremely emotional response to my (very intermittent) problem that set off my bells. Mary Beth,with all due respect,I found your extremely lengthy post/s very upsetting. It’s fine and dandy to say to someone if this continues,and if you have stomach acid coming up in your throat,it would be in your best interests to have it checked out. Instead,I read a few posts that went into scary detail about relatives and dire things that went wrong. As I said before,I have a very vivid imagination. Now I do apologize to Jette for urging her to at least carry an inhaler. I was quite alarmed when she described the (can’t remember how she said it) bronchial reaction because to me that *is* a symptom of asthma,regardless of what a doctor might say. It’s a simple matter over here to at least get an OTC inhaler. I don’t see anything scary about it at all. BUT…if you believe,Jette,that you don’t have asthma or can control it,that’s up to you. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

"Frankenmel" <franken…@aol.comnospam> wrote in message

news:20030419231506.19022.00000296@mb-m11.aol.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> >From: "Eva" EvaDStru…@NOatt.net > >Date: 4/19/03 2:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time > >I hadn’t been following the original thread, since GERD doesn’t affect me > >(knock wood). > >Reading this now, I can’t help but remember the time we were talking about > >my cat getting a stuck turd!  You warned me that it could be the first > >symptom of kidney failure, based on your personal experience with your cat. > >I protested that it was a one-time thing.  You urged me to check with the > >vet.  I said I would, but that I didn’t think there was any urgency since it > >was a one-time thing.  I said I’d ask the vet at Rosie’s next checkup, which > >at that point was a month or two away. > >So this must have happened last summer or late spring, and it hasn’t > >happened again.  I disagreed with you that it was cause for immediate > >concern, but I’m still glad you posted the warning, because if it *had* > >continued I don’t think I would otherwise have taken it seriously enough. > >Is there a valid analogy here?  Or should I have stayed out of this > >altogether?! > >Eva > Yes,it is a valid analogy. I hesitated to say it before,but with all the back > and forth going on about this controversy,I must say that it was Mary Beth’s > (to me) extremely emotional response to my (very intermittent) problem that set > off my bells. Mary Beth,with all due respect,I found your extremely lengthy > post/s very upsetting. It’s fine and dandy to say to someone if this > continues,and if you have stomach acid coming up in your throat,it would be in > your best interests to have it checked out. Instead,I read a few posts that > went into scary detail about relatives and dire things that went wrong. As I > said before,I have a very vivid imagination. > Now I do apologize to Jette for urging her to at least carry an inhaler. I was > quite alarmed when she described the (can’t remember how she said it) bronchial > reaction because to me that *is* a symptom of asthma,regardless of what a > doctor might say. It’s a simple matter over here to at least get an OTC > inhaler. I don’t see anything scary about it at all. BUT…if you > believe,Jette,that you don’t have asthma or can control it,that’s up to you. > Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> >From: "Eva" EvaDStru…@NOatt.net > >Date: 4/19/03 2:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time > >I hadn’t been following the original thread, since GERD doesn’t affect me > >(knock wood). > >Reading this now, I can’t help but remember the time we were talking about > >my cat getting a stuck turd!  You warned me that it could be the first > >symptom of kidney failure, based on your personal experience with your cat. > >I protested that it was a one-time thing.  You urged me to check with the > >vet.  I said I would, but that I didn’t think there was any urgency since it > >was a one-time thing.  I said I’d ask the vet at Rosie’s next checkup, which > >at that point was a month or two away. > >So this must have happened last summer or late spring, and it hasn’t > >happened again.  I disagreed with you that it was cause for immediate > >concern, but I’m still glad you posted the warning, because if it *had* > >continued I don’t think I would otherwise have taken it seriously enough. > >Is there a valid analogy here?  Or should I have stayed out of this > >altogether?! > >Eva

If you’re talking about me, nope I did nothing of the kind. I would never. I shared that my dog has gone thru that many times. We were all laughing about going thru this, and my ex DH puking behind the tree as it kept coming out more and more. But these were *hairs* mixed with poop, which will come out on it’s own too, and even pulling that out is no problem. I never said to immediately take it in, but was told by my vet, for hairs and poop coming out at all, it’s totally normal, all of my dogs have gone thru it, the post of mine was about how Rudy, my golden is embarrassed when he does it. <G> Don’t recall any warnings tho, as I don’t usually when I mention this, that if it is a very very long string or the like, to not pull too much out, as the string can be wrapped around in its intestinal tract. Cut it off at the rectum and *check* or rather to be literal about it, *CALL* him, of you think he needs to be seen. with your vet, if you have no idea how long the string is. Of course if you know he got a hold of a foot long bit, it would be fine to get it out, I’m talking looooong pieces But I figured that would be common sense. Not at all what I posted to Sharon. In the same vein as sharing anything that can hurt someone, I’ll still do that, tho not as strongly. MaryBeth Please do not paint me with the same broad brush as what I posted about GERD, Sharon has explained why she got so upset, and I have explained that I didn’t mean to scare her, but did want to warn not only her but anyone reading that there *CAN* not *will be*, can be problems with it. Not to run to the docs, but to have it checked out. To me that’s a mere phone call or a quick office visit. I am not some whacko, like the Little Red Hen, that warns ppl of anything, but did want the word out that GERD has the ability to get worse if not treated.. Since then Sharon has made it clearer than her first post about getting food stuck in her throat, it was then known to be once in a good while, not weekly nor, thank God daily. :) If you feel me doing so then filter me. :/

Response:

"Frankenmel" <franken…@aol.comnospam> wrote > Now I do apologize to Jette for urging her to at least carry an inhaler. I was > quite alarmed when she described the (can’t remember how she said it) bronchial > reaction because to me that *is* a symptom of asthma,regardless of what a > doctor might say. It’s a simple matter over here to at least get an OTC > inhaler. I don’t see anything scary about it at all. BUT…if you > believe,Jette,that you don’t have asthma or can control it,that’s up to

you. Whereas here there is no such thing as an "over the counter inhaler".  They’re all prescription drugs. — Jette "Work for Peace and remain Fiercely Loving" – Jim Byrnes je…@blueyonder.co.uk http://www.jette.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Jette Goldie wrote: > "Frankenmel" <franken…@aol.comnospam> wrote >>Now I do apologize to Jette for urging her to at least carry an inhaler. I > was >>quite alarmed when she described the (can’t remember how she said it) > bronchial >>reaction because to me that *is* a symptom of asthma,regardless of what a >>doctor might say. It’s a simple matter over here to at least get an OTC >>inhaler. I don’t see anything scary about it at all. BUT…if you >>believe,Jette,that you don’t have asthma or can control it,that’s up to > you. > Whereas here there is no such thing as an "over the counter > inhaler".  They’re all prescription drugs.

I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. Anyhow, IMO if you need an inhaler you should be seeing a doctor. sue

Response:

In article <Azyoa.70007$ja4.4654…@bgtnsc05-news.ops.worldnet.att.net>,  "Eva" <EvaDStru…@NOatt.net> wrote: > "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… > > I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in > > the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. > ————- > Abuse them?  You mean, to get high?

*Can* you get high off inhaler meds?  I mean those for asthma. Priscilla — "I don’t feel comfortable with a boot with my name on it on the throat of the rest of the world."  – Alan Winston in rec.arts.sf.fandom

Response:

Eva wrote: > "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > news:3EA2AC6E.8000500@comcast.net… >>I thought that the OTC inhalers were being taken off the market, here in >>the USA. If not, they should be, to many people abuse them. > ————- > Abuse them?  You mean, to get high? > Eva (worried about teenager)

I didn’t even think about that, don’t know if you could get high or not.   I was thinking more of a person with breathing problems, using an OTC inhaler and not seeing their doctor. Also of a person using an OTC inhaler more often then it should be used, causing many side effects. Of course this could be done with a prescription inhaler also. sue

Response:

FurPaw <furpawnews…@comcast.net> wrote in news:3EA06A3D.1060507@comcast.net: > I’m feeling badly that your posts on GERD hit a sour note. > I have it mildly, with no damage (endoscopy with biopsy for > H. pylori, negative) and good response since I started > taking prilosec.  I don’t know if *everything* you said was > accurate, but from what I’ve read, much of it was.  I did > recognize your desire to be helpful. > It sounds like you are going through a lot right now. > And I’m really sorry about your dog.  I don’t remember – > which one is it that is so ill?

You know, Furry, you’re a nice person.  Much nicer than I am.  Just thought you’d like to know.   Chakolate

Response:

>From: Chakolate chakolateDeathToSpammers@hot >You know, Furry, you’re a nice person.  Much nicer than I am.  Just thought >you’d like to know.   >Chakolate

What a nice thing to say. And I agree. Even tho Ms Paw and I don’t always agree, she even gets pissed off at me once in a while, I think she is very cool. <G> AneeBear "We have them surrounded in their tanks" Mohammed Saeed al-Sahaf, Iraqi Minister of Information (currently on administrative leave).

Response:

>Eva" wrote: >Reading this now, I can’t help but remember the time we were talking about >my cat getting a stuck turd!

Geez, Im sorry I missed that one. LOL

Response:

"Thelittlewench" <thelittlewe…@aol.com> wrote in message

news:20030419194318.18955.00000304@mb-m02.aol.com… > >Eva" wrote:

Sorry Eva, middle of the night and having so many post to me about being too leery, I hadn’t read the part about Sharon’s cat, I, with my very large ego, (YEAH, riiiight), thought it was another post to me. So just ignore it :) MaryBeth

Response:

"Frankenmel" <franken…@aol.comnospam> wrote in message

news:20030419004949.18889.00000285@mb-m03.aol.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> >From: "gs" gs2152nos…@charter.net > >Date: 4/18/03 9:15 PM Pacific Daylight Time > >I didn’t take MB’s posts as anything other than concern and giving out > >information. > >I could have taken them the way I did due to my Mom having experienced not > >being able to swallow and letting it go for awhile. > >I seem to remember several posts about asthma and making sure someone knew > >how serious asthma was. > >Gwen > But Gwen,the difficulties I’d (made the mistake of posting)mentioned were such > an intermittent thing. I posted the morning after DH had trouble swallowing dry > cereal. I haven’t had difficulty swallowing for over a year. So do you honestly > see these as something to have an endoscopy for? If we’d had troubles on a > regular basis instead of DH a couple of times eating cereal and me a year and a > half or more ago,then I could see that.

In the beginning, you said it happens every now and then. Especially when eating an apple or bagel. DH has trouble eating cereal some mornings. (or something like that)  I haven’t had a problem swallowing or gerd (except caused by medicine), so I found the MB’s posts to be informative. My Mom had a problem with swallowing and I could have used the information at that time. My Mom’s doctor said she should have come in sooner, (wasn’t cancer).  I wasn’t personally involved in the topic of swallowing or gerd…so my take was different. > Yes,I did express concern about asthma. I don’t really see that someone whose > air passageways close as being equivalent to a couple people who have trouble > swallowing VERY occasionally.

But, the other poster, who said it only happened under certain conditions may have felt the same way. All the replies were how about how serious it was (or could be). Same type of thing. Those who are personally involved react differently. (Personally involved can be any number of things) It can work both ways. That’s all I was saying. I wasn’t saying anyone was right or wrong. Gwen – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

"gs" <gs2152nos…@charter.net> wrote > I seem to remember several posts about asthma and making sure someone knew > how serious asthma was.

Yes, so do I. — Jette "Work for Peace and remain Fiercely Loving" – Jim Byrnes je…@blueyonder.co.uk http://www.jette.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -gs wrote: > "Frankenmel" <franken…@aol.comnospam> wrote in message > news:20030419004949.18889.00000285@mb-m03.aol.com… >>>From: "gs" gs2152nos…@charter.net >>>Date: 4/18/03 9:15 PM Pacific Daylight Time >>>I didn’t take MB’s posts as anything other than concern and giving out >>>information. >>>I could have taken them the way I did due to my Mom having experienced > not >>>being able to swallow and letting it go for awhile. >>>I seem to remember several posts about asthma and making sure someone > knew >>>how serious asthma was. >>>Gwen >>But Gwen,the difficulties I’d (made the mistake of posting)mentioned were > such >>an intermittent thing. I posted the morning after DH had trouble > swallowing dry >>cereal. I haven’t had difficulty swallowing for over a year. So do you > honestly >>see these as something to have an endoscopy for? If we’d had troubles on a >>regular basis instead of DH a couple of times eating cereal and me a year > and a >>half or more ago,then I could see that. > In the beginning, you said it happens every now and then. Especially when > eating an apple or bagel. DH has trouble eating cereal some mornings. (or > something like that) >  I haven’t had a problem swallowing or gerd (except caused by medicine), so > I found the MB’s posts to be informative. My Mom had a problem with > swallowing and I could have used the information at that time. My Mom’s > doctor said she should have come in sooner, (wasn’t cancer). >  I wasn’t personally involved in the topic of swallowing or gerd…so my > take was different. >>Yes,I did express concern about asthma. I don’t really see that someone > whose >>air passageways close as being equivalent to a couple people who have > trouble >>swallowing VERY occasionally. > But, the other poster, who said it only happened under certain conditions > may have felt the same way. All the replies were how about how serious it > was (or could be). > Same type of thing. > Those who are personally involved react differently. (Personally involved > can be any number of things) It can work both ways.

I think that one of the big differences between the gerd/reflus discussion and the asthma discussion, is that MB was speaking as a person with a medical backround. She mentioned her backround and would not further clarify it, which is her right. On the asthmas thread no person claimed to have a medical backround, we only spoke of our experiences and our personal feelings about asthma treatment. sue

Response:

"gs" <gs2152nos…@charter.net> wrote in message

news:va1jgl3iir4f45@corp.supernews.com… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> "Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message > news:3EA0A2F1.1010703@comcast.net… > > Frankenmel wrote: > > >>From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net > > >>Date: 4/18/03 4:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time > > >>I wasn’t thinking just of you, here, Sharon, and of course I > > >>(nor anyone else?) didn’t recognize that button.  Everyone > > >>has their buttons – mine get pushed now and then too.  I > > >>guess I should have realized that something of yours had > > >>been pushed, since your response was pretty uncharacteristic > > >>of you.  It just seemed like several people were jumping on > > >>MB for what was, in her view, an attempt to share her > > >>knowledge and raise a flag about a potentially dangerous > > >>condition.  Even if it doesn’t really apply in your case. > > >>Most everyone’s a bit edgy, it seems.  Me too.  Time to take > > >>a deep breath… :-) > > >>FurPaw > > > I probably interpreted her postings incorrectly. I just got the feeling > that MB > > > was shaking her head,thinking I was a fool for not rushing to the doctor > for an > > > endoscopy. > > Sharon, I felt the say way. I felt that MB was telling me that she was > > right and my doctor is wrong and there was no inbetween. > I didn’t take MB’s posts as anything other than concern and giving out > information. > I could have taken them the way I did due to my Mom having experienced not > being able to swallow and letting it go for awhile.

Thanks Gwen,     I hope it has all died down by now, and I really did mean to share my own experience with EVERYONE , like maybe some lurkers or seldom posters, that this can, operative word there, CAN lead to more serious problems. And the pain that I have gone thru, and especially losing my fave uncle for the same thing, it scares me, and I like to at least make sure ppl take it as serious. I told ppl that if they are having these problem to ‘ask’ their doc, not go in there and demand to do it, but it can’t hurt to ask. And then only IF it is an increasing problem. I would NEVER presume to tell anyone what they have nor what to do, other than direct them to their own docs, just as in the dog groups, I direct sickness and problems to their own vets. No one can diagnose anything on here, they can share, and pray that no one else has to go thru it. I really admire Susan and Sharon, and it just hurt when they thought I was pushing. I’m allbeddarnow, as my nephew used to say. <G> Being fairly crippled from something that could have been fixed years before, when I first complained to my new doctor, (after I fired Dr. Feelgood that ODed me on the Pred.), he kept telling me my knee pain was from my age, at 32!!! My ortho that I saw in SF, said that if this had been caught a couple of years before all of the veins/arteries/etc. had been totally cut off inside my bones I would be up again. I walk, but not for long periods, my walker is my pal. He told me, and ya’ll know how much docs usually NEVER put or talk badly about other docs, but he told me that I had a very good court case, from the doc that ODed the Pred. and the one who told me for two years it was nothing. My part? I should have gone right away for a second opinion, but didn’t. I trusted my doctors. :/ He even offered to go to court for me/or rather along with me. Heck, he had his secretary fill out all the info for SSDI, and I merely signed them in the office. And whatever he told them, they put me on disability for life, never have been checked up on since ‘91. So tho it was great to get it thru so fast, it scared me that it was something that bad. You know? Weird what life gives us.! Funny thing was, after I had the surgeries, and knew the DX, as AVN, every pro I went to, from my PCP, to my OB/GYN, to my Dentist, and yes, even my vet…..all of them immediately asked if it was steroids! They had absolutely no warnings on that back then, and I didn’t have the puter then either. But no insert and many pages I have found on the net NEVER mention bone loss from taking steroids, until maybe the past few years. They never mentioned AVN, at all. Scary!?!?! And being crippled by someone who misdiagnosed me, my EX stopped me from sueing him, as he was getting his drugs form him, unknown to me, and KNOWING for a fact that I didn’t need to be this way, I can’t sit still. Even if I did come across as too harsh, and I understand now why many had a problem, and have apologized. My feeling is that if it helps one person once, I made a difference. I sincerely wasn’t pointing out certain ppl, was meant as a general warning, tho I did specifically answer sue and Sharon about it, it wasn’t meant for them alone. I’m glad it’s gotten better, and for the e-mails I’ve received, thanks so much for the support. And what the hell did I say when I first came back????<DUH> I tend to take most ppl here gently if possible, as I know we’re all in a different place with our hormones all over. Being gentle now, can’t promise tomorrow. <WEG> MaryBeth

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net >Date: 4/18/03 4:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time >I wasn’t thinking just of you, here, Sharon, and of course I >(nor anyone else?) didn’t recognize that button.  Everyone >has their buttons – mine get pushed now and then too.  I >guess I should have realized that something of yours had >been pushed, since your response was pretty uncharacteristic >of you.  It just seemed like several people were jumping on >MB for what was, in her view, an attempt to share her >knowledge and raise a flag about a potentially dangerous >condition.  Even if it doesn’t really apply in your case. >Most everyone’s a bit edgy, it seems.  Me too.  Time to take >a deep breath… :-) >FurPaw

I probably interpreted her postings incorrectly. I just got the feeling that MB was shaking her head,thinking I was a fool for not rushing to the doctor for an endoscopy. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

"FurPaw" <furpawnews…@comcast.net> wrote in message > > I’m sorry if I hurt MB. It was not my intention. I "got it" the first time,and > > I just didn’t want to have it beat into my head. It’s one of my hot

buttons. I’m sorry Sharon, it sincerely was not my intention to hurt your feelings nor push a button. I know, I have my buttons, sexual abuse and rape being about the main ones these last 30 years or so. (Comes and goes with therapy) And my brother in law, banning me from my Godson, Frank, nephew, and his son with my sister, my other nephew Matt. He’s my heart’s love along with Frank, and I am not allowed to talk to them. I found out why tonight, two reasons. He told my mother that I am on serious meds and can’t be *trusted*. That’s button for me, big time. The other reason he tried to take some new wills and his atty to my parent’s house to change their existing ones. Telling them that I will merely use it for drug money!!! I would give the world to never take another pill, I would give the world to be able to walk, and the main thing is, he’s in AA, and NA, and thinks it all pertains to me. I blew up, and I’m sorry. MaryBeth > I wasn’t thinking just of you, here, Sharon, and of course I > (nor anyone else?) didn’t recognize that button.  Everyone > has their buttons – mine get pushed now and then too.  I > guess I should have realized that something of yours had > been pushed, since your response was pretty uncharacteristic > of you.

I really didn’t expect it of you either Sharon, I understand now, but wow I came in and thought it was a great place with all the newer and some older ppl still here. You just seemed so mellow, but as you’ve seen above I blew for other reasons too. It just seemed like several people were jumping on > MB for what was, in her view, an attempt to share her > knowledge and raise a flag about a potentially dangerous > condition.  Even if it doesn’t really apply in your case.

Thanks, you seem to be able tonight to express my thoughts better than I can. For that I am in your debt. :) ) – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Most everyone’s a bit edgy, it seems.  Me too.  Time to take > a deep breath… :-) > FurPaw > — > They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little > temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety – B. > Franklin > To reply, unleash the dog.

Response:

> I probably interpreted her postings incorrectly. I just got the feeling that MB > was shaking her head,thinking I was a fool for not rushing to the doctor for an > endoscopy.

No! Not at all. I just meant if it got worse, as I mentioned mine did. If it was everyday, I suggested not only you, but anyone that had this happen to get it checked out. I didn’t realize it would be a problem with the HMO or push your buttons. I was talking to every one, too. I guess ppl forgot when I mentioned to one of anee’s posts that I can only share what *I* have been thru, no one else. I wouldn’t expect anyone to give me the power to harm them in any way. Sorry again, MB – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

>From: "MaryBeth" marbe…@NOSPAMcomcast.net >Date: 4/18/03 5:26 PM Pacific Daylight Time >Not at all. I just meant if it got worse, as I mentioned mine did. If it >was everyday, I suggested not only you, but anyone that had this happen to >get it checked out. I didn’t realize it would be a problem with the HMO or >push your buttons. I was talking to every one, too. >I guess ppl forgot when I mentioned to one of anee’s posts that I can only >share what *I* have been thru, no one else. I wouldn’t expect anyone to give >me the power to harm them in any way. >Sorry again,

Understood. I just get freaked out easily about health things. Certainly,if I felt I had severe problems,I would have them checked out. It’s not just your posts,I have a history of overreacting to health/fear things. My mind starts going places it’s better not to go. For instance,a friend of mine’s husband is going through something scary right now,and I find myself over-empathizing with what could be wrong. I think it ties in with my panic disorder,and I have to be very careful not to "go there". This post of  mine sounds very confusing. Suffice it to say that things trigger panic things for me,and this discussion started to trigger one of mine. I own my feelings about it. You just got in the middle,MB. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

> Understood. I just get freaked out easily about health things.

Me too, I get a headache, it’s a brain tumor. My doc and others in my field, all remain true to the adage that most of those in the health profession are like that. I can NOT read the adverse reactions on the med info, or I’ll get every one. <G> Certainly,if I > felt I had severe problems,I would have them checked out. It’s not just your > posts,I have a history of overreacting to health/fear things. My mind starts > going places it’s better not to go. For instance,a friend of mine’s husband is > going through something scary right now,and I find myself over-empathizing with > what could be wrong. I think it ties in with my panic disorder,

More alike than I thought, which is what I imagined before all of this. I’ve had panic disorder for about 5 years now, I’m sure it ties in with my health problems, too. and I have to be > very careful not to "go there". This post of  mine sounds very confusing.

No, it doesn’t, not to me. It makes perfect sense. Really, Sharon. > Suffice it to say that things trigger panic things for me,and this discussion > started to trigger one of mine. I own my feelings about it. You just got in the > middle,MB.

Me too, Sharon, glad we ‘figgered’ it out. (oops spelchk anee will be along any time now. <G>) More like ironed it out. Thanks, MB – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

>From: "MaryBeth" marbe…@NOSPAMcomcast.net >Date: 4/18/03 5:55 PM Pacific Daylight Time >I’ve had panic disorder for about 5 years now, I’m sure it ties in with my >health problems, too.

I’ve had them since I was about 16. I know precisely how they started. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

"Frankenmel" <franken…@aol.comnospam> wrote in message

news:20030418210219.02146.00000112@mb-m01.aol.com… > >From: "MaryBeth" marbe…@NOSPAMcomcast.net > >Date: 4/18/03 5:55 PM Pacific Daylight Time > >I’ve had panic disorder for about 5 years now, I’m sure it ties in with my > >health problems, too. > I’ve had them since I was about 16. I know precisely how they started.

Oh  yikes I won’t ask, I may be way off, but it sounds like me, even tho I didn’t take meds back then, I was in need of them. I certainly hope it wasn’t the same reason for you. In e-mail, can I share it. Don’t have a need right now to go into it, but don’t need the trolls from another group to pick it up. MB whenever you feel safe enough let me know. ((((((((Sharon)))))))))

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Frankenmel wrote: >>From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net >>Date: 4/18/03 4:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time >>I wasn’t thinking just of you, here, Sharon, and of course I >>(nor anyone else?) didn’t recognize that button.  Everyone >>has their buttons – mine get pushed now and then too.  I >>guess I should have realized that something of yours had >>been pushed, since your response was pretty uncharacteristic >>of you.  It just seemed like several people were jumping on >>MB for what was, in her view, an attempt to share her >>knowledge and raise a flag about a potentially dangerous >>condition.  Even if it doesn’t really apply in your case. >>Most everyone’s a bit edgy, it seems.  Me too.  Time to take >>a deep breath… :-) >>FurPaw > I probably interpreted her postings incorrectly. I just got the feeling that MB > was shaking her head,thinking I was a fool for not rushing to the doctor for an > endoscopy.

Sharon, I felt the say way. I felt that MB was telling me that she was right and my doctor is wrong and there was no inbetween. sue

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->From: "MaryBeth" marbe…@NOSPAMcomcast.net >Date: 4/18/03 6:03 PM Pacific Daylight Time >"Frankenmel" <franken…@aol.comnospam> wrote in message >news:20030418210219.02146.00000112@mb-m01.aol.com… >> >From: "MaryBeth" marbe…@NOSPAMcomcast.net >> >Date: 4/18/03 5:55 PM Pacific Daylight Time >> >I’ve had panic disorder for about 5 years now, I’m sure it ties in with >my >> >health problems, too. >> I’ve had them since I was about 16. I know precisely how they started. >Oh  yikes I won’t ask, I may be way off, but it sounds like me, even tho I >didn’t take meds back then, I was in need of them. I certainly hope it >wasn’t the same reason for you.

Heck,it’s no biggie..I’ll share. It all started when I was in choir. We had to wear long robes over our clothes,high heels and stand on risers. I developed a fear of passing out and falling in front of an audience,as it was very hot. There was no option to the robes. I wore light clothes underneath but was still hot. Plus we had to stand very still and concentrate. Bright lights on us. It got so bad that I dropped out of honor choir in college. One time we had to be on tv with long-sleeved WOOL dresses under the bright tv lights. It just got worse and worse. So now,the panic slides over into various situations,having nothing to do with being too warm (although being too warm exacerbates it). I don’t drive,relating to panic. I can barely ride in the vehicle,especially on freeways. I got the syndrome really bad in grad school and dropped out. I know I could take meds for it,but I just prefer,right now,to avoid situations that trigger it. Oh,and the thing earlier about health worries? I nearly passed out one time when I accompanied DH to the doctor and he was instructed to have xrays on his spine (mind went crazy with imaginings). Sheesh,huh? Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

In article <b9a1aed02c51907f0d4297adb43d0…@news.teranews.com>,  "MaryBeth" <marbe…@NOSPAMcomcast.net> wrote: > He told my mother that I am on serious meds and can’t be *trusted*. That’s > button for me, big time. > The other reason he tried to take some new wills and his atty to my parent’s > house to change their existing ones. Telling them that I will merely use it > for drug money!!! > I would give the world to never take another pill, I would give the world to > be able to walk, and the main thing is, he’s in AA, and NA, and thinks it > all pertains to me.

Sounds like a serious projection problem.  If he were to ask me (ha!) I would suggest Al-Anon and to focus on his own inventory. Priscilla, 18 years of recovery — "I don’t feel comfortable with a boot with my name on it on the throat of the rest of the world."  – Alan Winston in rec.arts.sf.fandom

Response:

"Kevin and Sue Mullen" <kjmul…@comcast.net> wrote in message news:3EA0A2F1.1010703@comcast.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Frankenmel wrote: > >>From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net > >>Date: 4/18/03 4:35 PM Pacific Daylight Time > >>I wasn’t thinking just of you, here, Sharon, and of course I > >>(nor anyone else?) didn’t recognize that button.  Everyone > >>has their buttons – mine get pushed now and then too.  I > >>guess I should have realized that something of yours had > >>been pushed, since your response was pretty uncharacteristic > >>of you.  It just seemed like several people were jumping on > >>MB for what was, in her view, an attempt to share her > >>knowledge and raise a flag about a potentially dangerous > >>condition.  Even if it doesn’t really apply in your case. > >>Most everyone’s a bit edgy, it seems.  Me too.  Time to take > >>a deep breath… :-) > >>FurPaw > > I probably interpreted her postings incorrectly. I just got the feeling that MB > > was shaking her head,thinking I was a fool for not rushing to the doctor for an > > endoscopy. > Sharon, I felt the say way. I felt that MB was telling me that she was > right and my doctor is wrong and there was no inbetween.

I didn’t take MB’s posts as anything other than concern and giving out information. I could have taken them the way I did due to my Mom having experienced not being able to swallow and letting it go for awhile. I seem to remember several posts about asthma and making sure someone knew how serious asthma was. Gwen – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> sue

Response:

>From: "gs" gs2152nos…@charter.net >Date: 4/18/03 9:15 PM Pacific Daylight Time >I didn’t take MB’s posts as anything other than concern and giving out >information. >I could have taken them the way I did due to my Mom having experienced not >being able to swallow and letting it go for awhile. >I seem to remember several posts about asthma and making sure someone knew >how serious asthma was. >Gwen

But Gwen,the difficulties I’d (made the mistake of posting)mentioned were such an intermittent thing. I posted the morning after DH had trouble swallowing dry cereal. I haven’t had difficulty swallowing for over a year. So do you honestly see these as something to have an endoscopy for? If we’d had troubles on a regular basis instead of DH a couple of times eating cereal and me a year and a half or more ago,then I could see that. Yes,I did express concern about asthma. I don’t really see that someone whose air passageways close as being equivalent to a couple people who have trouble swallowing VERY occasionally. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

Apologies for putting out info on GERD. I wasn’t, (even if it looked like it) pointing out to anyone specific that it is a very serious problem. I was also, IN NO WAY, trying to argue nor put anyone else down. I refuse to reveal what I did for a living, (I am disabled now anyway), as it has caused problems in the past, it is no one’s business, and I only eluded to it to give credence. I would have most likely believed anyone else if they had said same. Perhaps I’m either more trusting or naive, than I thought, which I am glad to see. Ya’ll don’t know me as well as I thought, so I’ll let you be. And it won’t ever be brought up here again, in any case. I was merely trying to use my education and share it. That’s ALL. Sorry if ya’ll didn’t understand that, but it’s not on me, I tried to share a gift, sincerely from me to you. I just tried to pull up as much info to save you from having to go thru it all on the sites. <shrug> I’ve cancelled my posts on all of it, and the rest, tho most before today will probably be googled by now the latest ones are gone. I would sincerely appreciate it if no one reprints them. Thanks, MaryBeth <not in the right place anyway, been trying to focus on my problems, the peri meno, and all that encompasses, to take my mind off of other things. I am going to have to put one of my dog’s down, she rallied a few weeks ago, so we kept her. My mom is about to go from Non Hodgkin’s disease, (cancer), and my father has had his fifth stroke leaving him barely able to get around. They are making up the wills, again, even tho my Dad wanted everything split even, my sis  is contesting it with them, to give her the house, (paid for….because *I* have ‘owned two houses….yeah with large mortgages), not like theirs, and her husband is pissed at me, BANNED me from calling anyone there,  for God knows what, [he didn't get much when his parents died], and wants all of it for my sis and him, and no one in my family will take my calls. All my other relatives are trying to talk to my parents, my mom’s sisters are all wondering what’s up, and not getting thru to anyone. They know I did nothing wrong, and all it is is that they want all of it. I’ve always heard it sucks settling estates, but thought we’d be different. I lurked when I came back here for laughter, found lots of common ground, and felt better , so thanks for that. And to see that I wasn’t all making this meno shit up. I guess I’m in the wrong group, thought it would distract me, instead all it did was piss ppl off.>

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -MaryBeth wrote: > MaryBeth > <not in the right place anyway, been trying to focus on my problems, the > peri meno, and all that encompasses, to take my mind off of other things. I > am going to have to put one of my dog’s down, she rallied a few weeks ago, > so we kept her. My mom is about to go from Non Hodgkin’s disease, (cancer), > and my father has had his fifth stroke leaving him barely able to get > around. They are making up the wills, again, even tho my Dad wanted > everything split even, my sis  is contesting it with them, to give her the > house, (paid for….because *I* have ‘owned two houses….yeah with large > mortgages), not like theirs, and her husband is pissed at me, BANNED me from > calling anyone there,  for God knows what, [he didn't get much when his > parents died], and wants all of it for my sis and him, and no one in my > family will take my calls. All my other relatives are trying to talk to my > parents, my mom’s sisters are all wondering what’s up, and not getting thru > to anyone. They know I did nothing wrong, and all it is is that they want > all of it. I’ve always heard it sucks settling estates, but thought we’d be > different. I lurked when I came back here for laughter, found lots of common > ground, and felt better , so thanks for that. And to see that I wasn’t all > making this meno shit up. I guess I’m in the wrong group, thought it would > distract me, instead all it did was piss ppl off.>

I’m feeling badly that your posts on GERD hit a sour note. I have it mildly, with no damage (endoscopy with biopsy for H. pylori, negative) and good response since I started taking prilosec.  I don’t know if *everything* you said was accurate, but from what I’ve read, much of it was.  I did recognize your desire to be helpful. It sounds like you are going through a lot right now.  I don’t know what to say about your family.  It’s so sad when the (impending) death of one’s parents brings out the worst in their children.  Hubster’s family is going through that now; they regarded themselves as a close-knit family, but that myth has been exploded several times over.  So, seeing what he’s going through I can really sympathize (and remain grateful that I’m an only child). And I’m really sorry about your dog.  I don’t remember – which one is it that is so ill? So here’s a funny, in a wry sort if way – can’t recall if it’s been posted here before:    1. Only in America…… can a pizza get to your house faster than an ambulance. 2. Only in America…… are there handicap parking places in front of a skating rink. 3. Only in America…… do drugstores make the sick walk all the way to the back of the store to get their prescriptions while healthy people can buy cigarettes at the front. 4. Only in America…… do people order double cheese burgers, large fries, and a diet Coke. 5. Only in America…… do banks leave both doors to the vault open and then chain the pens to the counters. 6. Only in America…… do we leave cars worth thousands of dollars in the driveway and put our useless junk in the garage. 7. Only in America…… do we use answering machines to screen calls and then have call waiting so we won’t miss a call from someone we didn’t want to talk to in the first place. 8. Only in America…… do we buy hot dogs in packages of ten and buns in packages of eight. 9. Only in America…… do we use the word ‘politics’ to describe the process so well: Poli’ in Latin meaning ‘many’ and ‘tics’ meaning ‘bloodsucking creatures’. 10. Only in America…… do they have drive-up ATM machines with Braille lettering. FurPaw — They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety – B. Franklin To reply, unleash the dog.

Response:

"FurPaw" <furpawnews…@comcast.net> wrote > So here’s a funny, in a wry sort if way – can’t recall if > it’s been posted here before:

<snip> > 2. Only in America…… are there handicap parking places > in front of a skating rink. <snip> > 4. Only in America…… do people order double cheese > burgers, large fries, and a diet Coke. <snip> > 6. Only in America…… do we leave cars worth thousands of > dollars in the driveway and put our useless junk in the garage. > 7. Only in America…… do we use answering machines to > screen calls and then have call waiting so we won’t miss a > call from someone we didn’t want to talk to in the first place.

Nah, they do those in the UK too <g> — Jette "Work for Peace and remain Fiercely Loving" – Jim Byrnes je…@blueyonder.co.uk http://www.jette.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk/

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net >Date: 4/18/03 2:12 PM Pacific Daylight Time >net> >MaryBeth wrote: >> MaryBeth >> <not in the right place anyway, been trying to focus on my problems, the >> peri meno, and all that encompasses, to take my mind off of other things. I >> am going to have to put one of my dog’s down, she rallied a few weeks ago, >> so we kept her. My mom is about to go from Non Hodgkin’s disease, (cancer), >> and my father has had his fifth stroke leaving him barely able to get >> around. They are making up the wills, again, even tho my Dad wanted >> everything split even, my sis  is contesting it with them, to give her the >> house, (paid for….because *I* have ‘owned two houses….yeah with large >> mortgages), not like theirs, and her husband is pissed at me, BANNED me >from >> calling anyone there,  for God knows what, [he didn't get much when his >> parents died], and wants all of it for my sis and him, and no one in my >> family will take my calls. All my other relatives are trying to talk to my >> parents, my mom’s sisters are all wondering what’s up, and not getting thru >> to anyone. They know I did nothing wrong, and all it is is that they want >> all of it. I’ve always heard it sucks settling estates, but thought we’d be >> different. I lurked when I came back here for laughter, found lots of >common >> ground, and felt better , so thanks for that. And to see that I wasn’t all >> making this meno shit up. I guess I’m in the wrong group, thought it would >> distract me, instead all it did was piss ppl off.> >I’m feeling badly that your posts on GERD hit a sour note.

My mother used to control me,and I’ve had a lifelong problem with people who do more than just suggest something. I don’t have to be hit over the head to "get it". I feel bad that I felt it necessary to ask that MB stop,but it was freaking me out,and I felt as though I was perceptive enough to make my own decision. There are lots of people who have problems that I feel I could help them with. I have a friend who is very overweight and could benefit from both exercise and a dietary change. If she *asked* me about suggestions,I would give them to her. I am worried about her becoming diabetic or developing heart problems,but I respect her enough to let her live her own life. I’m sorry if I hurt MB. It was not my intention. I "got it" the first time,and I just didn’t want to have it beat into my head. It’s one of my hot buttons. Sharon…………Cats, Coffee, Chocolate…vices to live by

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Frankenmel wrote: >>From: FurPaw furpawnews…@comcast.net >>Date: 4/18/03 2:12 PM Pacific Daylight Time >>net> >>MaryBeth wrote: >>>MaryBeth >>><not in the right place anyway, been trying to focus on my problems, the >>>peri meno, and all that encompasses, to take my mind off of other things. I >>>am going to have to put one of my dog’s down, she rallied a few weeks ago, >>>so we kept her. My mom is about to go from Non Hodgkin’s disease, (cancer), >>>and my father has had his fifth stroke leaving him barely able to get >>>around. They are making up the wills, again, even tho my Dad wanted >>>everything split even, my sis  is contesting it with them, to give her the >>>house, (paid for….because *I* have ‘owned two houses….yeah with large >>>mortgages), not like theirs, and her husband is pissed at me, BANNED me >>from >>>calling anyone there,  for God knows what, [he didn't get much when his >>>parents died], and wants all of it for my sis and him, and no one in my >>>family will take my calls. All my other relatives are trying to talk to my >>>parents, my mom’s sisters are all wondering what’s up, and not getting thru >>>to anyone. They know I did nothing wrong, and all it is is that they want >>>all of it. I’ve always heard it sucks settling estates, but thought we’d be >>>different. I lurked when I came back here for laughter, found lots of >>common >>>ground, and felt better , so thanks for that. And to see that I wasn’t all >>>making this meno shit up. I guess I’m in the wrong group, thought it would >>>distract me, instead all it did was piss ppl off.> >>I’m feeling badly that your posts on GERD hit a sour note. > My mother used to control me,and I’ve had a lifelong problem with people who do > more than just suggest something. I don’t have to be hit over the head to "get > it". I feel bad that I felt it necessary to ask that MB stop,but it was > freaking me out,and I felt as though I was perceptive enough to make my own > decision. > There are lots of people who have problems that I feel I could help them with. > I have a friend who is very overweight and could benefit from both exercise and > a dietary change. If she *asked* me about suggestions,I would give them to her. > I am worried about her becoming diabetic or developing heart problems,but I > respect her enough to let her live her own life. > I’m sorry if I hurt MB. It was not my intention. I "got it" the first time,and > I just didn’t want to have it beat into my head. It’s one of my hot buttons.

I wasn’t thinking just of you, here, Sharon, and of course I (nor anyone else?) didn’t recognize that button.  Everyone has their buttons – mine get pushed now and then too.  I guess I should have realized that something of yours had been pushed, since your response was pretty uncharacteristic of you.  It just seemed like several people were jumping on MB for what was, in her view, an attempt to share her knowledge and raise a flag about a potentially dangerous condition.  Even if it doesn’t really apply in your case. Most everyone’s a bit edgy, it seems.  Me too.  Time to take a deep breath… :-) FurPaw — They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety – B. Franklin To reply, unleash the dog.

Response:

Colin Campbell

Question:

Your email message, with the Subject header of: "Information on ADR incident" has been dumped into the trash along with the attached file. Without being opened. Then I suggest that you refrain from asking me for ’support’ for my positions.  I have decided to stop posting long lists of citations to the newsgroup and to send them directly to the person who requested them.

Well Colin, it appears that you  have a comprehension problem. I guess you need a reminder of my reply to your previous post. Re: Herbal interventions in asthma and allergy [ MEDLINE ABSTRACT] I have NEVER asked you to "support your position" on anything, because I simply don’t care what your position is. You jumped on an article I posted over this newsgroup. The article was not directed specifically to you or to any other individual in the group. It was strictly an informational message that I felt may be interesting to some people who read this NG. I  certainly didn’t ask for your opinion on  it. Here is my reply to your previous post, read it again. Path: t2.direct.ca!brick.direct.ca!t2.direct.ca.POSTED!not-for-mail Newsgroups: alt.support.asthma ABSTRACT] X-Newsreader: Forte Free Agent 1.11/32.235 Lines: 33 NNTP-Posting-Host: 216.66.138.170 X-Trace: t2.direct.ca 937292653 216.66.138.170 (Tue, 14 Sep 1999 00:04:13 PDT) Organization: via Internet Direct – http://www.mydirect.com/ Xref: brick.direct.ca alt.support.asthma:185782 Title :     Herbal interventions in asthma and allergy. Author      Bielory L; Lupoli K Address      Asthma and Allergy Research Center, UMDNJ-New Jersey Medical School, Newark     07103-2499, USA. Source      J Asthma, 36(1):1-65 1999 That’s nice.  Do you want me to post the abstract of the article that shows that people who use alternative remedies for asthma are twice as likely to have a life threatening asthma episode?

Post whatever you please, you don’t need my permission and I certainly don’t need yours. You may not like my position on this issue, but we need to have balance.  

Actually Colin, I don’t give a rat’s ass about your position on anything. In the four + years that I’ve been reading this "ASTHMA SUPPORT" NG, I’ve see very few supportive messages from you. The people promoting alternative medicine only mention the (claimed) benefits and keep quiet about the risks.

Regards, Colleen http://persweb.direct.ca/chaugen/kombucha_faq_home.html

Response:

Allen) writes: You jumped on an article I posted over this newsgroup. The article was not directed specifically to you or to any other individual in the group. It was strictly an informational message that I felt may be interesting to some people who read this NG. I  certainly didn’t ask for your opinion on  it.

Anything posted here begs an opinion from anyone who happens along… if you want no responses may I suggest you scrawl your rhetoric in the sand at the water’s edge of some remote seashore at low tide.  What a planet! Sheldon On a recent Night Court rerun, Judge Harry Stone had a wonderful line: "I try to keep an open mind, but not so open that my brains fall out."

Response:

Anything posted here begs an opinion from anyone who happens along… if you want no responses may I suggest you scrawl your rhetoric in the sand at the water’s edge of some remote seashore at low tide.  What a planet! Sheldon

If I could leave my home, I might just do that. However, I can’t. This is how I communicate to the world. Through my computer. So, goodbye everyone, I’m seriously ill. I can’t take this anymore. I thought I could contribute something to this group,however, I find I cannot take the stress caused by some of the people who frequent this NG. Take care, and I wish you all the very best. Love and best wishes, Colleen

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Allen) writes: Anything posted here begs an opinion from anyone who happens along… if you want no responses may I suggest you scrawl your rhetoric in the sand at the water’s edge of some remote seashore at low tide.  What a planet! Sheldon If I could leave my home, I might just do that. However, I can’t. This is how I communicate to the world. Through my computer. So, goodbye everyone, I’m seriously ill. I can’t take this anymore. I thought I could contribute something to this group,however, I find I cannot take the stress caused by some of the people who frequent this NG. Take care, and I wish you all the very best. Love and best wishes, Colleen

Don’t let the door smack yer ass! Sheldon On a recent Night Court rerun, Judge Harry Stone had a wonderful line: "I try to keep an open mind, but not so open that my brains fall out."

Response:

Colin Please do not send me private email. I do not appreciate it, nor do  I accept unrequested private email that bears an attachment from anyone wishing to continue to argue a point from a NG discussion via private email. I am not subscribed to this "SUPPORT" NG to engage in warfare with you or anyone else, the only "thing" I am interested in fighting is my lung disease. I already  have too  much stress in my life and don’t need you or anyone else adding to it.. So please, if you have a report to add to one of the previous threads on this NG, please post it here where we all can all see it. Your email message, with the Subject header of: "Information on ADR incident" has been dumped into the trash along with the attached file. Without being opened. Thank you, Cheers, Colleen

Response:

Your email message, with the Subject header of: "Information on ADR incident" has been dumped into the trash along with the attached file. Without being opened.

Then I suggest that you refrain from asking me for ’support’ for my positions.  I have decided to stop posting long lists of citations to the newsgroup and to send them directly to the person who requested them. "Usenet is like a herd of performing elephants with diarrhea — massive, diffucult to redirect, awe-inspiring, entertaining, and a source of mind boggling amounts of excrement when you least expect it." Gene Spafford 1992

Response:

No, not appropriate.You lost my attention starting now. You have spent too much time with the BUT* folks- you act like them and I am finished. You think I am wrong, but I think your time would be better spent being introspective.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Forgive my optimism, but this aspect (originally having to do with Buteyko) might be useful. A sort of irony of fate. IMHO Buteyko in Soviet Russia  decades ago put his finger on some meaningful aspect of  asthma, but like all quacks has somehow failed to understand what he is doing. For practical purposes it is a tragedy that he ever worried his brains about the disease and so made a career in a totalitarian country. According to recent research by Binks et al. "tightness" (Am. J. Crt. Care Med. 2002, 78-82) and  POD "perception of dyspnea"  (probably the same, see Chest 2002 Jul;122(1):197-201 "Influence of gender and inspiratory muscle training on the perception of dyspnea in patients with asthma" by Weiner et al.) can be treated as a separate part of asthma only concurrent with spasm but not truly caused by it. Weiner does recommend muscle training (SIMT) to overcome the POD to reduce consumption of relievers, more specially for women as having a more intense POD. So one might come to the conclusion that bashing away at POD, at least with SIMT, is reasonably scientific and safe and does not (Weiner assures us, see Chest March 2000) make a patient insensitive to a worsening and possibly life endangering spasm. Instead of offering a sound and properly researched breathing method involving prolonged, continuous sessions as used by monks the Far East, Buteyko decided to try breath holding. This was used in ancient China (see The Primordial Breath, ISBN 0-944558-00-3). Buteyko himself did not suffer from asthma and is said to have a breath hold time of over three minutes. He seems to have missed the point that such extreme exercises, said to prolong life, were intended for healthy Chinese in the distant past. He is however to be credited with restricting tuition in his method, to specially trained persons excluding the highly vociferous common or garden Buteykoists, see http://www.geocities.com/buteykobreathingasia/statement.html (Statement by Dr. B.) "The Buteyko Method appears misleadingly simple to practice. However, there is a specific training on how to apply this method to each individual patient. If this is done incorrectly there could be severe complications and damaging effects on a patient’s health." "I categorically state that it is exceedingly dangerous for patients to be instructed in the Buteyko Method through the medium of video, audio tapes, books, instructions and manuals." So many a frustrated asthmatic fed up with medication and not able to develop a fruitful relationship with a doc may try breath holding and find that he gets relief from POD.  This might be a very small useful achievement.  However, because this form of exercise is not, by all accounts, anything more than a sort of confidence trick, the unfortunate asthmatic is unlikely to make any real progress.  A trial of the method has shown that it does not improve lung function. This seems IMHO to be the tragedy. The patient does not look around and see that there seem to be recognized effective methods for tackling POD like SIMT, zazen and yoga (TM etc.), and also the breath trainer from Intercure (Resperate). These things can be checked on PubMed before consulting a doc, which is obviously necessary. The Buteykoist in his delusion is not able to understand the objections of the medical profession and may read some of the nonsense put out by a certain "Buteyko" website in Australia and become so militant that his unable to get on with docs at all.  The sooner this website is put an end to the better it will be for all! The above comments are intended to be soundly based on research as well as just being personal conviction due to first hand asthma experience. Regards, Richard Friedel That’s a terrible thing to say about someone. Even though I strongly disagree with Colin about a few things, I respect the fact that he’s always there to try and help people and keep the commercial interests at bay in this forum. Jim Quinlan http://www.AsthmaStory.com GO BUC’S !!! Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass!

Response:

Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass!

Any more equestrians?

Response:

Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass!

Actually Colin, this situation you describe might best be managed by breath holding…

Response:

Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass! looks like you managed to show another moron up for what they are, Colin…I love the way the seriously stupid somehow think that if they gratuitously abuse somebody it will cover up for their inability to reason logically and everyone will go around saying how clever they really are…one wonders how these people manage to find the on switch on their computers…but I suppose they probably get a grown up to switch it on for them

Maybe they don’t know how to turn them off….  ;-) — Five Cats

Response:

Been away for a while. Whaddimiss, whaddimiis?! Pete

Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses

ass!

Response:

    Well, THAT was certainly uncalled for. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass!

Response:

    I think my horse would like to have a small discussion with him. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass! Any more equestrians?

Response:

The debating skills of the B people have now beome proverbial. Dennis as a newcomer to the Net seems to be a specially promising new talent. However, sarcasm aside, I for one do wish him good health despite his delusions: Firstly that increasing carbon dioxide by breathing cures asthma – there is no proof, though normal, i. e. higher,  levels of carbon dioxide are an indication of success with asthma treatment. Secondly that the exercises are in any way an intelligent or smart approach to getting a higher level of carbon dioxide in your body – they are a miserable failure, see clinical trial. Other exercises such as zazen or use of the Resperate device (see website) are much more effective and far less strenuous. Thirdly that having more carbon dioxide cures all sorts of diseases. However  D. A. Kregenow et al. ("The lung and carbon dioxide: implications for permissive and therapeutic hypercapnia" (Eur. Respir. J. July 2002, 20: 6-11)) do state that hypercapnia (having supposedly excessive carbon dioxide levels) in the special context of intubation may be useful against barotrauma inflammation.  Whether this would mean effectiveness against inflammation in asthma is an unanswered question, which cannot be answered by the B people, since they insist on doing ineffective masochistic exercises. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass! So this is what buteyko has to offer as evidence of its efficacy.  Thanks for a well-reasoned and temperate discussion of the merits of your theory–it is totally in character.

Response:

I think my horse would like to have a small discussion with him.

O my, please forgive me, but I must break into song, yet once again: A horse is a horse, of course, of course, And no one can talk to a horse of course That is, of course, unless the horse is the famous Special Ed. Go right to the source, stick your head in the horse He’ll give you the answer that you’ll endorse. He’s holding his breath, with Buteyko, of course, Talk to Special Ed. People will yakkity yak a streak and waste your time of day But holding your breath up Special Ed’s bum Tones the rhetoric down some, they say. A horse is a horse, of course, of course, And this one’ll talk ’til his voice is hoarse. You’ve never heard of a talking horse? Well listen to this. "I am Special Ed."

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I think my horse would like to have a small discussion with him. O my, please forgive me, but I must break into song, yet once again: A horse is a horse, of course, of course, And no one can talk to a horse of course That is, of course, unless the horse is the famous Special Ed. Go right to the source, stick your head in the horse He’ll give you the answer that you’ll endorse. He’s holding his breath, with Buteyko, of course, Talk to Special Ed. People will yakkity yak a streak and waste your time of day But holding your breath up Special Ed’s bum Tones the rhetoric down some, they say. A horse is a horse, of course, of course, And this one’ll talk ’til his voice is hoarse. You’ve never heard of a talking horse? Well listen to this. "I am Special Ed."

Heh Heh Kathy

Response:

That’s a terrible thing to say about someone. Even though I strongly disagree with Colin about a few things, I respect the fact that he’s always there to try and help people and keep the commercial interests at bay in this forum. Jim Quinlan http://www.AsthmaStory.com GO BUC’S !!!

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass!

Response:

Forgive my optimism, but this aspect (originally having to do with Buteyko) might be useful. A sort of irony of fate. IMHO Buteyko in Soviet Russia  decades ago put his finger on some meaningful aspect of  asthma, but like all quacks has somehow failed to understand what he is doing. For practical purposes it is a tragedy that he ever worried his brains about the disease and so made a career in a totalitarian country. According to recent research by Binks et al. "tightness" (Am. J. Crt. Care Med. 2002, 78-82) and  POD "perception of dyspnea"  (probably the same, see Chest 2002 Jul;122(1):197-201 "Influence of gender and inspiratory muscle training on the perception of dyspnea in patients with asthma" by Weiner et al.) can be treated as a separate part of asthma only concurrent with spasm but not truly caused by it. Weiner does recommend muscle training (SIMT) to overcome the POD to reduce consumption of relievers, more specially for women as having a more intense POD. So one might come to the conclusion that bashing away at POD, at least with SIMT, is reasonably scientific and safe and does not (Weiner assures us, see Chest March 2000) make a patient insensitive to a worsening and possibly life endangering spasm. Instead of offering a sound and properly researched breathing method involving prolonged, continuous sessions as used by monks the Far East, Buteyko decided to try breath holding. This was used in ancient China (see The Primordial Breath, ISBN 0-944558-00-3). Buteyko himself did not suffer from asthma and is said to have a breath hold time of over three minutes. He seems to have missed the point that such extreme exercises, said to prolong life, were intended for healthy Chinese in the distant past. He is however to be credited with restricting tuition in his method, to specially trained persons excluding the highly vociferous common or garden Buteykoists, see http://www.geocities.com/buteykobreathingasia/statement.html (Statement by Dr. B.) "The Buteyko Method appears misleadingly simple to practice. However, there is a specific training on how to apply this method to each individual patient. If this is done incorrectly there could be severe complications and damaging effects on a patient’s health." "I categorically state that it is exceedingly dangerous for patients to be instructed in the Buteyko Method through the medium of video, audio tapes, books, instructions and manuals." So many a frustrated asthmatic fed up with medication and not able to develop a fruitful relationship with a doc may try breath holding and find that he gets relief from POD.  This might be a very small useful achievement.  However, because this form of exercise is not, by all accounts, anything more than a sort of confidence trick, the unfortunate asthmatic is unlikely to make any real progress.  A trial of the method has shown that it does not improve lung function. This seems IMHO to be the tragedy. The patient does not look around and see that there seem to be recognized effective methods for tackling POD like SIMT, zazen and yoga (TM etc.), and also the breath trainer from Intercure (Resperate). These things can be checked on PubMed before consulting a doc, which is obviously necessary. The Buteykoist in his delusion is not able to understand the objections of the medical profession and may read some of the nonsense put out by a certain "Buteyko" website in Australia and become so militant that his unable to get on with docs at all.  The sooner this website is put an end to the better it will be for all! The above comments are intended to be soundly based on research as well as just being personal conviction due to first hand asthma experience. Regards, Richard Friedel – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – That’s a terrible thing to say about someone. Even though I strongly disagree with Colin about a few things, I respect the fact that he’s always there to try and help people and keep the commercial interests at bay in this forum. Jim Quinlan http://www.AsthmaStory.com GO BUC’S !!! Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass!

Response:

Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass!

Response:

Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses ass!

looks like you managed to show another moron up for what they are, Colin…I love the way the seriously stupid somehow think that if they gratuitously abuse somebody it will cover up for their inability to reason logically and everyone will go around saying how clever they really are…one wonders how these people manage to find the on switch on their computers…but I suppose they probably get a grown up to switch it on for them — eric www.ericjarvis.co.uk "live fast, die only if strictly necessary"

Response:

Certainly a splendid candidate for inserting his head in a dead horses

ass! So this is what buteyko has to offer as evidence of its efficacy.  Thanks for a well-reasoned and temperate discussion of the merits of your theory–it is totally in character.

Response:

Asthma and sex

Question:

sorry to lower the tone but i am a 28 year old male and happily married however my wife does not seem to have much sex drive and i carnt help thinking that maybe this is due to the fact sex  with me is crap as everytime we try i get / suffer from asthma attack. as anyone got any suggestions how i can improve our sex lives with out her doing all the work as this just gets a little boreing for her too please help some one

lots of good stuff in other replies one thing to add…take your time…don’t get into the heavy physical exertion too early, save that for last…by which stage, if it’s gone well up to that point, your partner may be willing to put in most of the effort and keep the inhaler handy where you can grab it without having to completely stop :) — eric www.ericjarvis.co.uk "I am a man of many parts, unfortunately most of them are no longer in stock"

Response:

Sting, who made eyebrow-raising headlines when he announced years ago that he used tantric techniques to prolong sex for up to five hours, has been vocal of yoga’s ability to take sex to profound levels of experience."

No wonder they call him Sting… Lots of people practicing Kundalini have been so successful that they are now living in nice, quiet places where they can be with others like themselves."

Are these nice, quiet places staffed by very friendly, self-actualized orderlies, dressed all in white? Is this what you were looking for?

Sign me up.

Response:

<nothing worthwhile Two things to never take advice from Kolb about 1) Asthma treatment 2) Sex — CBI, MD

Response:

… Viagra works by opening up blood vessels, exactly like CO2 does.  CO2 is necessary for the smooth muscle in the arterioles to relax, just like the smooth muscle in the bronchioles. Peter Kolb BSc(Eng),MSc(Med),CPEng(Biomed) Biomedical Engineer … Totally incorrect statement.  Viagra prolongs the relaxation of smooth arterial muscles thus retaining the blood flow causing erections; it has no effect in "opening up blood vessels."

OK – make that three. — CBI, MD

Response:

<nothing worthwhile Two things to never take advice from Kolb about 1) Asthma treatment 2) Sex

just the two? I’d add 3) marketing 4) Usenet etiquette 5) effective debating technique 6) scientific method 7) the conduct of medical trials in fact I’m not sure there is anything I’d take advice from him about…he’s not even a particularly effective and convincing charlatan — eric "I’m British, deep down I sincerely believe that there isn’t anything that can possibly happen that can’t be best dealt with by having a cup of tea"

Response:

"Sign me up" Can do, but in the retreat in Big Sur how are you going to stay tuned to the stuff here? Better let someone first vet any postings you manage to write between the 5 hour tantra antics. Or were you wanting to be an orderly? Impatiently yours. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Sting, who made eyebrow-raising headlines when he announced years ago that he used tantric techniques to prolong sex for up to five hours, has been vocal of yoga’s ability to take sex to profound levels of experience." No wonder they call him Sting… Lots of people practicing Kundalini have been so successful that they are now living in nice, quiet places where they can be with others like themselves." Are these nice, quiet places staffed by very friendly, self-actualized orderlies, dressed all in white? Is this what you were looking for? Sign me up.

Response:

"Sign me up" Can do, but in the retreat in Big Sur how are you going to stay tuned to the stuff here?

This is the ultimate dilemma, to be sure. Better let someone first vet any postings you manage to write between the 5 hour tantra antics.

"Let the vettings begin…" Or were you wanting to be an orderly?

Since I’m more prone to be disorderly, I think I’ll pass…out! Impatiently yours.

You really should see someone about that…

Response:

Clinical trials show that the so-called Buteyko method ("carbon dioxide is a cure-all") does not scientifically treat asthma. There are effective breathing methods, such as yoga and SIMT,

Got some pointers?  I’d like to try some proven breathing exercises in addition to the cromolyn and brochodilator inhalers. Thanks, Katherine

Response:

Clinical trials show that the so-called Buteyko method ("carbon dioxide is a cure-all") does not scientifically treat asthma. There are effective breathing methods, such as yoga and SIMT, Got some pointers?  I’d like to try some proven breathing exercises in addition to the cromolyn and brochodilator inhalers.

Breathing exercises will not do very much to treat airways inflammation and bronchospasm. Cromyln is a ‘mast cell stabilizer’ that is not a real effective means of controlling asthma.  You might be better off if you switched to an inhaled steroid such as Pulmicort or Flovent. If your asthma is allergy related, you should get allergy testing done then take measures to limit your exposure to those things which you react to. — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

tell you doctor that you are suffering from exercise induced asthma.   sex is exercise if we are doing it right ;)   Carolyn in Ont Canada

I frequently forget to take salbutamol (albuterol) before engaging in sex. I know I’m doing it right if I have to stop part way through to use my inhaler! When explained this way, your partner should be sympathetic; it’s a kind of complement, as in "Ooh baby, you got me so hot I had an asthma attack!" All of the messages on this thread, including this one, assume exercise induced asthma. It’s probably worth considering allergic causes too, which may require different treatment. Putting this as delicately as I can, it is not unheard of for people to be allergic to their partner’s bodily fluids, but this is less common than allergy to bedding and the tiny creatures who live in it.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – sorry to lower the tone but i am a 28 year old male and happily married however my wife does not seem to have much sex drive and i carnt help thinking that maybe this is due to the fact sex  with me is crap as everytime we try i get / suffer from asthma attack. as anyone got any suggestions how i can improve our sex lives with out her doing all the work as this just gets a little boreing for her too please help some one That’s very easy to fix. No, a TV dinner is easy to fix. Once you are aware that by stifling your breathing and developing a feeling of a slight shortage of air, you can do a lot for yourself. Peter, do you have this problem, and if so, what do you define as doing "a lot for yourself"? He’s holding his breath because he isn’t getting any–that ultimately leads to his having to sit down and "do a lot for himself".

Sit down, then fall down. "If you don’t stand for something, you’ll fall for anything."

Response:

Clinical trials show that the so-called Buteyko method ("carbon dioxide is a cure-all") does not scientifically treat asthma. There are effective breathing methods, such as yoga and SIMT, which are backed by trials noted in PubMed.   Touting an ineffective and simplistic method is irresponsible, antisocial and reflects on the character of the perpetrator.  See postings by "secret squirrel" on this, f. i. http://www.geocities.com/HotSprings/Villa/6249/pklib/peterkolb1996.html. Richard Friedel – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –

Response:

seems im still none the wiser though  i dont get out of breath becauseim errect im not alergic to my partner.. its the actuale physical excersize i have the trouble with. ive spoke with me doctors and he just sugest more foreplay and her doing all the work.. but thanks for all your help anyway …  and viagra is the last thing i need hehehehe

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – sorry to lower the tone but i am a 28 year old male and happily married however my wife does not seem to have much sex drive and i carnt help thinking that maybe this is due to the fact sex  with me is crap as everytime we try i get / suffer from asthma attack. as anyone got any suggestions how i can improve our sex lives with out her doing all the work as this just gets a little boreing for her too please help some one Go discuss this with your doctor.  It sounds like your asthma is not as well controlled as it could be. — Five Cats

Response:

See article on asthma: "Yoga, particularly hatha and kundalini, is another popular method of increasing  long-term lung function. Along with its  emphasis on deep breathing, yoga increases  strength and flexibility, making it a great  type of exercise for people with asthma." (http://test.bagus.org/medical/asthma/seek/info.selfcare.html) "Sexual performance – Some yoga forms, notably the tantric subset of kundalini yoga, employ special exercises to develop and balance the sexual organs. Sting, who made eyebrow-raising headlines when he announced years ago that he used tantric techniques to prolong sex for up to five hours, has been vocal of yoga’s ability to take sex to profound levels of experience." (http://www.usatoday.com/life/health/doctor/lhdoc109.htm) And: "K is for KUNDALINI. KUNDALINI is a serpent of energy curled up at the base of the spine, which rises when one meditates on it. When one gets really good at it, the Kundalini comes all the way up the spine, frazzles the brain, and leaps out the top. This is considered very desirable by people who practice Kundalini. Lots of people practicing Kundalini have been so successful that they are now living in nice, quiet places where they can be with others like themselves." (http://www.inspiredliving.com/humor/humor_newage.htm) Is this what you were looking for? – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – sorry to lower the tone but i am a 28 year old male and happily married however my wife does not seem to have much sex drive and i carnt help thinking that maybe this is due to the fact sex  with me is crap as everytime we try i get / suffer from asthma attack. as anyone got any suggestions how i can improve our sex lives with out her doing all the work as this just gets a little boreing for her too please help some one

Response:

Hi You could (after checking with your doctor), use the same treatment as asthmatic athletes use  when they have exercise induced asthma. I’ll let your doctor (or better yet, your pumonologist… if your asthma is this bad, you really need to be seeing a specialist… In my opinion anyway) advise you on the proper procedures. It sounds like step one will be to get you asthma under control first. What sort of treatment are you on now? We may have some suggestions you can make to your doctor. Dan Rhea "Loyalty is for family, friends and country, not operating systems, compilers and computers"   – Dan Rhea, 1986

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – seems im still none the wiser though  i dont get out of breath becauseim errect im not alergic to my partner.. its the actuale physical excersize i have the trouble with. ive spoke with me doctors and he just sugest more foreplay and her doing all the work.. but thanks for all your help anyway …  and viagra is the last thing i need hehehehe Menni$ sorry to lower the tone but i am a 28 year old male and happily married however my wife does not seem to have much sex drive and i carnt help thinking that maybe this is due to the fact sex  with me is crap as everytime we try i get / suffer from asthma attack. as anyone got any suggestions how i can improve our sex lives with out her doing all the work as this just gets a little boreing for her too please help some one Go discuss this with your doctor.  It sounds like your asthma is not as well controlled as it could be. — Five Cats

Response:

That’s very easy to fix. Your bronchioles won’t go into spasm unless they are over-ventilated. We are prone to hyperventilate during sex.  Once you are aware that by stifling your breathing and developing a feeling of a slight shortage of air, you can do a lot for yourself.   Incidentally, the same consequence of hyperventilation, viz spasm of smooth muscle,  can lead to impotence or just erectile weakeness. Viagra works by opening up blood vessels, exactly like CO2 does.  CO2 is necessary for the smooth muscle in the arterioles to relax, just like the smooth muscle in the bronchioles.

Just remember that Kolb thinks that asthma is caused by hyperventilation.   This is a theory that was shot down when it was first introduced in the 1950s and has never been proven scientifically. Also remember that Kolb and his fellows refuse to modify the theory to account for new discoveries made into the nature of asthma that have occurred since then. "In every generation, the world has produced enemies of human freedom. They have attacked America because we are freedom’s home and defender. And the commitment of our fathers is now the calling of our time." President George W. Bush, Sept 14, 2001

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – sorry to lower the tone but i am a 28 year old male and happily married however my wife does not seem to have much sex drive and i carnt help thinking that maybe this is due to the fact sex  with me is crap as everytime we try i get / suffer from asthma attack. as anyone got any suggestions how i can improve our sex lives with out her doing all the work as this just gets a little boreing for her too please help some one That’s very easy to fix. No, a TV dinner is easy to fix. Once you are aware that by stifling your breathing and developing a feeling of a slight shortage of air, you can do a lot for yourself. Peter, do you have this problem, and if so, what do you define as doing "a lot for yourself"?

He’s holding his breath because he isn’t getting any–that ultimately leads to his having to sit down and "do a lot for himself".

Response:

… Viagra works by opening up blood vessels, exactly like CO2 does.  CO2 is necessary for the smooth muscle in the arterioles to relax, just like the smooth muscle in the bronchioles. Peter Kolb BSc(Eng),MSc(Med),CPEng(Biomed) Biomedical Engineer …

Totally incorrect statement.  Viagra prolongs the relaxation of smooth arterial muscles thus retaining the blood flow causing erections; it has no effect in "opening up blood vessels." "In response to sexual excitement, the parasympathetic nerves in the penis release nitric oxide which stimulates the enzyme guanylate cyclase to produce cyclic GMP. Cyclic GMP relaxes arterial smooth muscle. Cyclic GMP is then broken down by a specific enzyme in the penis called phosphodiesterase type 5. Viagra

do meds let you endure triggers?

Question:

I’ve got comparatively mild asthma; I use my albuterol perhaps every other day, which I’d like to reduce, but it’s already down quite a bit since I began Advair (it took me a long time to find a doctor who’d prescribe an inhaled steroid, even when I was using albuterol many times a day).  I’ve noticed that my exercise-induced symptoms are completely gone, which is wonderful.  However, I can still give myself an attack by laughing too hard, and by cleaning the apartment.  These are activities I can’t exactly give up.  I’ve never been to an emergency room for my asthma or taken oral steroids.  Since I began treatment, I’ve never had an attack that brought me below about 70% of my maximum peak flow, but I have had a couple that brought me down that low and refused to let up for some time, which was unpleasant enough.  I’ve been on Advair about six months.   My question is.. should I be expecting better?  Does having control of asthma mean you can laugh in the face of your triggers (or at least that you can vacuum the living room)?  I expect a little reaction when I run into heavy dust, but I’d like to be able to at least watch Mystery Science Theatre without clutching my albuterol.   Could I reasonably expect that if I bumped up to the next dose of Advair (I’m on the 100/50, the lowest) that it should offer some improvement?  Does doubling the Flovent portion sound like overkill?  I know I could get the inhalers separately, but I really like the convenience (and the single copay) of Advair.   Strictly speaking, I think I should be on more meds because I am using the reliever several times a week (I sometimes go a day without, but almost never two).  But I’m wondering if anything will stop the reaction from laughing, or from breathing cold air.  Yes, I hope.  

Response:

My question is.. should I be expecting better?  Does having control of asthma mean you can laugh in the face of your triggers (or at least that you can vacuum the living room)?  I expect a little reaction when I run into heavy dust, but I’d like to be able to at least watch Mystery Science Theatre without clutching my albuterol.   Could I reasonably expect that if I bumped up to the next dose of Advair (I’m on the 100/50, the lowest) that it should offer some improvement?  Does doubling the Flovent portion sound like overkill?  I know I could get the inhalers separately, but I really like the convenience (and the single copay) of Advair.  

Yes, you should be expecting better.  Current asthma treatment doctrine is to start off with high dosage medications in order to get the asthma firmly under control, then to taper down to the lowest dose that still maintains full control. It would probably be best if you asked for a referral to an asthma specialist. Strictly speaking, I think I should be on more meds because I am using the reliever several times a week (I sometimes go a day without, but almost never two).  But I’m wondering if anything will stop the reaction from laughing, or from breathing cold air.  Yes, I hope.  

Sounds like your asthma is not being properly maintained.  Ask for a referral to an asthma specialist. "…there is always a well-known solution to every human problem–neat, plausible, and wrong."    H. L. Mencken

Response:

<snip I’ve noticed that my exercise-induced symptoms are completely gone, which is wonderful.  However, I can still give myself an attack by laughing too hard, and by cleaning the apartment.  These are activities I can’t exactly give up.  <snip My question is.. should I be expecting better?  <snip Could I reasonably expect that if I bumped up to the next dose of Advair (I’m on the 100/50, the lowest) that it should offer some improvement?  <snip Strictly speaking, I think I should be on more meds because I am using the reliever several times a week (I sometimes go a day without, but almost never two).  But I’m wondering if anything will stop the reaction from laughing, or from breathing cold air.  Yes, I hope.

Yes, and no. To some extent the avoidance of triggers is part of the treatment and the goal of treatment is not to let you flaunt your asthma in the face of known triggers. Having said that, it does sound like you are not quite there yet. I would say that if the only time you wheezed was when you encountered heavy dust, as when vacuuming, then this would be well controlled and you should arrange to vacuum less. Not being able to sit through a funny TV show is another matter. You are on the lowest (some would say pediatric) dose of Advair. Unless there are some things you haven’t told us then it certainly sounds like it would be worthwhile to increase it to at least a middle (adult) dose. If you are still not well controlled and for some reason the docs don’t want to go up to the 500ug dose then they should be able to add another agent like Singulair/Accolate or Tilade/Intal or, as a last resort, even theophylline. You have not given us any reason to suggest that the agents should be split into two inhalers. I am curious about why your docs have been so reluctant to prescribe an inhaled steroid. Is it that you smoke and they have been pushing for you to stop this first (and it may not be as clearly indicated) or is there some other element of your history? If not, then I would agree with Colin that they are not practicing within the accepted standards and referral may be warranted. If so, then it still may be warranted as a more complicated case. Good luck, CBI, MD

Response:

 I’ve noticed that my exercise-induced symptoms are completely gone, which is wonderful.  However, I can still give myself an attack by laughing too hard, and by cleaning the apartment.

Colin and CBI have given good advice, and I, too, would advise you to see a specialist. A couple of additional notes: if vacuuming bothers you, there are a couple of additional options. The first is to get a vacuum with a HEPA filter, the second is to wear a dust mask while vacuuming. Joan

Response:

I am curious about why your docs have been so reluctant to prescribe an inhaled steroid. Is it that you smoke and they have been pushing for you to stop this first (and it may not be as clearly indicated) or is there some other element of your history? If not, then I would agree with Colin that they are not practicing within the accepted standards and referral may be warranted. If so, then it still may be warranted as a more complicated case.

No, I’ve never smoked, and my history is pretty simple.  I’ve had exercise-induced symptoms since I was a child, though I didn’t know this until I had allergy-related attacks as an adult (all my gym teachers must have assumed I was just really out of shape).  Then I started wheezing one winter (age 24 or so) while closed up in my dorm room with my rats.  I no longer keep rats, because my lungs can’t handle it.   My doctors have never seemed to take my asthma seriously, though; I suspect it’s because my attacks are rarely severe.  My first doctor gave me ventolin and sent me on my way.  Other doctors have been unconcerned as long as I wasn’t using the ventolin more than once every four hours. If I told them I was using it 3-4 times a day, they didn’t have a problem with that.  I walked into a doctor’s office with a peak flow of 425; he dismissed it as normal for my height/age/whatever.  My normal is 550-575.   Actually, my current doctor’s been the most aggressive.  She got me on Serevent right away, and when I admitted to still using my albuterol more than a few times a week she went for the Advair.  I’ve also got diabetes, and our office visits generally focus on that, which may be the biggest distractor.  At our next visit I’ll be sure to spend some time on the asthma, and hope to bump up the Advair.  Resolving the EIA has been miraculous — I’m hiking all over the place now (which is good for diabetes too).  I just still feel like I don’t exactly have ironclad control.  For what I’ve always been told is a comparatively mild case, I’d hoped for better.  We’ll see what happens at my next office visit. Thanks for the advice.

Response:

Actually, my current doctor’s been the most aggressive.  She got me on Serevent right away, and when I admitted to still using my albuterol more than a few times a week she went for the Advair.

Serevent is not intended to be used by itself.  It is intended as an ‘add on’ treatment to some from of anti-inflammitory medication. Serevent is nothing more than a version of albuterol that lasts 12 hours.  As such it has the same problem that albuterol has – it only treats a symptom while doing nothing to control the underlying disease. — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

 My doctors have never seemed to take my asthma seriously, though; I suspect it’s because my attacks are rarely severe.  My first doctor gave me ventolin and sent me on my way.  Other doctors have been unconcerned as long as I wasn’t using the ventolin more than once every four hours. If I told them I was using it 3-4 times a day, they didn’t have a problem with that.  I walked into a doctor’s office with a peak flow of 425; he dismissed it as normal for my height/age/whatever.  My normal is 550-575.

This is not the accepted standard of care. — CBI, MD

Response:

My question is.. should I be expecting better?  Does having control of asthma mean you can laugh in the face of your triggers (or at least that you can vacuum the living room)?  

You should be HOPING for better, but you can’t always EXPECT better. The goal of asthma management is:  No interference with a normal life: work, play, etc. Unfortunately, not everyone reaches that goal.  I sure haven’t.  My life is significantly impaired.  The reason is that I have chronic sinusitis (which my doctors disagree is infectious or not), and that acts as a kind of permanent asthma trigger for me.   I don’t think most asthmatics can laugh in the face of respiratory infections, acute or chronic. — Steven D. Litvintchouk                  

Response:

yes. i have mild exercise induced, and worse fragrance induced.  since taking singular, i don’t have to hold my breath walking thru perfume section of stores.  i used to get very tight chested if i didn’t make it thru or was otherwised forces to breath in (most) fragrances.

Response:

bloodletting/erythrocytosis

Question:

I find it kind of hard to believe that there is such a reaction to the mention of phlebotomy / iron depletion in this ng. Since polycythemia .. high red blood cell count .. erythrocytosis is VERY common in those with asthma and bronchitis and copd. Theophylline .. IS .. a treatment for erythrocytosis .. and is extensively used in asthma .. I guess it is just the messenger .. eh .. Who loves ya. Tom — Jesus was a Vegetarian! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman Moses was a Mystic! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman/light.html

Response:

I find it kind of hard to believe that there is such a reaction to the mention of phlebotomy / iron depletion in this ng. Since polycythemia .. high red blood cell count .. erythrocytosis is VERY common in those with asthma and bronchitis and copd. Theophylline .. IS .. a treatment for erythrocytosis .. and is extensively used in asthma .. I guess it is just the messenger .. eh ..

What makes you so sure that this means anything?   "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god."   Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

What makes you so sure that this means anything?  

Logic .. Try it sometime .. Who loves ya. Tom — Jesus was a Vegetarian! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman Moses was a Mystic! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman/light.html

Response:

Tom How many newsgroups do you have on your list to hassle?  Must be in the hundreds to obtain the level of idiocy that you have achieved. Congratulations. You need to ‘iron’ out your obvious problems. Can you say ‘kill file?’

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – What makes you so sure that this means anything? Logic .. Try it sometime .. Who loves ya. Tom — Jesus was a Vegetarian! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman Moses was a Mystic! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman/light.html

Response:

Tom How many newsgroups do you have on your list to hassle?  

Hey .. Jan .. Can you count .. ? And then some ..    http://www.wws.princeton.edu/cgi-bin/byteserv.prl/~ota/disk3/1983/8318    /831804.PDF.    Apheresis       Table I.-Reported Use of Therapeutic Apheresis    Acute necrotizing hemorrhagic encephalomyelitis    Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis    Acute post-streptococcal glomerulonephritis    Acute rheumatic fever    Addison’s disease    Adenocarcinoma of the colon    Adenocarcinoma of the breast    Allergic granulomatosis and angiitis    Amyloidosis    Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)    Ankylosing spondylitis    Aplastic anemia    Atopic dermatitis    Atrophic gastritis type A    Autoimmune infertility & gonadal insufficiency    Autoimmune hemolytic anemia (AIHA)    Autoimmune hypogammaglobulinemia    Autoimmune neutropenia    Behcet’s syndrome    Bone marrow transplant    Bronchial asthma    Bronchogenic carcinoma    Bullous pemphigoid    Cardiac allograft rejection    Chronic membranoproliferative hypocomplementemic    glomerulonephritis    Chronic active hepatitis    Circulating anticoagulant (Anti-Factor Vlll)    Cold agglutinins    Colon carcinoma    Crohn’s disease    Cryogenic fibrosing alveolitis    Cryoglobulinemia    Cutaneous vasculitis    Dermatitis herpetiformis    Dermatomyositis    Discoid lupus erythematosus    Disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC)    Dressier’s syndrome    Eaton-Lambert syndrome    Endomyocardial fibrosis    Erythema multiform    Fabry’s disease    Felty’s syndrome    Gastric carcinoma    Gaucher’s disease    Giant cell arteritis    Glomerulonephritis in subacute bacterial endocarditis    Goodpasture’s syndrome    Graft versus host disease    Graves’ disease    Graves’ ophthalmopathy    Guillain-Barre syndrome    Acute    Chronic    Relapsing    Hashimoto’s thyroiditis    Hemolytic uremic syndrome    Henoch-Schonlein purpura    Hepatic coma    Herpes gestations    Hodgkins disease    Hypercholesterolemia    Hyperglobulinemic purpura    Hypersensitivity pneumonitis    Hypersensitivity angiitis    Hypertension    Hypertriglyceridemia    Hyperviscosity syndrome    Idiopathic membranous glomerulopathy    Idiopathic thrombocytopenic purpura (ITP)    Idiopathic hypoparathyroidism    Insulin resistant diabetes mellitus due to    anti-receptor antibody    Juvenile onset diabetes mellitus    Lipoid nephrosis    Lymphomas    Malignant melonoma    Mixed connective tissue disease    Multiple sclerosis    Multiple myeloma    Myasthenia gravis    Necrotizing cutaneous angitis    Neuroblastoma    Other neoplasms    Pemphigus vulgaris    Pernicious anemia    Poisoning or overdose (paraquat, mushroom, digitalis)    Polyarteritis nodosa    Polymyositis    Post-transfusion purpura    Primary cardiomyopathy    Primary biliary cirrhosis    Proliferative/membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis    Psoriasis    Pure red cell aplasia    Rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis    Raynaud’s disease    Refsum’s syndrome    Reiter’s disease    Renal allograft rejection    Reye’s syndrome    Rhesus iso-immunization    Rheumatoid arthritis    Sarcoidosis    Scleroderma    Sjogren’s syndrome    Subacute bacterial endocarditis    Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE)    Takayasu’s arteritis    Thrombotic thrombocytopenic purpura (lTP)    Thyroid storm    Ulcerative colitis    Viral hepatitis    Waldenstrom’s macroglobulinemia    Wegener’s granulomatosis    White cell isoantibodies Who loves ya. Tom — Jesus was a Vegetarian! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman Moses was a Mystic! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman/light.html

Response:

    Colin, have you ever determined if Tom has *any* disease whatsoever that would make him a good candidate as participant in this group, or if he is just a pest?

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I find it kind of hard to believe that there is such a reaction to the mention of phlebotomy / iron depletion in this ng. Since polycythemia .. high red blood cell count .. erythrocytosis is VERY common in those with asthma and bronchitis and copd. Theophylline .. IS .. a treatment for erythrocytosis .. and is extensively used in asthma .. I guess it is just the messenger .. eh .. What makes you so sure that this means anything? "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god." Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

please provide references regarding high red blood cell count and asthma, and treatment "extensively used in asthma .."

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I find it kind of hard to believe that there is such a reaction to the mention of phlebotomy / iron depletion in this ng. Since polycythemia .. high red blood cell count .. erythrocytosis is VERY common in those with asthma and bronchitis and copd. Theophylline .. IS .. a treatment for erythrocytosis .. and is extensively used in asthma .. I guess it is just the messenger .. eh .. Who loves ya. Tom — Jesus was a Vegetarian! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman Moses was a Mystic! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman/light.html

Response:

I find it kind of hard to believe that there is such a reaction to the mention of phlebotomy / iron depletion in this ng. Since polycythemia .. high red blood cell count .. erythrocytosis is VERY common in those with asthma and bronchitis and copd. Theophylline .. IS .. a treatment for erythrocytosis .. and is extensively used in asthma .. I guess it is just the messenger .. eh ..

No. It’s because most of us have decided that mainstream science offers the best hope for successful treatment of asthma. This is the last reply from me that you will ever see. Welcome to my killfile. — Steven D. Litvintchouk                  

Response:

What makes you so sure that this means anything?   Logic ..

No, this is not ‘logic.’  You are guessing and _assuming_ that there is a connection without any evidence of a connection. Try it sometime ..

I have read up on logic.  Enough to know that you have not. "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god."   Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

     Table I.-Reported Use of Therapeutic Apheresis

Just because it is ‘reported’ does not mean that it worked or that it is a good idea.  (Or that it even really happened that way.) There are a couple of books you need to read: "How to think straight" by Antony Flew "Voodoo Science" by Robert Park "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god."   Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

The VA has a bad reputation for selecting the cheapest medications rather than the ones the patient needs.

I have experienced this but I have my regular doctor give me a prescription and mark no substitutions. I carry it to the VA doctor and have her mark the same thing with very few problems. If I have a problem,I go up the ladder one step at a time until I get what my regular doctor prescribed. I just don’t let them dictate to me against my regular doctors advice. They don’t like it but so what?

Response:

    I know that feeling all too well… I have a cardio stress test in the morning at the VA. Should I study? ;-)

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –    I have to use the VA, Colin. You get to see the doctors when they are available…..usually a couple of months after you have a problem. Right now, all they want to do is give me more inhalers, and wait until my regular appointment next month.    As it is, I’ve had to import my medications for thyroid because the doc they gave me cancelled my medications in favor of those that failed to work well in 3 years. I had a choice of continuing to call my regular doctor in Florida and have him write a new prescription, or use the meds the VA was willing to give and don’t work, or import them ( which worked out to be as little as if I had used the medical insurance…about $3 a month ). The VA has a bad reputation for selecting the cheapest medications rather than the ones the patient needs. I was dealing with the VA for my asthma for a time when I was without health insurance but decided to pay for a doctor out of my own pocket because I did not feel that they were doing a good job. "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god." Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

   Thanks. It was beginning to feel as though I was beating myself up using it.

I really do recommend that you see your doctor about this.  Two times a day is a lot. "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god."   Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

   Well, you are in good company. I noticed he didn’t want to mention his arsenic argument after another individual and I covered it quite thoroughly.

If you are talking to me .. keep your bull to yourself .. You NEVER talked to me about arsenic .. So .. just like everything else you have ever said to me in any post .. if is bull .. I don’t run from nobody .. dickhead .. never have .. never will .. So .. seeing you have a problem which goes much deeper than any medical posts I have made .. once again .. let me tell you to .. S.T.F.A.F.M .. Who loves ya. Tom — Jesus was a Vegetarian! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman Moses was a Mystic! http://www.nucleus.com/watchman/light.html

Response:

    I have to use the VA, Colin. You get to see the doctors when they are available…..usually a couple of months after you have a problem. Right now, all they want to do is give me more inhalers, and wait until my regular appointment next month.     As it is, I’ve had to import my medications for thyroid because the doc they gave me cancelled my medications in favor of those that failed to work well in 3 years. I had a choice of continuing to call my regular doctor in Florida and have him write a new prescription, or use the meds the VA was willing to give and don’t work, or import them ( which worked out to be as little as if I had used the medical insurance…about $3 a month ).

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –    Thanks. It was beginning to feel as though I was beating myself up using it. I really do recommend that you see your doctor about this.  Two times a day is a lot. "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god." Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

   I have to use the VA, Colin. You get to see the doctors when they are available…..usually a couple of months after you have a problem. Right now, all they want to do is give me more inhalers, and wait until my regular appointment next month.    As it is, I’ve had to import my medications for thyroid because the doc they gave me cancelled my medications in favor of those that failed to work well in 3 years. I had a choice of continuing to call my regular doctor in Florida and have him write a new prescription, or use the meds the VA was willing to give and don’t work, or import them ( which worked out to be as little as if I had used the medical insurance…about $3 a month ).

The VA has a bad reputation for selecting the cheapest medications rather than the ones the patient needs. I was dealing with the VA for my asthma for a time when I was without health insurance but decided to pay for a doctor out of my own pocket because I did not feel that they were doing a good job.   "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god."   Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

   Well, you are in good company. I noticed he didn’t want to mention his arsenic argument after another individual and I covered it quite thoroughly.    BTW, is it unusual to use the Albuterol more than twice a day? I can get by without out it, but I sure breathe better using it? I also noticed that I occasionally hack what feels like a large chunk from my lungs after using it. Any ideas on that? I wasn’t producing anything before.

The rule of thumb is that if you are using your albuterol more than ~3x a week, you need to see your doctor.  It sounds like you are losing control of your asthma – but you need to see a doctor to know for sure. Also remember that the albuterol does not treat the asthma – it only treats asthma symptoms.   Current asthma treatment doctrine calls for the primary asthma medications to be ‘long term control’ medications with ‘quick relief’ medications (such as albuterol) only to be needed infrequently. "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god."   Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

    Thanks. It was beginning to feel as though I was beating myself up using it.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –    Well, you are in good company. I noticed he didn’t want to mention his arsenic argument after another individual and I covered it quite thoroughly.    BTW, is it unusual to use the Albuterol more than twice a day? I can get by without out it, but I sure breathe better using it? I also noticed that I occasionally hack what feels like a large chunk from my lungs after using it. Any ideas on that? I wasn’t producing anything before. The rule of thumb is that if you are using your albuterol more than ~3x a week, you need to see your doctor.  It sounds like you are losing control of your asthma – but you need to see a doctor to know for sure. Also remember that the albuterol does not treat the asthma – it only treats asthma symptoms. Current asthma treatment doctrine calls for the primary asthma medications to be ‘long term control’ medications with ‘quick relief’ medications (such as albuterol) only to be needed infrequently. "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god." Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

    Well, you are in good company. I noticed he didn’t want to mention his arsenic argument after another individual and I covered it quite thoroughly.     BTW, is it unusual to use the Albuterol more than twice a day? I can get by without out it, but I sure breathe better using it? I also noticed that I occasionally hack what feels like a large chunk from my lungs after using it. Any ideas on that? I wasn’t producing anything before.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –    Then you have just confirmed the same reaction we got on the other groups as well. I’ve kill filed him a long time ago, but I tried to remain reserved in my final judgements of him. He simply has a pattern that emerges in all the groups and it is the same. He may think he’s helping, but I haven’t found too many cases when he is correct or helpful. Some people do continue dialog with him in regards to some of his information, but none of it is ever about iron, a topic he seems to be stuck on, like a broken record. I have noticed that he appears to lack a real understanding of the subject. "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god." Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

   Then you have just confirmed the same reaction we got on the other groups as well. I’ve kill filed him a long time ago, but I tried to remain reserved in my final judgements of him. He simply has a pattern that emerges in all the groups and it is the same. He may think he’s helping, but I haven’t found too many cases when he is correct or helpful. Some people do continue dialog with him in regards to some of his information, but none of it is ever about iron, a topic he seems to be stuck on, like a broken record.

I have noticed that he appears to lack a real understanding of the subject.   "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god."   Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

   Colin, have you ever determined if Tom has *any* disease whatsoever that would make him a good candidate as participant in this group, or if he is just a pest?

He is just a pest.  I asked him if he, or someone he knew,  had asthma and he evaded the question. "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god."   Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

    Then you have just confirmed the same reaction we got on the other groups as well. I’ve kill filed him a long time ago, but I tried to remain reserved in my final judgements of him. He simply has a pattern that emerges in all the groups and it is the same. He may think he’s helping, but I haven’t found too many cases when he is correct or helpful. Some people do continue dialog with him in regards to some of his information, but none of it is ever about iron, a topic he seems to be stuck on, like a broken record.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –    Colin, have you ever determined if Tom has *any* disease whatsoever that would make him a good candidate as participant in this group, or if he is just a pest? He is just a pest.  I asked him if he, or someone he knew,  had asthma and he evaded the question. "With Confidence in our Armed Forces –  with the determination of our people –  we will gain the inevitable triumph –  so help us god." Franklin Delano Roseveldt, 8 december 1941

Response:

Salt with iodine???????

Question:

In article <CFiEO0NGGKZzWv40Ud4cUsKdC…@4ax.com>, Don Brady – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -<dbr…@pobox.com> wrote: > On Wed, 22 Aug 2001 14:38:50 -0700, "              MS" <m…@nospam.com> wrote: > >It is possible that there is some kind of sensitivity to iodine, without > >being officially classified as "allergy". > >I have heard that too much iodine can cause problems with the thyroid gland, > >as too little iodine can also. > True – that is why it was decided to add it to salt – in a few areas of the > country, the soil is low in iodine and you could develop goiter if you ate > only > locally-grown food. > Today we eat food from all over and the *excess* of iodine in the diet is now > causing thyroid disease.   It should be removed from salt now.

This is not my area, so I am asking for information. What diseases of the thyroid are caused by Iodine in our diet?        Larry

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -On Wed, 22 Aug 2001 21:32:34 -0400, Larry Preuss <LPre…@provide.net> wrote: >In article <CFiEO0NGGKZzWv40Ud4cUsKdC…@4ax.com>, Don Brady ><dbr…@pobox.com> wrote: >> On Wed, 22 Aug 2001 14:38:50 -0700, "              MS" <m…@nospam.com> wrote: >> >It is possible that there is some kind of sensitivity to iodine, without >> >being officially classified as "allergy". >> >I have heard that too much iodine can cause problems with the thyroid gland, >> >as too little iodine can also. >> True – that is why it was decided to add it to salt – in a few areas of the >> country, the soil is low in iodine and you could develop goiter if you ate >> only >> locally-grown food. >> Today we eat food from all over and the *excess* of iodine in the diet is now >> causing thyroid disease.   It should be removed from salt now. >This is not my area, so I am asking for information. What diseases of >the thyroid are caused by Iodine in our diet?

Hypothyroidism.  The incidence is far higher in populations where iodine is added to the salt (as it is here).

Response:

On Thu, 23 Aug 2001 03:44:42 GMT, Don Brady <dbr…@pobox.com> wrote: >>This is not my area, so I am asking for information. What diseases of >>the thyroid are caused by Iodine in our diet? >Hypothyroidism.  The incidence is far higher in populations where iodine is >added to the salt (as it is here).

To avoid overstatement on my part, I should amend my original statement to say: There is strong statistical evidence that the exess of iodine in Western diets, resulting from iodized salt and other added iodine,  can be linked to the much higher incidence of hypothyroidism, in comparison to populations which have lower intake of iodine. This issue is discussed in all books on endocrinology.   It can be a difficult decision for public health policy:  Add iodine to prevent sever goiters?  Or avoid doing so because of the risks of increased hpothryoidism?

Response:

In article <na2EO7MM+DMrB1qIVvKR4X984…@4ax.com>, Don Brady – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -<dbr…@pobox.com> wrote: > On Thu, 23 Aug 2001 03:44:42 GMT, Don Brady <dbr…@pobox.com> wrote: > >>This is not my area, so I am asking for information. What diseases of > >>the thyroid are caused by Iodine in our diet? > >Hypothyroidism.  The incidence is far higher in populations where iodine is > >added to the salt (as it is here). > To avoid overstatement on my part, I should amend my original statement to > say: > There is strong statistical evidence that the exess of iodine in Western > diets, > resulting from iodized salt and other added iodine,  can be linked to the much > higher incidence of hypothyroidism, in comparison to populations which have > lower intake of iodine. > This issue is discussed in all books on endocrinology.   It can be a difficult > decision for public health policy:  Add iodine to prevent sever goiters?  Or > avoid doing so because of the risks of increased hpothryoidism?

It is certain that a lack of iodine will lead to hypothyroidism and hypothyroid goiter; that was the reason for adding iodine to salt in the first place. At least that was my teaching in Endocrinology, and in my Endocrinology texts. I was not aware that iodine was felt to be a cause of hypothyroidism. Could you help me with more specific information.      Larry

Response:

  Don, I must thank you for directing my attention to this topic. It is clear that the teaching of thyroid function was simplistic at the time, years ago, when it was important that I be current. I have just consulted Werner & Ingbar’s The Thyroid; A Fundamental Text (Lippincott, 2000), and found a long discussion of the effects of excess iodine. I have been long aware that heavy iodine administration to pregnant women could cause fetal goiter; this was the reason for the removal of the old standard Quadrinal from asthma treatment. I had not known of the more widespread problem of both hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism in association with high iodine intake.   The present status appears extremely complex. There are aras of the world where iodine is found in enormous quantities in the drinking water, and there are diets (the Japanese for instance) which contain like amounts – and various thyroid abnormalities are almost the rule in those areas. More ordinary levels of iodine intake can cause real thyroid problems in those with pre-existing thyroid disease.   It is not clar to me, from what I read this morning, that iodine should be removed from table salt, but I am certainly open to more information. Fortunately, the amount of iodine used, by Americans at least, has dropped significantly in the last decade, largely because of changes in the dairy and bread industries. The general decline in table salt usage should further this decline, but it seems that studies on this are not up to date.   Thanks again, Don. I must re-evaluate my use of a daily multivitamin tablet that includes 100% of "daily requirements" of iodine.       Larry

Response:

"Larry Preuss" <LPre…@provide.net> wrote in message

news:230820010651377629%LPreuss@provide.net… > In article <na2EO7MM+DMrB1qIVvKR4X984…@4ax.com>, Don Brady > <dbr…@pobox.com> wrote: > It is certain that a lack of iodine will lead to hypothyroidism and > hypothyroid goiter; that was the reason for adding iodine to salt in > the first place. At least that was my teaching in Endocrinology, and in > my Endocrinology texts. I was not aware that iodine was felt to be a > cause of hypothyroidism. Could you help me with more specific > information. >      Larry

Larry, I am no expert, but I went to see a thyroid expert, a doctor who specializes in that gland in particular, for hypothyroidism. He told me to be careful not to get to much iodine. He asked to see the vitamins I take. He saw that the multivitamin had exactly the RDA of iodine, said that’s OK, but be careful not to get more. He even said to avoid eating seaweed, kelp, etc., or supplements containing it. He said the Japanese have the highest incidence of thyroid disease in the world, due to eating a lot of seaweed, tofu, etc. (I don’t think tofu is because of iodine, but some have reported it as a goitrigen, don’t know why.)

Response:

In article <toa7tt3mp2d…@corp.supernews.com>, MS <m…@nospam.com> wrote: > Larry, > I am no expert, but I went to see a thyroid expert, a doctor who specializes > in that gland in particular, for hypothyroidism. He told me to be careful > not to get to much iodine. He asked to see the vitamins I take. He saw that > the multivitamin had exactly the RDA of iodine, said that’s OK, but be > careful not to get more. He even said to avoid eating seaweed, kelp, etc., > or supplements containing it. He said the Japanese have the highest > incidence of thyroid disease in the world, due to eating a lot of seaweed, > tofu, etc. (I don’t think tofu is because of iodine, but some have reported > it as a goitrigen, don’t know why.)

Thanks for this.     Larry

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -On Thu, 23 Aug 2001 09:48:06 -0400, Larry Preuss <LPre…@provide.net> wrote: >  Don, I must thank you for directing my attention to this topic. It is >clear that the teaching of thyroid function was simplistic at the time, >years ago, when it was important that I be current. I have just >consulted Werner & Ingbar’s The Thyroid; A Fundamental Text >(Lippincott, 2000), and found a long discussion of the effects of >excess iodine. I have been long aware that heavy iodine administration >to pregnant women could cause fetal goiter; this was the reason for the >removal of the old standard Quadrinal from asthma treatment. I had not >known of the more widespread problem of both hypothyroidism and >hyperthyroidism in association with high iodine intake. >  The present status appears extremely complex. There are aras of the >world where iodine is found in enormous quantities in the drinking >water, and there are diets (the Japanese for instance) which contain >like amounts – and various thyroid abnormalities are almost the rule in >those areas. More ordinary levels of iodine intake can cause real >thyroid problems in those with pre-existing thyroid disease. >  It is not clar to me, from what I read this morning, that iodine >should be removed from table salt, but I am certainly open to more >information. Fortunately, the amount of iodine used, by Americans at >least, has dropped significantly in the last decade, largely because of >changes in the dairy and bread industries. The general decline in table >salt usage should further this decline, but it seems that studies on >this are not up to date. >  Thanks again, Don. I must re-evaluate my use of a daily multivitamin >tablet that includes 100% of "daily requirements" of iodine.

You’re welcome. Of course one also has to watch that supplements do not contain iron (especially men) as this may be associated with heart disease.

Response:

Speaking of supplements, some contain Niacin. Persons with migraine can percipitate a migraine attack when they take this. Niacin is a vasodialator, and Migraine pain is the extreme vasodilitation.  So I caution Migraine patients on this matter. Murray Grossan, M.D. http://www.ent-consult.com http://www.TinnitusRelief.net

Response:

I wonder if using Betadine regularly in irrigation fluid could also add to excess iodine, as some of that must be absorbed by the body, swallowed, etc.? "Larry Preuss" <LPre…@provide.net> wrote in message

news:230820010948066566%LPreuss@provide.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text ->   Don, I must thank you for directing my attention to this topic. It is > clear that the teaching of thyroid function was simplistic at the time, > years ago, when it was important that I be current. I have just > consulted Werner & Ingbar’s The Thyroid; A Fundamental Text > (Lippincott, 2000), and found a long discussion of the effects of > excess iodine. I have been long aware that heavy iodine administration > to pregnant women could cause fetal goiter; this was the reason for the > removal of the old standard Quadrinal from asthma treatment. I had not > known of the more widespread problem of both hypothyroidism and > hyperthyroidism in association with high iodine intake. >   The present status appears extremely complex. There are aras of the > world where iodine is found in enormous quantities in the drinking > water, and there are diets (the Japanese for instance) which contain > like amounts – and various thyroid abnormalities are almost the rule in > those areas. More ordinary levels of iodine intake can cause real > thyroid problems in those with pre-existing thyroid disease. >   It is not clar to me, from what I read this morning, that iodine > should be removed from table salt, but I am certainly open to more > information. Fortunately, the amount of iodine used, by Americans at > least, has dropped significantly in the last decade, largely because of > changes in the dairy and bread industries. The general decline in table > salt usage should further this decline, but it seems that studies on > this are not up to date. >   Thanks again, Don. I must re-evaluate my use of a daily multivitamin > tablet that includes 100% of "daily requirements" of iodine. >       Larry

Response:

Many physicians have been recommending Betadine for pulsatile irrigation for years, especially after surgery and no one has ever reported a problem other than occasional irritation. I don’t recommend non iodized salt for concern about absorbing more iodine. I recommend non iodized salt because some persons are sensitive and do better with non iodized salt. All the prepared preparations for pulsatile irrigation, including Breathe.ease are without iodine or silica.  Except one. Sea salt, which is one reason why I recommend to my patients not to use Sea Salt. Murray Grossan, M.D. http://www.ent-consult.com http://www.TinnitusRelief.net

Response:

"ENTconsult" <entcons…@aol.com> wrote in message

news:20010825132333.14716.00005085@mb-fo.aol.com… > Many physicians have been recommending Betadine for pulsatile irrigation for > years, especially after surgery and no one has ever reported a problem other > than occasional irritation.

Would someone necessarily notice and "report a problem" if they were getting too much iodine through using Betadine? If using iodized salt in irrigation water might cause an excess of iodine in the bloodstream, why wouldn’t Betadine do the same? > I don’t recommend non iodized salt for concern about absorbing more iodine. I > recommend non iodized salt because some persons are sensitive and do better > with non iodized salt. All the prepared preparations for pulsatile irrigation, > including Breathe.ease are without iodine or silica.  Except one. Sea salt, > which is one reason why I recommend to my patients not to use Sea Salt.

Sea salt has iodine and silica in it? Any references for that?

Response:

From what you have told me, and from what I have recently read,it is certainly not an unreasonable consideration.     Larry In article <toded9j8636…@corp.supernews.com>, MS <m…@nospam.com> wrote: – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> I wonder if using Betadine regularly in irrigation fluid could also add to > excess iodine, as some of that must be absorbed by the body, swallowed, > etc.? > "Larry Preuss" <LPre…@provide.net> wrote in message > news:230820010948066566%LPreuss@provide.net… > >   Don, I must thank you for directing my attention to this topic. It is > > clear that the teaching of thyroid function was simplistic at the time, > > years ago, when it was important that I be current. I have just > > consulted Werner & Ingbar’s The Thyroid; A Fundamental Text > > (Lippincott, 2000), and found a long discussion of the effects of > > excess iodine. I have been long aware that heavy iodine administration > > to pregnant women could cause fetal goiter; this was the reason for the > > removal of the old standard Quadrinal from asthma treatment. I had not > > known of the more widespread problem of both hypothyroidism and > > hyperthyroidism in association with high iodine intake. > >   The present status appears extremely complex. There are aras of the > > world where iodine is found in enormous quantities in the drinking > > water, and there are diets (the Japanese for instance) which contain > > like amounts – and various thyroid abnormalities are almost the rule in > > those areas. More ordinary levels of iodine intake can cause real > > thyroid problems in those with pre-existing thyroid disease. > >   It is not clar to me, from what I read this morning, that iodine > > should be removed from table salt, but I am certainly open to more > > information. Fortunately, the amount of iodine used, by Americans at > > least, has dropped significantly in the last decade, largely because of > > changes in the dairy and bread industries. The general decline in table > > salt usage should further this decline, but it seems that studies on > > this are not up to date. > >   Thanks again, Don. I must re-evaluate my use of a daily multivitamin > > tablet that includes 100% of "daily requirements" of iodine. > >       Larry

Response:

On Wed, 22 Aug 2001 14:38:50 -0700, "              MS" <m…@nospam.com> wrote: >It is possible that there is some kind of sensitivity to iodine, without >being officially classified as "allergy". >I have heard that too much iodine can cause problems with the thyroid gland, >as too little iodine can also.

True – that is why it was decided to add it to salt – in a few areas of the country, the soil is low in iodine and you could develop goiter if you ate only locally-grown food. Today we eat food from all over and the *excess* of iodine in the diet is now causing thyroid disease.   It should be removed from salt now.

Response:

It is possible that there is some kind of sensitivity to iodine, without being officially classified as "allergy". I have heard that too much iodine can cause problems with the thyroid gland, as too little iodine can also. "Larry Preuss" <LPre…@provide.net> wrote in message

news:210820011024342541%LPreuss@provide.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> In article <i%tg7.167357$Cy.23226…@news1.rdc1.az.home.com>, John > <joh…@spamcop.net> wrote: > > Larry: > > I can only tell you that I have a very strong reaction to IVP dye, which > > previously had been deemed an iodine allergy.  During a period of high > > sensitivity we stayed at a friends home who used a salt-based soft water > > treatment system.  Immediately after donning clothes washed in that water I > > broke out in hives, especially at the points of the body where the clothes > > came in best contact with the body (the waist, armpit and crotch).  I needed > > two injections of Benedryl to stop the reaction.  So you will pardon me if I > > believe in iodine allergies. > John, the reaction to iodine-containing contrast media is not due to > Iodine, but to a complex molecule that happens to contain Iodine, as > well as a number of other elements. The reaction itself is not an > allergic one, that is it does not involve antibodies, but is one of > release of histamine from mast cells by a physical, non-allergic, > mechanism. This may seem like quibbling, but is an important > differentiation, as it does not predict reaction to iodine in any other > form. You will recognize the fact that you eat Iodine in many foods; if > you did not, you would have a goiter. If you were allergic to Iodine > you would have a constant allergic reaction. I am not sure why you > conclude that your hives after washing your clothes implied or > confirmed Iodine allergy. > I do not argue with your right to believe in Iodine allergy. I would > simply like to point out that there is not an allergist, an > immunologist, or a radiologist in the world who believes that such > exists. Dr. Grossan of course does. >      Larry

Response:

In article <i%tg7.167357$Cy.23226…@news1.rdc1.az.home.com>, John <joh…@spamcop.net> wrote: > Larry: > I can only tell you that I have a very strong reaction to IVP dye, which > previously had been deemed an iodine allergy.  During a period of high > sensitivity we stayed at a friends home who used a salt-based soft water > treatment system.  Immediately after donning clothes washed in that water I > broke out in hives, especially at the points of the body where the clothes > came in best contact with the body (the waist, armpit and crotch).  I needed > two injections of Benedryl to stop the reaction.  So you will pardon me if I > believe in iodine allergies.

John, the reaction to iodine-containing contrast media is not due to Iodine, but to a complex molecule that happens to contain Iodine, as well as a number of other elements. The reaction itself is not an allergic one, that is it does not involve antibodies, but is one of release of histamine from mast cells by a physical, non-allergic, mechanism. This may seem like quibbling, but is an important differentiation, as it does not predict reaction to iodine in any other form. You will recognize the fact that you eat Iodine in many foods; if you did not, you would have a goiter. If you were allergic to Iodine you would have a constant allergic reaction. I am not sure why you conclude that your hives after washing your clothes implied or confirmed Iodine allergy. I do not argue with your right to believe in Iodine allergy. I would simply like to point out that there is not an allergist, an immunologist, or a radiologist in the world who believes that such exists. Dr. Grossan of course does.      Larry

Response:

On Mon, 20 Aug 2001 06:14:41 -0400, Larry Preuss <LPre…@provide.net> wrote: >. There is no such thing as allergy to >elemental iodine. Nobody is allergic to the iodine in salt, and you >cannot cite even _one_ scientific source for this statement. >      Larry

I was wondering about that myself, because our diet is laced with an excess of iodized salt.  So if people were allergic to that, they’d be in real trouble!

Response:

Larry: I can only tell you that I have a very strong reaction to IVP dye, which previously had been deemed an iodine allergy.  During a period of high sensitivity we stayed at a friends home who used a salt-based soft water treatment system.  Immediately after donning clothes washed in that water I broke out in hives, especially at the points of the body where the clothes came in best contact with the body (the waist, armpit and crotch).  I needed two injections of Benedryl to stop the reaction.  So you will pardon me if I believe in iodine allergies. "Larry Preuss" <LPre…@provide.net> wrote in message

news:200820010614414083%LPreuss@provide.net… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> In article <20010820000157.00709.00004…@mb-mq.aol.com>, ENTconsult > <entcons…@aol.com> wrote: > > Some persons are allergic to the iodine in salt. Also regular salt contains > > silica. Pickling salt and Breathe.ease contain no silica or iodine so less > > chance of a sensitivity. > > Murray Grossan, M.D. > > http://www.ent-consult.com > > http://www.TinnitusRelief.net > This is absolutely false. There is no such thing as allergy to > elemental iodine. Nobody is allergic to the iodine in salt, and you > cannot cite even _one_ scientific source for this statement. >       Larry

Response:

Some persons are allergic to the iodine in salt. Also regular salt contains silica. Pickling salt and Breathe.ease contain no silica or iodine so less chance of a sensitivity. Murray Grossan, M.D. http://www.ent-consult.com http://www.TinnitusRelief.net

Response:

In article <20010820000157.00709.00004…@mb-mq.aol.com>, ENTconsult <entcons…@aol.com> wrote: > Some persons are allergic to the iodine in salt. Also regular salt contains > silica. Pickling salt and Breathe.ease contain no silica or iodine so less > chance of a sensitivity. > Murray Grossan, M.D. > http://www.ent-consult.com > http://www.TinnitusRelief.net

This is absolutely false. There is no such thing as allergy to elemental iodine. Nobody is allergic to the iodine in salt, and you cannot cite even _one_ scientific source for this statement.       Larry

Response:

On Sun, 19 Aug 2001 17:11:48 -0400, Bill Poston <bil…@mindspring.com> wrote: >I’ve seen mixed posts about whether to use salt with or without iodine for >adding to water to flush your sinuses. >Which is best?????? >Thanks.

Iodine intake from diet alone is already excessive and suspected (by some) of causing thyroid problems, so I would not want it if I could avoid it.

Response:

What non-drug related practices help your Asthma?

Question:

Sounds great in theory, but in practicality is would be almost impossible to keep a greenhouse mold free.  Even if you started with "mold free" soil, any introduction of plant material would almost guarantee an introduction of mold.  High humidity and heat are perfect breeding grounds for countless organisms, including mold.  Now, perhaps sterile hydroponics?

Perhaps, I was thinking starting with all mold free substances. Seeds shouldnt be advercly effected by mold/fungacides and nither are a lot of plants (there are several mold/fungacise for use on plants particularly roses). I know there are a several molds and fungie that attack plants in the rosera famly such as black spot. The main problem I would think of would be bring them in on your cloths and shoes. Course a hall way structer were one might change should help with that. I was thinking of setting up an arbererium as I described because of the types of plants I would put into it and the type of soil/water around here (I dont think citrus would do well in Iowas dark loam alkaline dirt (a heated green house setting would be a given. or pots in the house as my baybe oringe and baybe grapfruit are now-4 inch) – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Patrice This reminds me. For the horticuluralist who has troble now. If you can get the cash, you could invest in a green house, build up  a brick foundation (a cuple of feet) and back fill with steral soil. Sence you can buy soil that is mold/funguse free you could make the envirement work. Oh it would be a good idea to clean the area with a fungicide/mold n mildew cleaner Elf-Kin

Response:

We got a waterbed in order to avoid dust mites.  It is on a full pedistal so there is no "under the bed" for dust and the matress wipes off easily.  All the bedding is washed in hot water.  More often if the asthma is acting up. I cant sleep on a water bed (realy sux, we have a king sized one). I cant breath on one, and thats not the result of my asthma as there is no attack asociated with the breathing difficulty. . . .

That’s probably due to compression of your chest from sagging down in the bed.  A little more water in the bed might help. Actually, you probably are not having that much additional difficulty breathing, but asthmatics become tuned to ANY additional difficulty breathing, so even the slight amount that results from a slight chest compression is enough to create discomfort.

Response:

Sounds great in theory, but in practicality is would be almost impossible to keep a greenhouse mold free.  Even if you started with "mold free" soil, any introduction of plant material would almost guarantee an introduction of mold.  High humidity and heat are perfect breeding grounds for countless organisms, including mold.  Now, perhaps sterile hydroponics? Patrice – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – This reminds me. For the horticuluralist who has troble now. If you can get the cash, you could invest in a green house, build up  a brick foundation (a cuple of feet) and back fill with steral soil. Sence you can buy soil that is mold/funguse free you could make the envirement work. Oh it would be a good idea to clean the area with a fungicide/mold n mildew cleaner Elf-Kin

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – We got a waterbed in order to avoid dust mites.  It is on a full pedistal so there is no "under the bed" for dust and the matress wipes off easily.  All the bedding is washed in hot water.  More often if the asthma is acting up. I cant sleep on a water bed (realy sux, we have a king sized one). I cant breath on one, and thats not the result of my asthma as there is no attack asociated with the breathing difficulty. . . . That’s probably due to compression of your chest from sagging down in the bed.  A little more water in the bed might help.

More water then what we had in it would put me sleeping on a hill:) Actually, you probably are not having that much additional difficulty breathing, but asthmatics become tuned to ANY additional difficulty breathing, so even the slight amount that results from a slight chest compression is enough to create discomfort.

Actualy its probly not that bad a thing that the only bed we own that is big enufe for both of us (my husband takes his half out of the middle) to sleep in (other things are adifrint mater, a rocker has enufe room for outher things;} As my so details concrete bridge beams and the dust folows hom home something ferce.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Resistive Breathing Training can make a significant differenc. Anyone suffering with asthma knows how important it is to be in tip top shape. We exercise the muscles that show. i.e. legs, arms, etc. What about the muscles that don’t show? Now you can exercise the diaphragm, the major muscle for breathing. It is simple with the Breather, an inspiratory/expiratory muscle trainer. total BS andridiculous as a follow up to a post where I mention singing as something I do to help asthma DO NOT buy some gadget to exercise your diaphragm…if you are going to spend money, then spend it with a voice coach and simultaneously get a better singing or speaking voice

Not to mention the symple act of drawing your knees tight to your chest while doing breath exercized acomplishes the same thing, And there is nothing new about risitive breathing exercizes. I was taught that as a child. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – and I’ve never heard of any voice coach recommending any such device eric "live fast, die only if strictly necessary"

Response:

Hello Bill, I guess I don’t understand the method here.  I know when I cracked a couple of ribs several years ago, my doc would not wrap them because he said I could end up with pneumonia due to constriction of the chest.  I assumed he was talking about interference of lung expansion, also.  Does your friend have asthma? Patrice P.S.  PENMART, I can’t wait until I see your response to this one. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Resistive Breathing Training can make a significant differenc. Anyone suffering with asthma knows how important it is to be in tip top shape. We exercise the muscles that show. i.e. legs, arms, etc. What about the muscles that don’t show? Now you can exercise the diaphragm, the major muscle for breathing. This post brought back to mind a recommedation a friend made several weeks ago..one that Im still pondering. She recommended that when excercising, biking, etc that I wear a sports bra to help restrict the chest wall movement and strenghen the inner chest muscles/etc. Ant thoughts to the effectiveness of this strategy? Bill

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – One nice thing about cycling is that you can pace yourself based on your energy level and how easily you’re breathing.  No need to limit yourself to 10 miles or any other particular limit, if you have the time.  And if you aren’t breaking a sweat in 10 miles you’re taking it too easy! I’m not cycling purely for exercise…I cycle to get from A to B…so I tend to take it very easy going somewhere…then I arrive feeling fresh…and I sprint the journey home to get some decent exercise I don’t have a limit as such…it’s just that over ten miles can often be faster by train or underground

Me too — I regard cycling as something you do to go somewhere, not something you go somewhere to do.  But I could wait a long time for a train around here (and then I’d have to ride with the wood chips), and even though this is the Gopher State, I’m not about to try the underground route. It’s 9.6 miles from my house to my place of work.  In the mornings, when I ride, I take a "short cut" that makes the total about 14.5 miles.  My record is 54 minutes.  I shower at work before I start my job.  I take the direct route home, and take it a little easier (partly because it’s uphill and usually against the wind).

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Resistive Breathing Training can make a significant differenc. Anyone suffering with asthma knows how important it is to be in tip top shape. We exercise the muscles that show. i.e. legs, arms, etc. What about the muscles that don’t show? Now you can exercise the diaphragm, the major muscle for breathing. This post brought back to mind a recommedation a friend made several weeks ago..one that Im still pondering. She recommended that when excercising, biking, etc that I wear a sports bra to help restrict the chest wall movement and strenghen the inner chest muscles/etc. Ant thoughts to the effectiveness of this strategy? Bill

Bill, I’m wondering what you’d look like in a sports bra.  I know it wouldn’t do a thing for me.

Response:

It’s 9.6 miles from my house to my place of work.  In the mornings, when I ride, I take a "short cut" that makes the total about 14.5 miles.  My record is 54 minutes.  I shower at work before I start my job.  I take the direct route home, and take it a little easier (partly because it’s uphill and usually against the wind).

I have a huge advantage…I live by the river…so whereever I go the chances are most of the journey home is downhill :) eric "live fast, die only if strictly necessary"

Response:

About the only thing other than steroids is avoidance of things that trigger asthma. — Gordon    W5RED www.couger.com/gcouger "You miss 100 percent of the shots you never take."   – Wayne Gretzky

Response:

Hello everyone Like a lot of Asthma sufferers I take meds, but I also do other things that make me feel better.

I’m a rather naughty asthmatic whin it comes to this. I dont use my rescue inhalor unless its realy bad. Like, whin the face in the merror looks like an extra from _night of the zombies_ Drink lots of water

Mt dew. Lots of caffeen. Corse that could just meen I"m a caffeen addict:} Take hot showers

Hot baths. (not wimpy, 90degree ones my baths have been messered in the 114-120 range). Whin my asthmas acting up I’ll put euchaliptus oil in it. Use a treadmill

Live on an achorage. Digging right now. Putting in a rose garden in a lovily area infested with burdock, and grass. It very arobic. Because Breaking up sod is hard to do:) couldnt resist. Still need to prepare the area for my vegies. This reminds me. For the horticuluralist who has troble now. If you can get the cash, you could invest in a green house, build up  a brick foundation (a cuple of feet) and back fill with steral soil. Sence you can buy soil that is mold/funguse free you could make the envirement work. Oh it would be a good idea to clean the area with a fungicide/mold n mildew cleaner Use mite-proof pillow and mattress cases

Were does one get such things? I’d like to hear what others are doing.

I like Yoga and dance exercizes. Elf-Kin

Response:

We got a waterbed in order to avoid dust mites.  It is on a full pedistal so there is no "under the bed" for dust and the matress wipes off easily.  All the bedding is washed in hot water.  More often if the asthma is acting up.

I cant sleep on a water bed (realy sux, we have a king sized one). I cant breath on one, and thats not the result of my asthma as there is no attack asociated with the breathing difficulty. . . . Jo An Firey * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Elf-kin

Response:

Other suggestions: Avoid iced drinks.  Lots of hot tea, esp in early AM Carry a windbreaker so if you do get chilled you can warm your body. Vacuum rugs???? Try to keep only throw rugs that can be washed in machine. Singing is something every doctor forgets about. You learn breath control and deep breathing. Mirror biofeedback helps to reduce anxiety reinforcement (www.ent-consult.com) Murray Grossan, M.D. http://www.ent-consult.com

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – eating a healthy diet cycling anywhere under 10 miles…when health allows replaced curtains with blinds…replaced nearly all carpet with tiles singing Why under 10 miles? because over ten miles I’ll be fairly tired when I get there, hence it isn’t always appropriate to cycle…less than that and all things being equal I’ll be fine to get straight on with pretty much anything as soon as I’m off the bike…may have not even broken sweat

One nice thing about cycling is that you can pace yourself based on your energy level and how easily you’re breathing.  No need to limit yourself to 10 miles or any other particular limit, if you have the time.  And if you aren’t breaking a sweat in 10 miles you’re taking it too easy!

Response:

One nice thing about cycling is that you can pace yourself based on your energy level and how easily you’re breathing.  No need to limit yourself to 10 miles or any other particular limit, if you have the time.  And if you aren’t breaking a sweat in 10 miles you’re taking it too easy!

I’m not cycling purely for exercise…I cycle to get from A to B…so I tend to take it very easy going somewhere…then I arrive feeling fresh…and I sprint the journey home to get some decent exercise I don’t have a limit as such…it’s just that over ten miles can often be faster by train or underground eric "live fast, die only if strictly necessary"

Response:

Resistive Breathing Training can make a significant differenc. Anyone suffering with asthma knows how important it is to be in tip top shape. We exercise the muscles that show. i.e. legs, arms, etc. What about the muscles that don’t show? Now you can exercise the diaphragm, the major muscle for breathing.

This post brought back to mind a recommedation a friend made several weeks ago..one that Im still pondering. She recommended that when excercising, biking, etc that I wear a sports bra to help restrict the chest wall movement and strenghen the inner chest muscles/etc. Ant thoughts to the effectiveness of this strategy? Bill

Response:

This post brought back to mind a recommedation a friend made several weeks ago..one that Im still pondering. She recommended that when excercising, biking, etc that I wear a sports bra to help restrict the chest wall movement and strenghen the inner chest muscles/etc. Ant thoughts to the effectiveness of this strategy?

IMO, worthless.  The idea behind asthma treatment is to eliminate the necessity of using accessory muscles for breathing.  The use of accessory muscles is a symptom and modern asthma treatment concentrates on treating causes in order to prevent symptoms in the first place. There is no place for the hyphen in our citizenship… We are a nation, not a hodge-podge of foreign nationalities. We are a people, and not a polyglot boarding house.  - Theodore Roosevelt

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hello everyone Like a lot of Asthma sufferers I take meds, but I also do other things that make me feel better. Drink lots of water Take hot showers Use a treadmill Use mite-proof pillow and mattress cases I’d like to hear what others are doing. eating a healthy diet cycling anywhere under 10 miles…when health allows replaced curtains with blinds…replaced nearly all carpet with tiles singing eric "live fast, die only if strictly necessary"

Resistive Breathing Training can make a significant differenc. Anyone suffering with asthma knows how important

it is to be in tip top shape. We exercise the muscles that show. i.e. legs, arms, etc. What about the muscles that don’t show? Now you can exercise the diaphragm, the major muscle for breathing. It is simple with the Breather, an inspiratory/expiratory muscle trainer. Please Before you buy.

Response:

Hello everyone Like a lot of Asthma sufferers I take meds, but I also do other things that make me feel better. Drink lots of water Take hot showers Use a treadmill Use mite-proof pillow and mattress cases I’d like to hear what others are doing.

eating a healthy diet cycling anywhere under 10 miles…when health allows replaced curtains with blinds…replaced nearly all carpet with tiles singing eric "live fast, die only if strictly necessary"

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hello everyone Like a lot of Asthma sufferers I take meds, but I also do other things that make me feel better. Drink lots of water Take hot showers Use a treadmill Use mite-proof pillow and mattress cases I’d like to hear what others are doing. eating a healthy diet cycling anywhere under 10 miles…when health allows replaced curtains with blinds…replaced nearly all carpet with tiles singing

Why under 10 miles?

Response:

Hello everyone Like a lot of Asthma sufferers I take meds, but I also do other things that make me feel better.

Hiya – For me, my biggest thing was moving.  I moved from one area of the Bx that had one of the highest occurrences of asthma to a different part that had lower occurrences.  We had lived in the same apt for my entire life (im 31) and moving got rid of a lot of dust laden things.  I am much better since the move. Also, I wash sheets and pillow cases twice a week in very hot water.  I eat a low fat diet and exercise if at all possible.  Exercising for me is a big deal, as I usually am not healthy enough.  Sadly, I am estatic about being able to do the treadmill for 5 minutes.  But at least 5 minutes are better than no minutes. I take a multivitamin and calcium supplements, as I am steroid-dependent.  I stay indoors on very hot and humid days, or ozone alert days.  I avoid any animals, smoke, cleaners or perfumes. I take my peak flow 3x a day, and I have a reallly good rapore with my doc.  I think that is really important.  I can beep her if I just have a question, or if I feel a little iffy – she tells me just what to do.  That might be the most important thing you can do. Life is uncertain – eat dessert first. Nancy 8=: )

Response:

Forgot to mention.  Right after dealing with the furnace filter, if I’m up to it the dog and cat both get baths.  They usually get a weekly bath anyway.  And washing my hands after playing with them has become a habit. (I’m at work writing this.  My husband is home shampooing carpets.  I won’t go home till he is done and they are dry, the hose is aired out, closed up and the filter has run for a while. ) Jo An Firey * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Response:

Hello everyone Like a lot of Asthma sufferers I take meds, but I also do other things that make me feel better. Drink lots of water Take hot showers Use a treadmill Use mite-proof pillow and mattress cases I’d like to hear what others are doing.

Eat a healthy (balanced) diet. Exercise regularly. Identify what I am allergic to then minimize my exposure. Get plenty of sleep at night. Reduce stress and develop a relaxation routine. Utilize peakflow monitoring. There is no place for the hyphen in our citizenship… We are a nation, not a hodge-podge of foreign nationalities. We are a people, and not a polyglot boarding house.  - Theodore Roosevelt

Response:

Hello everyone Like a lot of Asthma sufferers I take meds, but I also do other things that make me feel better. Drink lots of water Take hot showers Use a treadmill Use mite-proof pillow and mattress cases I’d like to hear what others are doing.

Response:

We got a waterbed in order to avoid dust mites.  It is on a full pedistal so there is no "under the bed" for dust and the matress wipes off easily.  All the bedding is washed in hot water.  More often if the asthma is acting up. Also the first thing I do when having more trouble than usual is wash the furnace filter.  And I do that weekly if there are problems.  It took years to convince my hubby that the windows need to stay closed.  Both in the car and in the house. Also avoid out of doors when pollen is bad.  Or at least shower and change when I come inside. And I haven’t touched a vacuum cleaner in years.  I even leave the house while it is being vacuumed.  (All of the non-dusty cleaning jobs are mine.) Jo An Firey * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Response:

Asthma treatment through trachy

Question:

Hi……I’m in the UK and this is on behalf of a dear friend of mine who had cancer of the throat. He is over the cancer but uses a nebuliser with an attachment into his throat to administer drugs to help his connectors [for want of the proper term]……he feels very uncomfortable with the one they have given him and he is of the mind that perhaps he could find something more comfortable.  Basically is there a Rolls Royce!!  He has been issued with this one by the NHS here in England. So, can any kind soul out there enlighten us as to whether or not he could buy a better one anywhere? Regards Helene

Response:

There is such a thing called a trach collar aeresol mask.  It looks like a tiny oxygen mask that fits over the trach site and secures with a neck strap or he can just hold it in place. a small infant mask such as one used with the pari-nebulizer set up may also work.  His local hospital respiratory therapy dept should be able to advise him as to what is available in the UK…sorry I’m in the US. Good luck and god bless ACL – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi……I’m in the UK and this is on behalf of a dear friend of mine who had cancer of the throat. He is over the cancer but uses a nebuliser with an attachment into his throat to administer drugs to help his connectors [for want of the proper term]……he feels very uncomfortable with the one they have given him and he is of the mind that perhaps he could find something more comfortable.  Basically is there a Rolls Royce!!  He has been issued with this one by the NHS here in England. So, can any kind soul out there enlighten us as to whether or not he could buy a better one anywhere? Regards Helene

Response:

Dear Ziggy The end of a tracheostomy tube has a 15mm male connection, this is a universal standard. This is a different type of connection from the connection on the medication holder that he is using with his nebuliser pump (the end that the mask or mouthpiece fits on to). If you are near a hospital that has anaesthetic department you should ask their technician if he can find you a connector that will be compatible with the medication holder and the 15mm connection on the tracheostomy tube. These people have lots of connectors lying around and are usually pleased to help.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi……I’m in the UK and this is on behalf of a dear friend of mine who had cancer of the throat. He is over the cancer but uses a nebuliser with an attachment into his throat to administer drugs to help his connectors [for want of the proper term]……he feels very uncomfortable with the one they have given him and he is of the mind that perhaps he could find something more comfortable.  Basically is there a Rolls Royce!!  He has been issued with this one by the NHS here in England. So, can any kind soul out there enlighten us as to whether or not he could buy a better one anywhere? Regards Helene

Response:

Any Canadians comment on Pulmicort wrt asthma treatment?

Question:

My 16 month old son has been given a drug not yet officially ok’d by the US FDA for US pharmacies to dispense. Is Pulmicort used well in Canada as an alternative to Prednisolone? It’s being nebulized with Xenopex (1.2) in our case. I don’t like how Prednisolone winds up my 16 month old. ALSO: any FAQ of alt.support.asthma would be appreciated! regards, Jim (opinions my own, not mirroring those of my employer)

Response:

My 16 month old son has been given a drug not yet officially ok’d by the US FDA for US pharmacies to dispense. Is Pulmicort used well in Canada as an alternative to Prednisolone? It’s being nebulized with Xenopex (1.2) in our case. I don’t like how Prednisolone winds up my 16 month old. ALSO: any FAQ of alt.support.asthma would be appreciated! regards, Jim

Nebulized steroids are not FDA approved in US: however available in most other countries including Canada. For Pulmicort see: http://www.rxmed.com/monographs/pulmico.html PULMICORT

albuterol sulfate resistance?

Question:

Is it possible to build up a resistance to albuterol, needing more and more? Thanks, H.

Response:

Is it possible to build up a resistance to albuterol, needing more and more?

If you are overusing the stuff then you can run into a situation where it loses effectiveness. If you are using the stuff more than three times a week, you need to go to your doctor and get a better asthma treatment program going. No electrons were harmed in the posting of this message.

Response: