Cough variant – Know this situation?
Question:
What ever you do don’t give up I spent around 2 years constant bronchitis and losing my voice. I had phnumoia in jan. So they gave me an inhahler to use because of the shortness of breath. They also did not think /I had Asthma because they did not hear the weezing but it would only affect me at certain times of the day and never when i was at the doctors office. I finally went to an allergist who was not sure either because my tests showed normal breathing limits. So they decided to do this test where if you have asthma it will put you into a respitory attack. I had this test last friday and they said that they have never had a patient react to that test so quickly. So now I have this breathing machine I have to use every 8 hrs or every 4 hours if needed so I would ask your doctor about this test it is really scary if you have asthma but at least you would know. If you have any questions p[ease feel free to contact me: Hang in there Janet
Response:
- Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - A nebulizer ensures better delivery of the medication "better" is a generallity... better how? More of the medication gets into the respiratory system faster, in part because breathing does not have to be timed to inhalation of medication. I agree the pattern of deposition is somewhat different but your comment, as it is written, is wrong. More medication is delivered with a neb. Estimates range from fairly comparable to 10 times as much (ten puffs of albuterol equalling one 2.5 mg neb). It is not delivered faster - about 10 minutes (neb) vs a second or so.
If you read my original post, I have already made this very statement. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - and delivers it in a higher concentration. Nebulizers deliver meds at far lower concentrations than do MDIs. You're just dead wrong on that one. I'm not sure the concentration really is a relevant factor - but if you must argue about it the medication in a puff of an MDI is more concentrated than the neb.
Response:
A nebulizer ensures better delivery of the medication "better" is a generallity... better how?
More of the medication gets into the respiratory system faster, in part because breathing does not have to be timed to inhalation of medication. and delivers it in a higher concentration. Nebulizers deliver meds at far lower concentrations than do MDIs.
You're just dead wrong on that one. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Sheldon "Life would be devoid of all meaning were it without tribulation."
Response:
A nebulizer ensures better delivery of the medication "better" is a generallity... better how? More of the medication gets into the respiratory system faster, in part because breathing does not have to be timed to inhalation of medication.
I agree the pattern of deposition is somewhat different but your comment, as it is written, is wrong. More medication is delivered with a neb. Estimates range from fairly comparable to 10 times as much (ten puffs of albuterol equalling one 2.5 mg neb). It is not delivered faster - about 10 minutes (neb) vs a second or so. and delivers it in a higher concentration. Nebulizers deliver meds at far lower concentrations than do MDIs. You're just dead wrong on that one.
I'm not sure the concentration really is a relevant factor - but if you must argue about it the medication in a puff of an MDI is more concentrated than the neb.
Response:
Thanks everyone for your replies. I'm already on Flovent 250 (for almost 2 years now). Just doesn't seem to be effective anymore. I did see a pulmonologist at first, but I was referred back to my GP after a few months. I'll see what my GP says about trying something else, and if necessary, get referred back to a pulmonologist. Pierre
- Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - I put off going to Emerg for 7 hours yesterday. Finally, around 3 AM, I had to go to the local ER because I couldn't breathe despite having used my rescue inhaler to the limit, and I was coughing non-stop. They sent me right into Observation without even having to register in. When I got there, they said my lungs sounded clear, but that I was having bronchospams. Anyway, whatever it was, I stopped coughing and was able to breathe normally within about 10-15 minutes of them putting the ventolin mask on me. And however clear my lungs sounded before, they sounded even better afterwards, so they let me go home. The spirometry post ventolin was great, but they didn't do it before to be able to compare. My allergist diagnosed me with cough-variant asthma (not to mention the multiple respiratory allergies) a couple of years ago, and my PCP calls it reactive airways. The problem is, nobody ever believes it's asthma at first because I don't wheeze at all - and this includes doctors and nurses. I can't say that Flovent is terribly effective for this kind of thing, but the Ventolin is. Any thoughts? I'm beginning to wonder if I should ask about trying something like Tilade, or Singulair instead. Pierre
Response:
nobody ever believes it's asthma at first because I don't wheeze at all - and this includes doctors and nurses. I can't say that Flovent is terribly effective for this kind of thing, but the Ventolin is. Any thoughts? I'm beginning to wonder if I should ask about trying something like Tilade, or Singulair instead. Pierre
I've had similar problems. I found Singulair worked quite well, except that I get migraines & that gave me one daily. But it worked. Worked the best of anything I've tried.
Response:
A nebulizer ensures better delivery of the medication and delivers it in a higher concentration.. With ventolin, for example, it would take 10 puffs to equal one adult dose neb. Also, you have moist air enveloping the respiratory tract which is of some benefit. My family has a nebulizer and it has saved many, many trips to the emerg. My sons even took their pulmicort this way when they were little. Apparently, there are doctors out there who do not think a mebulizer makes any difference. Those doctors should experience a serious asthma attack and be told they can't have one. Finally to the poster who said their medication did a great job controlling their asthma until they get a cold. If you are consistently having a serious problem when you hve a cold, then your current medication is not enough. You may need an inhaled steroid, such as Pulmicort, rather than just Singulair. Talk to an asthma specialist. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - I put off going to Emerg for 7 hours yesterday. Finally, around 3 AM, I had to go to the local ER because I couldn't breathe despite having used my rescue inhaler to the limit, and I was coughing non-stop. They sent me right into Observation without even having to register in. When I got there, they said my lungs sounded clear, but that I was having bronchospams. Anyway, whatever it was, I stopped coughing and was able to breathe normally within about 10-15 minutes of them putting the ventolin mask on me. And however clear my lungs sounded before, they sounded even better afterwards, so they let me go home. The spirometry post ventolin was great, but they didn't do it before to be able to compare. My allergist diagnosed me with cough-variant asthma (not to mention the multiple respiratory allergies) a couple of years ago, and my PCP calls it reactive airways. The problem is, nobody ever believes it's asthma at first because I don't wheeze at all - and this includes doctors and nurses. I can't say that Flovent is terribly effective for this kind of thing, but the Ventolin is. Any thoughts? I'm beginning to wonder if I should ask about trying something like Tilade, or Singulair instead. Pierre Not only does the situation sound familiar, it sounds EXACTLY like my cough variant asthma (I rarely wheeze). According to my Pulmonary doctor and my Allergist (also an Asthma specialist), the best treatment, is to treat it exactly the same as regular Asthma. I.E. Emergency inhalers with some sort of preventative medication (inhaled steroids, Singulair, etc.). Keeping in mind that we all react differently to different treatments... here is what I'm taking (and it's keeping me very stable... unless I get a cold or flu): Advair 250/50 two puffs a day, Singulair 10mg once a day, Tesselon Pearls twice a day (cough suppressant)... for emergencies, Combivent two puffs every 4 to 6 hours or .5ml Albuterol in 3ml saline in a nebulizer followed by two puffs of Atrovent (this is every 4 to 6 hours). It's interesting that you mention responding better with the ER nebulizer than an inhaler. This is also the case for me (though I have my own nebulizer). I couldn't even begin to guess why a nebulizer seems more effective. As always, this is just for information... see a doctor or better yet, and asthma specialist for effective treatment of your asthma [another generic disclaimer 1.2.5c]. Dan Rhea "Loyalty is for family, friends and country, not operating systems, compilers and computers" – Dan Rhea, 1986
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I put off going to Emerg for 7 hours yesterday. Finally, around 3 AM, I had to go to the local ER because I couldn’t breathe despite having used my rescue inhaler to the limit, and I was coughing non-stop. They sent me right into Observation without even having to register in. When I got there, they said my lungs sounded clear, but that I was having bronchospams. Anyway, whatever it was, I stopped coughing and was able to breathe normally within about 10-15 minutes of them putting the ventolin mask on me. And however clear my lungs sounded before, they sounded even better afterwards, so they let me go home. The spirometry post ventolin was great, but they didn’t do it before to be able to compare. My allergist diagnosed me with cough-variant asthma (not to mention the multiple respiratory allergies) a couple of years ago, and my PCP calls it reactive airways. The problem is, nobody ever believes it’s asthma at first because I don’t wheeze at all – and this includes doctors and nurses. I can’t say that Flovent is terribly effective for this kind of thing, but the Ventolin is. Any thoughts? I’m beginning to wonder if I should ask about trying something like Tilade, or Singulair instead.
My advice is to ask your PCP for a referral to an asthma specialist. It’s a terrible responsibility – but somebody has to be the Americans.
Response:
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I put off going to Emerg for 7 hours yesterday. Finally, around 3 AM, I had to go to the local ER because I couldn’t breathe despite having used my rescue inhaler to the limit, and I was coughing non-stop. They sent me right into Observation without even having to register in. When I got there, they said my lungs sounded clear, but that I was having bronchospams. Anyway, whatever it was, I stopped coughing and was able to breathe normally within about 10-15 minutes of them putting the ventolin mask on me. And however clear my lungs sounded before, they sounded even better afterwards, so they let me go home. The spirometry post ventolin was great, but they didn’t do it before to be able to compare. My allergist diagnosed me with cough-variant asthma (not to mention the multiple respiratory allergies) a couple of years ago, and my PCP calls it reactive airways. The problem is, nobody ever believes it’s asthma at first because I don’t wheeze at all – and this includes doctors and nurses. I can’t say that Flovent is terribly effective for this kind of thing, but the Ventolin is. Any thoughts? I’m beginning to wonder if I should ask about trying something like Tilade, or Singulair instead. Pierre
Not only does the situation sound familiar, it sounds EXACTLY like my cough variant asthma (I rarely wheeze). According to my Pulmonary doctor and my Allergist (also an Asthma specialist), the best treatment, is to treat it exactly the same as regular Asthma. I.E. Emergency inhalers with some sort of preventative medication (inhaled steroids, Singulair, etc.). Keeping in mind that we all react differently to different treatments… here is what I’m taking (and it’s keeping me very stable… unless I get a cold or flu): Advair 250/50 two puffs a day, Singulair 10mg once a day, Tesselon Pearls twice a day (cough suppressant)… for emergencies, Combivent two puffs every 4 to 6 hours or .5ml Albuterol in 3ml saline in a nebulizer followed by two puffs of Atrovent (this is every 4 to 6 hours). It’s interesting that you mention responding better with the ER nebulizer than an inhaler. This is also the case for me (though I have my own nebulizer). I couldn’t even begin to guess why a nebulizer seems more effective. As always, this is just for information… see a doctor or better yet, and asthma specialist for effective treatment of your asthma [another generic disclaimer 1.2.5c]. Dan Rhea "Loyalty is for family, friends and country, not operating systems, compilers and computers" – Dan Rhea, 1986
Response:
Lots of people ONLY cough with asthma and never wheeze. It’s not that uncommon and yes it sounds like you need some regular controlling medication like singulair or pulmicort. Just using a rescue inhaler like Bricanyl or Ventolin is not going to resolve the situation. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I put off going to Emerg for 7 hours yesterday. Finally, around 3 AM, I had to go to the local ER because I couldn’t breathe despite having used my rescue inhaler to the limit, and I was coughing non-stop. They sent me right into Observation without even having to register in. When I got there, they said my lungs sounded clear, but that I was having bronchospams. Anyway, whatever it was, I stopped coughing and was able to breathe normally within about 10-15 minutes of them putting the ventolin mask on me. And however clear my lungs sounded before, they sounded even better afterwards, so they let me go home. The spirometry post ventolin was great, but they didn’t do it before to be able to compare. My allergist diagnosed me with cough-variant asthma (not to mention the multiple respiratory allergies) a couple of years ago, and my PCP calls it reactive airways. The problem is, nobody ever believes it’s asthma at first because I don’t wheeze at all – and this includes doctors and nurses. I can’t say that Flovent is terribly effective for this kind of thing, but the Ventolin is. Any thoughts? I’m beginning to wonder if I should ask about trying something like Tilade, or Singulair instead. Pierre
Response:
I put off going to Emerg for 7 hours yesterday. Finally, around 3 AM, I had to go to the local ER because I couldn’t breathe despite having used my rescue inhaler to the limit, and I was coughing non-stop. They sent me right into Observation without even having to register in. When I got there, they said my lungs sounded clear, but that I was having bronchospams. Anyway, whatever it was, I stopped coughing and was able to breathe normally within about 10-15 minutes of them putting the ventolin mask on me. And however clear my lungs sounded before, they sounded even better afterwards, so they let me go home. The spirometry post ventolin was great, but they didn’t do it before to be able to compare. My allergist diagnosed me with cough-variant asthma (not to mention the multiple respiratory allergies) a couple of years ago, and my PCP calls it reactive airways. The problem is, nobody ever believes it’s asthma at first because I don’t wheeze at all – and this includes doctors and nurses. I can’t say that Flovent is terribly effective for this kind of thing, but the Ventolin is. Any thoughts? I’m beginning to wonder if I should ask about trying something like Tilade, or Singulair instead. Pierre
Categories:
