Posts belonging to Category 'what happens during asthma attack'

antibiotics and asthma?

Question:

Good reason!  Just be careful taking it for a long term.  UM MOM Susan

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I have Crohn’s disease and have researched antibiotics as much as a lay person can.  Antibiotics are over uses and DO kill the bad bacteria’s with the good messing up the flora.  Those of us with autoimmune diseases stay as far away from antibiotics as possible.  Even my pulmonary dr says that antibiotics is not the medication to choose for control.  It should only be uses if all other avenues  have been taken and if a bacterial infection is diagnosed.  UM MOM Susan In my case, everything else had been tried.  My asthma was not due to allergies, it was quite likely due to an infection.  Every time I was put on antibiotics for whatever (pneumonia, surgery, etc.) my asthma got better for a while. The long term antibiotic treatment was a last ditch effort since none of the medicines on the market were making a dent in the asthma and I was truly afraid I was going to die in an asthma attack in the near future. Sue Sue, Nobody is discussing the situation that you describe – where you are ON MEDICATION – it is likely you are making life unpleasant for both the good bacteria, and the bad bacteria that may be contributing to asthma. The real test will come when you are off medication – and have been off for say 12 months. See what happens then. Our experience is that that the asthmatic condition returns to approximately the same extent that it occurred before, and may even be worsened. The theory (pet theory as labelled by Colin) is that Biaxin will have killed off the helpful bacteria, while allowing the bad bacteria to thrive. Take someone in India or Nigeria who has never taken any of these drugs, and lived off poorly cooked food, cooked over smokey stoves fuelled by cow-dung, most will have no asthma. But give them a strong dose of Biaxin (or drug from similar family), and a significant number will develop asthma. (http://www.new-asthma.uk.net for coverage of the bad bacteria) Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Oddly enough, I’m on the experimental antibiotic treatment for asthma. I’ve been taking Biaxin (spelling)500mg twice a day for two months. I’m supposed to take it for another two months. When I started, I was diagnosed as a Severe Chronic Brittle Asthmatic and, even though I was on every asthma medication, my asthma was still not under control. Now, I’m fine.  I’m not wheezing.  I’m not short of breath.  I’m not using any of my inhalers or my nebulizer. I haven’t been this well in years. I had to talk my doctor into trying it and he sent me to Cleveland Clinic for an assessment.  The doctor there said he didn’t know if it would help but he was willing to give it a try. If I’m still doing OK in two months, I’m writing him a letter. This may not work for everyone but it works for me and that’s all I care about. Sue Any takers? Pete

Response:

Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers?

purely anecdotal I developed asthma age 4…first took antibiotics aged 12 — eric www.ericjarvis.co.uk "live fast, die only if strictly necessary"

Response:

Fungus, which one? Personally, I would probably go for C. albicans (thrush). But I admit that is my own "personal" hobby horse/culprit/villain – some of the time.

a groups.google for the contributions to this group by Csilla Csank might provide you with food for thought…she is a researcher into candida albicans and made a number of knowledgeable posts about the subject a few years ago — eric www.ericjarvis.co.uk "live fast, die only if strictly necessary"

Response:

Sue, I went through a similar antibiotic treatment for 14 weeks in 1996.  My severe asthma is now completely gone and I’ve been asthma free since 1996 (It NEVER came back).   Yesterday I heard from a friend of mine (ex neighbor) who recently finished up the exact treatment I took and his asthma seems to be gone after many years of dealing with it. The comment made by Colin about this being a "pet mission" is absolutely correct !  Asthma sucks and it made my life miserable.  I agree that it’s not for everyone but it sure was the right thing for me also. Jim http://www.AsthmaStory.com

Response:

I have Crohn’s disease and have researched antibiotics as much as a lay person can.  Antibiotics are over uses and DO kill the bad bacteria’s with the good messing up the flora.  Those of us with autoimmune diseases stay as far away from antibiotics as possible.  Even my pulmonary dr says that antibiotics is not the medication to choose for control.  It should only be uses if all other avenues  have been taken and if a bacterial infection is diagnosed.  UM MOM Susan

In my case, everything else had been tried.  My asthma was not due to allergies, it was quite likely due to an infection.  Every time I was put on antibiotics for whatever (pneumonia, surgery, etc.) my asthma got better for a while. The long term antibiotic treatment was a last ditch effort since none of the medicines on the market were making a dent in the asthma and I was truly afraid I was going to die in an asthma attack in the near future. Sue – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Sue, Nobody is discussing the situation that you describe – where you are ON MEDICATION – it is likely you are making life unpleasant for both the good bacteria, and the bad bacteria that may be contributing to asthma. The real test will come when you are off medication – and have been off for say 12 months. See what happens then. Our experience is that that the asthmatic condition returns to approximately the same extent that it occurred before, and may even be worsened. The theory (pet theory as labelled by Colin) is that Biaxin will have killed off the helpful bacteria, while allowing the bad bacteria to thrive. Take someone in India or Nigeria who has never taken any of these drugs, and lived off poorly cooked food, cooked over smokey stoves fuelled by cow-dung, most will have no asthma. But give them a strong dose of Biaxin (or drug from similar family), and a significant number will develop asthma. (http://www.new-asthma.uk.net for coverage of the bad bacteria) Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Oddly enough, I’m on the experimental antibiotic treatment for asthma. I’ve been taking Biaxin (spelling)500mg twice a day for two months. I’m supposed to take it for another two months. When I started, I was diagnosed as a Severe Chronic Brittle Asthmatic and, even though I was on every asthma medication, my asthma was still not under control. Now, I’m fine.  I’m not wheezing.  I’m not short of breath.  I’m not using any of my inhalers or my nebulizer. I haven’t been this well in years. I had to talk my doctor into trying it and he sent me to Cleveland Clinic for an assessment.  The doctor there said he didn’t know if it would help but he was willing to give it a try. If I’m still doing OK in two months, I’m writing him a letter. This may not work for everyone but it works for me and that’s all I care about. Sue Any takers? Pete

Response:

I have Crohn’s disease and have researched antibiotics as much as a lay person can.  Antibiotics are over uses and DO kill the bad bacteria’s with the good messing up the flora.  Those of us with autoimmune diseases stay as far away from antibiotics as possible.  Even my pulmonary dr says that antibiotics is not the medication to choose for control.  It should only be uses if all other avenues  have been taken and if a bacterial infection is diagnosed.  UM MOM Susan

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Sue, Nobody is discussing the situation that you describe – where you are ON MEDICATION – it is likely you are making life unpleasant for both the good bacteria, and the bad bacteria that may be contributing to asthma. The real test will come when you are off medication – and have been off for say 12 months. See what happens then. Our experience is that that the asthmatic condition returns to approximately the same extent that it occurred before, and may even be worsened. The theory (pet theory as labelled by Colin) is that Biaxin will have killed off the helpful bacteria, while allowing the bad bacteria to thrive. Take someone in India or Nigeria who has never taken any of these drugs, and lived off poorly cooked food, cooked over smokey stoves fuelled by cow-dung, most will have no asthma. But give them a strong dose of Biaxin (or drug from similar family), and a significant number will develop asthma. (http://www.new-asthma.uk.net for coverage of the bad bacteria) Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Oddly enough, I’m on the experimental antibiotic treatment for asthma. I’ve been taking Biaxin (spelling)500mg twice a day for two months. I’m supposed to take it for another two months. When I started, I was diagnosed as a Severe Chronic Brittle Asthmatic and, even though I was on every asthma medication, my asthma was still not under control. Now, I’m fine.  I’m not wheezing.  I’m not short of breath.  I’m not using any of my inhalers or my nebulizer. I haven’t been this well in years. I had to talk my doctor into trying it and he sent me to Cleveland Clinic for an assessment.  The doctor there said he didn’t know if it would help but he was willing to give it a try. If I’m still doing OK in two months, I’m writing him a letter. This may not work for everyone but it works for me and that’s all I care about. Sue Any takers? Pete

Response:

Sue, Nobody is discussing the situation that you describe – where you are ON MEDICATION – it is likely you are making life unpleasant for both the good bacteria, and the bad bacteria that may be contributing to asthma. The real test will come when you are off medication – and have been off for say 12 months. See what happens then.

I do realize that.  But I  also know I am now free of all symptoms. Our experience is that that the asthmatic condition returns to approximately the same extent that it occurred before, and may even be worsened.

What experience are you referrring to?  Cites, please. The theory (pet theory as labelled by Colin) is that Biaxin will have killed off the helpful bacteria, while allowing the bad bacteria to

thrive. ????? Take someone in India or Nigeria who has never taken any of these drugs, and lived off poorly cooked food, cooked over smokey stoves fuelled by cow-dung, most will have no asthma. But give them a strong dose of Biaxin (or drug from similar family), and a significant number will develop asthma.

Since the infant and child death rate is very high in 3rd world countries, this is not a good example.  It’s like trying to compare osteoarthritis percentages of population between US and Nigeria.  Very few people in those 3rd world countries live long enough to get it. Sue – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – (http://www.new-asthma.uk.net for coverage of the bad bacteria) Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Oddly enough, I’m on the experimental antibiotic treatment for asthma. I’ve been taking Biaxin (spelling)500mg twice a day for two months. I’m supposed to take it for another two months. When I started, I was diagnosed as a Severe Chronic Brittle Asthmatic and, even though I was on every asthma medication, my asthma was still not under control. Now, I’m fine.  I’m not wheezing.  I’m not short of breath.  I’m not using any of my inhalers or my nebulizer. I haven’t been this well in years. I had to talk my doctor into trying it and he sent me to Cleveland Clinic for an assessment.  The doctor there said he didn’t know if it would help but he was willing to give it a try. If I’m still doing OK in two months, I’m writing him a letter. This may not work for everyone but it works for me and that’s all I care about. Sue Any takers? Pete

Response:

Sue, Nobody is discussing the situation that you describe – where you are ON MEDICATION – it is likely you are making life unpleasant for both the good bacteria, and the bad bacteria that may be contributing to asthma. The real test will come when you are off medication – and have been off for say 12 months. See what happens then. Our experience is that that the asthmatic condition returns to approximately the same extent that it occurred before, and may even be worsened. The theory (pet theory as labelled by Colin) is that Biaxin will have killed off the helpful bacteria, while allowing the bad bacteria to thrive. Take someone in India or Nigeria who has never taken any of these drugs, and lived off poorly cooked food, cooked over smokey stoves fuelled by cow-dung, most will have no asthma. But give them a strong dose of Biaxin (or drug from similar family), and a significant number will develop asthma. (http://www.new-asthma.uk.net for coverage of the bad bacteria)

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Oddly enough, I’m on the experimental antibiotic treatment for asthma. I’ve been taking Biaxin (spelling)500mg twice a day for two months. I’m supposed to take it for another two months. When I started, I was diagnosed as a Severe Chronic Brittle Asthmatic and, even though I was on every asthma medication, my asthma was still not under control. Now, I’m fine.  I’m not wheezing.  I’m not short of breath.  I’m not using any of my inhalers or my nebulizer. I haven’t been this well in years. I had to talk my doctor into trying it and he sent me to Cleveland Clinic for an assessment.  The doctor there said he didn’t know if it would help but he was willing to give it a try. If I’m still doing OK in two months, I’m writing him a letter. This may not work for everyone but it works for me and that’s all I care about. Sue Any takers? Pete

Response:

Absolutely agree. We are now fully cured of asthma that affected myself and one daughter, and in trying to understand how the treatment worked in our cases, we researched a large number of scientific papers which gave an explanation of a) how the treatment worked and b) how the asthma arose in the first place. There is a lot of evidence to show that the cause of asthma in our cases had been brought on by prevalant use of penicillins – which had distorted the established bacterial flora and fauna to allow irritant anaerobic bacteria to thrive. The process is reversible – which is what we did. We used treatment to reduce the anerobic bacterial population, and since then try to avoid drug all treatments of any kind – hopefully we have returned to "normal" bacterial balance – as still exists in some of the primitive parts of the 3rd world. There’s no sign of asthma at all, ever. I’ve since been driving a mini-campaign to fund research in this direction, with some success. There’s a very bad set of web-pages at http://www.new-asthma.uk.net  My health at age 57 is better now than at age 27.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers? Pete I’m beginning to feel like a demographic statistic – broken down by age and sex.

Response:

"Woody Long" wrote Asthma is less commmon in poor countries where hygiene is worse, bacterial infections common and antibiotics unaffordable.  This in spite of the fact that air pollution is usually worse and nutrition is worse.

Absolutely right – why doesn’t someone research this point. Our findings – relate to increased prevalence of anaerobic bacteria in the human bacterial flora and fauna – that has occurred since use of penicillins became widespread since approx 1945. The presence of anaerobic bacteria was MARKEDLY less in 3rd world countries see following table of presence of Bacteroides (in 1987)     Finland 100%  - high incidence of asthma and allergies     UK 90%   – high incidence of asthma and allergies     Hong Kong 89%   – high incidence of asthma and allergies     USA 85%   – high incidence of asthma and allergies     Uganda 37%     India 30%   – low incidence of asthma and allergies     Nigeria 15%   – low incidence of asthma and allergies Figures now, 15 years later, should show much higher incidence in 3rd world countries because penicillins are now cheap, and available over-the-counter without prescription in such countries. Treatment against anaerobes cured our asthma. see http://www.new-asthma.uk.net if you are interested. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers? Well think about it. 1)  Asthma has increased dramatically along with the use of antibiotics. 2)  Exposure to certain types of bacteria in childhood reduce the risk of asthma 3) Asthma is less commmon in poor countries where hygiene is worse, bacterial infections common and antibiotics unaffordable.  This in spite of the fact that air pollution is usually worse and nutrition is worse. 4)  Fungus is implicated in asthma and chronic sinusitis 5)  Antibiotics promote the growth of fungus. 6)  Antibiotics affect or hinder the immune system in many ways which is why dotors use them to treat disease like rheumatoid arthritis even where no bacterias are present. Pete I’m beginning to feel like a demographic statistic – broken down by age and sex.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – 1)  Asthma has increased dramatically along with the use of antibiotics. And at the same time computer use has increased and pollution in the US has decreased.  Also the increase in the reported incidence of asthma has occurred at the same time the space shuttle has been in service. Your point being what?  You not seriously saying that space travel and computer use is a plausible alternative explanation for the increase of asthma? My point is that coincidence does not mean causation.  Just because two events occurred at the same time does not mean that they had anything to do with each other.

And you can make the same argument for the increased use of plastics in all areas of our lives. Sue – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – (I just got off 24-hour duty.  I am not going to read your stuff.) — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

The references look interesting, must look at the full papers. I think it was the term "hinder the immune system " in your original post in the thread that caused [me]concern. But it doesn’t look like feeding antibiotics to mice "hinders" the immune system, (arguably) quite the opposite, the immune systerm is rallying its resources, and one of the observed effects is an increase in IgE. In response to fewer bacteria being present, perhaps the fungi are throwing a party.. :-) ? And there you go, atopy, asthma and antibiotics! You’d think ALL those kids in West Africa would have succumed to alaphylaxis by the age of three – with all those peanuts they eat! Pete

<snipped Your point being what?  You not seriously saying that space travel and computer use is a plausible alternative explanation for the increase of asthma? Look what happens when you feed antibiotics to mice. IgE levels in the blood increase, and other immune parameters are perturbed (the first reference).  You could not ethically do such a study in humans, but retrospective analysis shows that use of antibiotics greatly increase the risk of atopic disease (second reference).  In fact I am surprised that the personal injury attorneys have not picked up the ball on this issue yet.

<snipped

Response:

Tom, A really interesting reference. But in utero…? At first sight it doesn’t quite fit my own personal preconceived model <g…… So, if one goes along with the data (which is actually quite startling) I would have to question experimental design and hence conclusions. Presumably the control group was age matched etc (duhh! – almost typed sex-matched, LOL). But was it also matched for socio-economic factors such as earnings, housing, nutrition, smoking etc. The pregnant mothers presumably were given antibiotics for a reason. Generally in the "developed" world (caveats, trade-marks etc. acknowledged) "poor" people earn less, live in poorer housing, eat worse and smoke more than "rich" people – hence they get sick more …. increased use of antibiotics and increased incidence of asthma, atopy etc may or may not then ensue. Pete

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers? Pete In utero exposure to antibiotics may increase risk of allergic disease Oct 10, 2002 – Lead author Tricia McKeever and colleagues, from the University of Nottingham in the UK, report their findings in the September 15th issue of the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. Because much of the immune system develops in utero, some experts speculate that "factors that modify microbial exposure at this time may have a long-term impact on the risk of developing allergic disease," McKeever and her team note. Still, research in this area has been limited. To investigate, the researchers reviewed the medical records of nearly 25,000 British children and their mothers to determine whether antibiotic exposure during pregnancy increased a child’s risk of developing asthma, eczema or hay fever. "Approximately one third of the mothers were prescribed one or more courses of antibiotics during pregnancy and this exposure was associated with an increased incidence of all three allergic disease," the authors write. In addition, infection during pregnancy was associated with a small increased risk of developing allergic disease. Children exposed to antibiotics in utero had a 68%, 56% and 17% increased risk of developing asthma, hay fever, and eczema, respectively, the findings indicate. "This effect did not appear to depend on the type of antibiotic or the trimester the antibiotics were prescribed in, but there was some evidence of a dose-response effect, especially for asthma," the researchers note. Since the use of antibiotics during pregnancy may have an effect on allergic disease, and such drug use is potentially avoidable, further research on prenatal antibiotic exposure and allergic disease is needed, the authors conclude. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2002;166:827-832. Tom Halpin

Response:

The references look interesting, must look at the full papers. I think it was the term "hinder the immune system " in your original post in the thread that caused [me]concern. But it doesn’t look like feeding antibiotics to mice "hinders" the immune system, (arguably) quite the opposite, the immune systerm is rallying its resources, and one of the observed effects is an increase in IgE. In response to fewer bacteria being present, perhaps the fungi are throwing a party.. :-) ?

IIRC, IgE protects against parasitic infections – not fungal. — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss…

Oddly enough, I’m on the experimental antibiotic treatment for asthma. I’ve been taking Biaxin (spelling)500mg twice a day for two months. I’m supposed to take it for another two months. When I started, I was diagnosed as a Severe Chronic Brittle Asthmatic and, even though I was on every asthma medication, my asthma was still not under control. Now, I’m fine.  I’m not wheezing.  I’m not short of breath.  I’m not using any of my inhalers or my nebulizer. I haven’t been this well in years. I had to talk my doctor into trying it and he sent me to Cleveland Clinic for an assessment.  The doctor there said he didn’t know if it would help but he was willing to give it a try. If I’m still doing OK in two months, I’m writing him a letter. This may not work for everyone but it works for me and that’s all I care about. Sue – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Any takers? Pete

Response:

In order (rather than loose them in the text): Colin, your quite correct: I wish I could recall the "erroneous" correlation between hat size and something amusingly unlikely that was cited in a stats module I took decades ago. At 95% confidence limit one will ALWAYS turn up an "erroneous" correlation one time in twenty. However to dismiss it out of hand is to fall into exactly the same trap as to blindly believe it. Well – theories come and go, some re-emerge and become "fact" other deservedly fall by the way-side, others such as escapees from a.s.a.b. continue to plague us. To discount it, however, because it is "only" a theory and currently out of favour… (see above). All scientific "fact" started as a theory. Child mortality – sounds a good, probably a reasonable assumption in the developing world. Empirically however, in the last 40-50 years the incidence of asthma has increased about 10 fold, has child mortality fallen by an equivalent amount? Fungus, which one? Personally, I would probably go for C. albicans (thrush). But I admit that is my own "personal" hobby horse/culprit/villain – some of the time. Growth promotion? I’d say that antibiotics "facilitate" fungal growth. In any habitat there is a limited supply of resources (space, nutrients etc.). Bacteria and fungi compete for these resources, wipe out (some) bacteria – more resources are available for (more) fungi …so they flourish… Antibiotics hindering the immune system? Hmm… bit of a generalization! I think I’m with Colin on this one – what leads you to making this assertion? So how about allergies, asthma and antibiotics then? Pete

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers? Well think about it. 1)  Asthma has increased dramatically along with the use of antibiotics. And at the same time computer use has increased and pollution in the US has decreased.  Also the increase in the reported incidence of asthma has occurred at the same time the space shuttle has been in service. You are assuming that two events that occur at the same time are related. 2)  Exposure to certain types of bacteria in childhood reduce the risk of asthma This theory has fallen out of favor. 3) Asthma is less commmon in poor countries where hygiene is worse, bacterial infections common and antibiotics unaffordable.  This in spite of the fact that air pollution is usually worse and nutrition is worse. And a higher incidence of child mortality kills the asthmatics before they can be diagnosed. 4)  Fungus is implicated in asthma and chronic sinusitis Only in some instances. 5)  Antibiotics promote the growth of fungus. Not necessarily. 6)  Antibiotics affect or hinder the immune system in many ways which is why dotors use them to treat disease like rheumatoid arthritis even where no bacterias are present. References? — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

1)  Asthma has increased dramatically along with the use of antibiotics. And at the same time computer use has increased and pollution in the US has decreased.  Also the increase in the reported incidence of asthma has occurred at the same time the space shuttle has been in service. Your point being what?  You not seriously saying that space travel and computer use is a plausible alternative explanation for the increase of asthma?

My point is that coincidence does not mean causation.  Just because two events occurred at the same time does not mean that they had anything to do with each other. (I just got off 24-hour duty.  I am not going to read your stuff.) — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers? Well think about it. 1)  Asthma has increased dramatically along with the use of antibiotics. And at the same time computer use has increased and pollution in the US has decreased.  Also the increase in the reported incidence of asthma has occurred at the same time the space shuttle has been in service.

Your point being what?  You not seriously saying that space travel and computer use is a plausible alternative explanation for the increase of asthma? Look what happens when you feed antibiotics to mice. IgE levels in the blood increase, and other immune parameters are perturbed (the first reference).  You could not ethically do such a study in humans, but retrospective analysis shows that use of antibiotics greatly increase the risk of atopic disease (second reference).  In fact I am surprised that the personal injury attorneys have not picked up the ball on this issue yet. J Allergy Clin Immunol 2001 Jan;107(1):153-9 Related Articles, Links   Antibiotic use during infancy promotes a shift in the T(H)1/T(H)2 balance toward T(H)2-dominant immunity in mice. Oyama N, Sudo N, Sogawa H, Kubo C. Department of Psychosomatic Medicine, Graduate School of Medical Sciences, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, Japan. BACKGROUND: Recent epidemiologic studies indicate that antibiotic use in infancy may be associated with an increased risk of development of atopy; however, its precise mechanism remains to be elucidated. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study is to clarify whether one such antibiotic, kanamycin, affects the T(H)1/T(H)2 balance. METHODS: BALB/c mice at 3 and 52 weeks of age were orally administered 600 mg/d kanamycin sulfate for 7 consecutive days. Blood samples were collected on weeks 0, 10, 18, and 26 after the cessation of kanamycin treatment, and the effect of the kanamycin treatment on the T(H)1/T(H)2 balance was evaluated on the basis of both the in vivo antibody levels and the in vitro splenocyte cytokine secretion pattern. RESULTS: The administration of kanamycin increased the serum levels of total IgG1 and IgE while decreasing the serum IgG2a levels. Moreover, when spleen cells were stimulated with immobilized anti-CD3 antibody in vitro, such kanamycin treatment enhanced the in vitro IL-4 secretion while reducing the in vitro IFN-gamma secretion. The basal IL-12 p70 secretion levels of splenic dendritic cells in the kanamycin-treated mice were lower than those in the control mice, although no significant difference was seen in IL-12 p40 levels between either group of mice. CONCLUSION: These results suggested that antibiotic use during infancy may indeed quantitatively disturb, qualitatively disturb, or both the intestinal microflora and thereby prevent postnatal T(H)1 cell maturation, thus resulting in a T(H)2-polarized immune deviation.  J Allergy Clin Immunol 2002 Jan;109(1):43-50 Related Articles, Links Early exposure to infections and antibiotics and the incidence of allergic disease: a birth cohort study with the West Midlands General Practice Research Database. McKeever TM, Lewis SA, Smith C, Collins J, Heatlie H, Frischer M, Hubbard R. Division of Respiratory Medicine, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom. BACKGROUND: It has been suggested that the rise in prevalence of allergic disease in westernized countries is due in part to a decrease in exposure to infections and an increase in the use of antibiotics early in life. OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this investigation was to quantify the relationships between (1) exposure to personal infections, infections in siblings, and use of antibiotics in early life and (2) the incidence of allergic disease. METHODS: Using the West Midlands section of the UK General Practice Research Database, we established a historical birth cohort of children (N = 29,238). For each child, we identified all personal infections and infections in siblings and determined the use of antibiotics in early life; we also noted incident diagnoses of asthma, eczema, and hay fever. The data were analyzed through use of Cox regression. RESULTS: There was no clear protective effect of exposure to either personal infections or infections in siblings with respect to the incidence of allergic disease. Antibiotic exposure was associated with an increased risk of developing allergic disease in a dose-related manner: having 4 or more courses of antibiotics in the first year of life was associated with an increased incidence of asthma (hazard ratio [HR], 3.13; 95% CI, 2.75-3.57), eczema (HR, 1.48; 95% CI, 1.31-1.68), and hay fever (HR, 2.12; 95% CI, 1.68-2.66). However, adjusting for consulting behavior reduced these effects (adjusted HR [95% CI]: asthma, 1.99 [1.72-2.31]; eczema, 1.01 [0.88-1.17]; hay fever, 1.14 [0.88-1.47]). CONCLUSIONS: We found no evidence that exposure to infections reduced the incidence of allergic disease, and infections did not explain the previous findings of a strong birth order effect in this cohort. The use of antibiotics might be associated with early diagnoses of allergic disease. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – You are assuming that two events that occur at the same time are related. 2)  Exposure to certain types of bacteria in childhood reduce the risk of asthma This theory has fallen out of favor. 3) Asthma is less commmon in poor countries where hygiene is worse, bacterial infections common and antibiotics unaffordable.  This in spite of the fact that air pollution is usually worse and nutrition is worse. And a higher incidence of child mortality kills the asthmatics before they can be diagnosed. 4)  Fungus is implicated in asthma and chronic sinusitis Only in some instances. 5)  Antibiotics promote the growth of fungus. Not necessarily. 6)  Antibiotics affect or hinder the immune system in many ways which is why dotors use them to treat disease like rheumatoid arthritis even where no bacterias are present. References? — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

In my opinion there’s definately a link between asthma and bacteria.  So in reference to the statement "Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma"  I’d have to say that that’s a very real possibility.

Care to post your credentials so we can know what weight to give to your opinions? FYI you are beginning to sound like just another mission-poster with a pet theory. — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers? Pete

In utero exposure to antibiotics may increase risk of allergic disease Oct 10, 2002 – Lead author Tricia McKeever and colleagues, from the University of Nottingham in the UK, report their findings in the September 15th issue of the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. Because much of the immune system develops in utero, some experts speculate that "factors that modify microbial exposure at this time may have a long-term impact on the risk of developing allergic disease," McKeever and her team note. Still, research in this area has been limited. To investigate, the researchers reviewed the medical records of nearly 25,000 British children and their mothers to determine whether antibiotic exposure during pregnancy increased a child’s risk of developing asthma, eczema or hay fever. "Approximately one third of the mothers were prescribed one or more courses of antibiotics during pregnancy and this exposure was associated with an increased incidence of all three allergic disease," the authors write. In addition, infection during pregnancy was associated with a small increased risk of developing allergic disease. Children exposed to antibiotics in utero had a 68%, 56% and 17% increased risk of developing asthma, hay fever, and eczema, respectively, the findings indicate. "This effect did not appear to depend on the type of antibiotic or the trimester the antibiotics were prescribed in, but there was some evidence of a dose-response effect, especially for asthma," the researchers note. Since the use of antibiotics during pregnancy may have an effect on allergic disease, and such drug use is potentially avoidable, further research on prenatal antibiotic exposure and allergic disease is needed, the authors conclude. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2002;166:827-832. Tom Halpin

Response:

In my opinion there’s definately a link between asthma and bacteria.  So in reference to the statement "Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma"  I’d have to say that that’s a very real possibility. From visitors to my website http://www.AsthmaStory.com  I’ve heard interesting stories from those who are battling these bacteria successfully using long term antibiotic therapy.   These people (and myself) were able to kill the chlamydia pneumoniae or mycoplasm in their bodies and then their asthma completely went away.  Completely … 100%. However,  I’ve also heard from a few who started out with extremely severe asthma and were just about back to being asthma free when the bacteria went totally immune to the antibiotic they were taking.  They needed to change to different antibiotic. Interestingly enough, every person I’ve corresponded with (from the website) with asthma that took a blood test to determine if they had the bacteria chlamydia pneumoniae or mycoplasm has tested positive.  Then again, maybe some tested negative and I just didn’t hear about it. Jim Quinlan http://www.AsthmaStory.com

Response:

Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers? Well think about it. 1)  Asthma has increased dramatically along with the use of antibiotics.

And at the same time computer use has increased and pollution in the US has decreased.  Also the increase in the reported incidence of asthma has occurred at the same time the space shuttle has been in service. You are assuming that two events that occur at the same time are related. 2)  Exposure to certain types of bacteria in childhood reduce the risk of asthma

This theory has fallen out of favor. 3) Asthma is less commmon in poor countries where hygiene is worse, bacterial infections common and antibiotics unaffordable.  This in spite of the fact that air pollution is usually worse and nutrition is worse.

And a higher incidence of child mortality kills the asthmatics before they can be diagnosed. 4)  Fungus is implicated in asthma and chronic sinusitis

Only in some instances. 5)  Antibiotics promote the growth of fungus.

Not necessarily. 6)  Antibiotics affect or hinder the immune system in many ways which is why dotors use them to treat disease like rheumatoid arthritis even where no bacterias are present.

References? — "We are fighting today for security, for progress, and for peace, not only for ourselves but for all men, not only for one generation but for all generations. We are fighting to cleanse the world of ancient evils, ancient ills." Franklin Delano Rosevelt State of the Union Address – 1942

Response:

Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers? Pete I’m beginning to feel like a demographic statistic – broken down by age and sex.

Response:

Antibiotics as a causative contributory factor in the development of asthma: discuss… Any takers?

Well think about it. 1)  Asthma has increased dramatically along with the use of antibiotics. 2)  Exposure to certain types of bacteria in childhood reduce the risk of asthma 3) Asthma is less commmon in poor countries where hygiene is worse, bacterial infections common and antibiotics unaffordable.  This in spite of the fact that air pollution is usually worse and nutrition is worse. 4)  Fungus is implicated in asthma and chronic sinusitis 5)  Antibiotics promote the growth of fungus. 6)  Antibiotics affect or hinder the immune system in many ways which is why dotors use them to treat disease like rheumatoid arthritis even where no bacterias are present. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Pete I’m beginning to feel like a demographic statistic – broken down by age and sex.

Response:

Inhalers… how much is too much?

Question:

I sure am Patrice. But mostly I was talking about the people in the battlefield. Do you think that you are going to walk away from a nerve gas attack next time some nutcase blows up a nerve gas bomb in your neighborhood? I really do not think that I would survive a sudden nerve gas attack if I were to be in the same breathing space as the gas was floating in.

Neither do I.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –             <snip When people talk about high or frequent dosing of rescue inhalers as being dangerous they mean that it is a marker of a problem that should be better addressed. There is some evidence that chronically high doses of rescue meds may have a more direct detrimental effect. — CBI, MD     Could you please give us more of an idea of just what these "detrimental effects" might be?    Speaking strictly for myself, I find high doses of rescue meds cause my heart to "flutter",  I get light headed, and blood pressure (already *much* too high) to soar.    Comments???

That is pretty much it. There is speculation, but little hard evidence, that the chronic overstimulation of the heart can cause a cardiomyopathy (big word meaning literally "heart problem"). Some have taken this a step further and speculated that the cardiomyopathy then predisposes the heart to lethal heart rhythms and sudden death. Some speculate that this may be one mechanism of death in people who chronically take high doses of beta agonists. All we know for sure is that asthmatics who chronically take high doses of inhaled beta agonists have an increased incidence of death. Personally, I think it is far more likely that the deaths are directly related to out of control asthma and lack of oxygen and see no need to manufacture theories about how it is the drug. Either way if the asthma is controlled the heart problems and sudden death should not occur. — CBI, MD

Response:

I sure am Patrice. But mostly I was talking about the people in the battlefield. Do you think that you are going to walk away from a nerve gas attack next time some nutcase blows up a nerve gas bomb in your neighborhood? I really do not think that I would survive a sudden nerve gas attack if I were to be in the same breathing space as the gas was floating in. Signature To Chat With A LIVE Sales Person { NOW ! } Click On The Box To The Right Add the HumanClick "Click to Chat" button to your own e-mails for free at www.humanclick.com

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Im sorry to burst some of your bubbles, but your dreaming if you think that any of you are going to survive a nerve gas attack.  You can train for this for months on end, but when the fat lady sings most of you would end up dead and dying like fish out of water gasping for air. When you refer to "any of you" and "most of you" are you referring to the human population?  If so, aren’t  you referring to yourself as well? Patrice

Response:

By the way,I never dodged the draft. Look who’s the yellow belly. Your so yellow, you have to use a fake ID tag in your post. Signature To Chat With A LIVE Sales Person { NOW ! } Click On The Box To The Right Add the HumanClick "Click to Chat" button to your own e-mails for free at www.humanclick.com

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – NOTICE: This message may not have been sent by the Sender Name above.  Always use cryptographic digital signatures to verify the identity of the sender of any usenet post or e-mail. Like I said, training for an attack is one thing. Living through a sudden nerve gas attack in the heat of battle in a whole other story.I feel that your casualty and kill numbers will fall apart in the heat of a full blown attack.Many would die even before the gas was detected and the information could be passed to all of the troops in the affected area. First of all there are different types of agents that can be exploded. Some will penetrate the epidermis and some are corrosive to both the skin and lungs.I always understood that the gas that was used in training was only an irritant gas. Are you telling me that you were exposed to an actual Nerve Gas Agent that would kill you if you panicked during the test ? Somehow I doubt that you were exposed to a deadly nerve gas agent in your training colon.. Go ahead and take your turn. combat advice from a yellow belly draft dodger

Response:

Colon, I think that I will stick to my opinion.I do not agree with you. People get very frustrated and screw up alot in the heat of battle. In Iraq and Kuwait, more Americans were killed by each other then by the enemy If you ever get yourself knocked off from a gas attack, you can tell me about the details in the next world if you make it there. Signature To Chat With A LIVE Sales Person { NOW ! } Click On The Box To The Right Add the HumanClick "Click to Chat" button to your own e-mails for free at www.humanclick.com

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Like I said, training for an attack is one thing. Living through a sudden nerve gas attack in the heat of battle in a whole other story.I feel that your casualty and kill numbers will fall apart in the heat of a full blown attack.Many would die even before the gas was detected and the information could be passed to all of the troops in the affected area. First of all there are different types of agents that can be exploded. And the _issue_ protective gear will protect against all of these. What is your basis for the claim that many people will die before the agent is detected?  Are you aware of what methods are used to detect these agents (and the stand-off)?  Do you know what procedures are used to warn of an imminent or in-progress attack?  Are you aware of how fast a company level unit can get everybody into gas masks? Or is this hot air? Do you really think that you know more about this subject than I? Some will penetrate the epidermis and some are corrosive to both the skin and lungs.I always understood that the gas that was used in training was only an irritant gas. There are a number of different agents.  The agents that penetrate the skin are not very lethal as this is a slow process which requires you to physically come into contact with the liquid or solid. Every soldier is issued protective over garments and a skin decontamination kit (as well as antidote autoinjectors). Are you telling me that you were exposed to an actual Nerve Gas Agent that would kill you if you panicked during the test ? Somehow I doubt that you were exposed to a deadly nerve gas agent in your training colon.. Go ahead and take your turn. It was a type ‘G’ (persistent) nerve agent.  (Actually wouldn’t have killed me as there were instructors and medical support standing by). "The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has limits." Einstein

Response:

Like I said, training for an attack is one thing. Living through a sudden nerve gas attack in the heat of battle in a whole other story.I feel that your casualty and kill numbers will fall apart in the heat of a full blown attack.Many would die even before the gas was detected and the information could be passed to all of the troops in the affected area. First of all there are different types of agents that can be exploded.

And the _issue_ protective gear will protect against all of these. What is your basis for the claim that many people will die before the agent is detected?  Are you aware of what methods are used to detect these agents (and the stand-off)?  Do you know what procedures are used to warn of an imminent or in-progress attack?  Are you aware of how fast a company level unit can get everybody into gas masks? Or is this hot air? Do you really think that you know more about this subject than I? Some will penetrate the epidermis and some are corrosive to both the skin and lungs.I always understood that the gas that was used in training was only an irritant gas.

There are a number of different agents.  The agents that penetrate the skin are not very lethal as this is a slow process which requires you to physically come into contact with the liquid or solid. Every soldier is issued protective over garments and a skin decontamination kit (as well as antidote autoinjectors).   Are you telling me that you were exposed to an actual Nerve Gas Agent that would kill you if you panicked during the test ? Somehow I doubt that you were exposed to a deadly nerve gas agent in your training colon.. Go ahead and take your turn.

It was a type ‘G’ (persistent) nerve agent.  (Actually wouldn’t have killed me as there were instructors and medical support standing by). "The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has limits." Einstein

Response:

            <snip When people talk about high or frequent dosing of rescue inhalers as being dangerous they mean that it is a marker of a problem that should be better addressed. There is some evidence that chronically high doses of rescue meds may have a more direct detrimental effect. — CBI, MD

    Could you please give us more of an idea of just what these "detrimental effects" might be?    Speaking strictly for myself, I find high doses of rescue meds cause my heart to "flutter",  I get light headed, and blood pressure (already *much* too high) to soar.    Comments??? Later…             Ray

Response:

NOTICE: This message may not have been sent by the Sender Name above.  Always use cryptographic digital signatures to verify the identity of the sender of any usenet post or e-mail. Like I said, training for an attack is one thing. Living through a sudden nerve gas attack in the heat of battle in a whole other story.I feel that your casualty and kill numbers will fall apart in the heat of a full blown attack.Many would die even before the gas was detected and the information could be passed to all of the troops in the affected area. First of all there are different types of agents that can be exploded. Some will penetrate the epidermis and some are corrosive to both the skin and lungs.I always understood that the gas that was used in training was only an irritant gas. Are you telling me that you were exposed to an actual Nerve Gas Agent that would kill you if you panicked during the test ? Somehow I doubt that you were exposed to a deadly nerve gas agent in your training colon.. Go ahead and take your turn.

combat advice from a yellow belly draft dodger

Response:

Im sorry to burst some of your bubbles, but your dreaming if you think that any of you are going to survive a nerve gas attack.

 You can train for this for months on end, but when the fat lady sings most of you would end up dead and dying like fish out of water gasping for air.

When you refer to "any of you" and "most of you" are you referring to the human population?  If so, aren’t  you referring to yourself as well? Patrice

Response:

Like I said, training for an attack is one thing. Living through a sudden nerve gas attack in the heat of battle in a whole other story.I feel that your casualty and kill numbers will fall apart in the heat of a full blown attack.Many would die even before the gas was detected and the information could be passed to all of the troops in the affected area. First of all there are different types of agents that can be exploded. Some will penetrate the epidermis and some are corrosive to both the skin and lungs.I always understood that the gas that was used in training was only an irritant gas. Are you telling me that you were exposed to an actual Nerve Gas Agent that would kill you if you panicked during the test ? Somehow I doubt that you were exposed to a deadly nerve gas agent in your training colon.. Go ahead and take your turn. Signature To Chat With A LIVE Sales Person { NOW ! } Click On The Box To The Right Add the HumanClick "Click to Chat" button to your own e-mails for free at www.humanclick.com

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – lungs.Even in battle, the majority of prepared troops would drop like flies in a nerve gas attack due to the anti- gas drugs just not working good enough or fast enough, confusion and lack of warning. You can train for this for months on end, but when the fat lady sings most of you would end up dead and dying like fish out of water gasping for air. Sorry,  Pray For Peace ! Are you aware that US Army chemical warfare protection specialists train with _live_ agent?  (This is the final exam at the school.) All US soldiers are given extensive training in CW/BW defense.  Every unit emplaces CW/BW detector units during field training and at higher level there is gear with remote detection capability. The M1A1/2 tanks in use have an over pressurization system (that also functions as an air conditioner) that provides a ’shirtsleeve’ environment inside the tank during CW/BW attack.  And the tank remains fully battle ready.  (Part of the Tank Crew qualification Tables test the crews ability to fight the tank while wearing gas masks.) US Army estimates are that we will take 10% casualties (2% fatal) from the first attack with CW, from then on we expect each attack to take 2-4% casualties.  The fact that our soldiers can not only protect themselves from chemical attack but continue to fight is considered to be an important deterrent to an enemy considering the use of CW/BW weapons (all he will accomplish will be to _really_ piss us off). Of course, I’ve only been a soldier for close to 20 years (and been to NBC defense school).  What are your qualifications to an opinion on this subject? Trivia note:  US policy is:  If we are attacked by any weapon of mass destruction, we will respond in an _overwhelming manner_ with our own weapons of mass destruction. "The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has limits." Einstein

Response:

lungs.Even in battle, the majority of prepared troops would drop like flies in a nerve gas attack due to the anti- gas drugs just not working good enough or fast enough, confusion and lack of warning. You can train for this for months on end, but when the fat lady sings most of you would end up dead and dying like fish out of water gasping for air. Sorry,  Pray For Peace !

Are you aware that US Army chemical warfare protection specialists train with _live_ agent?  (This is the final exam at the school.) All US soldiers are given extensive training in CW/BW defense.  Every unit emplaces CW/BW detector units during field training and at higher level there is gear with remote detection capability. The M1A1/2 tanks in use have an over pressurization system (that also functions as an air conditioner) that provides a ’shirtsleeve’ environment inside the tank during CW/BW attack.  And the tank remains fully battle ready.  (Part of the Tank Crew qualification Tables test the crews ability to fight the tank while wearing gas masks.) US Army estimates are that we will take 10% casualties (2% fatal) from the first attack with CW, from then on we expect each attack to take 2-4% casualties.  The fact that our soldiers can not only protect themselves from chemical attack but continue to fight is considered to be an important deterrent to an enemy considering the use of CW/BW weapons (all he will accomplish will be to _really_ piss us off). Of course, I’ve only been a soldier for close to 20 years (and been to NBC defense school).  What are your qualifications to an opinion on this subject? Trivia note:  US policy is:  If we are attacked by any weapon of mass destruction, we will respond in an _overwhelming manner_ with our own weapons of mass destruction. "The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has limits." Einstein

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – It takes _massive_ amounts of atropine to counteract the effects of a nerve agent.  The US army uses autoinjectors (somewhat like epi-pens) for first aid for nerve agent exposure.  There are two injectors, the first is atropine, and the second contains an antidote for the first. Using the nerve agent antidote if you have not been exposed to nerve gas is very dangerous. The epi-pens used to self-administer epinephrine to people with life threatening allergies are an adaptation of the devices the military invented to allow troops to self-administer atropine. — CBI, MD

Thanks for that bit of history – I didn’t know that. As it seems to me that the Epi-Pen goes back at least 25 years, I wonder if its predecessor (the atropine autoinjector) was developed for WWII, or for Korea or Vietnam? If for atropine, my guess would be WWII.     Larry

Response:

Im sorry to burst some of your bubbles, but your dreaming if you think that any of you are going to survive a nerve gas attack. One breath and you have bought the farm. Your chance of survival is very limited do to the fact that you will have to continue keep breathing the gas from lack of a handy dandy gas mask and a chemical body suit within your easy reach. Remember that many of these gases will also asorb into your skin as well as into your lungs.Even in battle, the majority of prepared troops would drop like flies in a nerve gas attack due to the anti- gas drugs just not working good enough or fast enough, confusion and lack of warning. You can train for this for months on end, but when the fat lady sings most of you would end up dead and dying like fish out of water gasping for air. Sorry,  Pray For Peace ! Signature To Chat With A LIVE Sales Person { NOW ! } Click On The Box To The Right Add the HumanClick "Click to Chat" button to your own e-mails for free at www.humanclick.com

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I doubt asthmatics will find themselves in an advantageous possition if terrorists use any kind of gas or respiratory infectious agent. — CNI, MD Not too long ago my sister’s good friend (a critical care nurse) in Minneapolis was at a meeting addressing all the issues involved with planning for treatment of casualties from a biological terrorist attack. Since there are limited meds available to counteract these agents, the healthy people would get them first.  Those without chronic illness.  So I asked "I guess that means we 17 million asthmatics are out of luck"?  The answer was at this point, yes. Patrice

Response:

It takes _massive_ amounts of atropine to counteract the effects of a nerve agent.  The US army uses autoinjectors (somewhat like epi-pens) for first aid for nerve agent exposure.  There are two injectors, the first is atropine, and the second contains an antidote for the first. Using the nerve agent antidote if you have not been exposed to nerve gas is very dangerous.

The epi-pens used to self-administer epinephrine to people with life threatening allergies are an adaptation of the devices the military invented to allow troops to self-administer atropine. — CBI, MD

Response:

I doubt asthmatics will find themselves in an advantageous possition if terrorists use any kind of gas or respiratory infectious agent. — CNI, MD

Not too long ago my sister’s good friend (a critical care nurse) in Minneapolis was at a meeting addressing all the issues involved with planning for treatment of casualties from a biological terrorist attack. Since there are limited meds available to counteract these agents, the healthy people would get them first.  Those without chronic illness.  So I asked "I guess that means we 17 million asthmatics are out of luck"?  The answer was at this point, yes. Patrice

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – . . . . When the child goes to the hospital with an attack what they will do is keep giving this same reliever medicine (in nebulised form), as well as others, until he is better. In this sense it is not likely to O.D. on it and the risks of this certainly are less then the risks of not giving the meds during an acute attack. This is not to say there will be no side effects. You should understand the context. You have recognized that the child is having a severe attack and EMS has been activated. You give these doses while waiting for the ambulance to arrive. This is not the same as saying it is O.K to just give the child high doses of the meds with no contact with the doctor. By the way, with all this talk of terrorism like that nerve gas incident in the Tokyo subway: I heard that nerve gas kills a person by causing severe bronchospasm. The "mother of all asthma attacks," your lungs quickly fill with secretions and you suffocate. If terrorists ever struck a major metropolitan area with nerve gas, the asthmatics would survive because they could use their rescue inhalers. (And offer their inhalers to their friends as well.)  But it would certainly take much more than the usual two puffs to stabilize you after a nerve gas exposure.  In such a case, I would just keep on puffing until I felt better.

Bronchospasm may be one of the mecahnisms but there are others. I doubt asthmatics will find themselves in an advantageous possition if terrorists use any kind of gas or respiratory infectious agent. — CNI, MD

Response:

By the way, with all this talk of terrorism like that nerve gas incident in the Tokyo subway: I heard that nerve gas kills a person by causing severe bronchospasm. The "mother of all asthma attacks," your lungs quickly fill with secretions and you suffocate.

Nerve gas kills by interfering with the functioning of the nervous system.  There is a chemical that passes impulses between nerve cells and nerve gas blocks its action. If terrorists ever struck a major metropolitan area with nerve gas, the asthmatics would survive because they could use their rescue inhalers. (And offer their inhalers to their friends as well.)  But it would certainly take much more than the usual two puffs to stabilize you after a nerve gas exposure.  In such a case, I would just keep on puffing until I felt better.

It takes _massive_ amounts of atropine to counteract the effects of a nerve agent.  The US army uses autoinjectors (somewhat like epi-pens) for first aid for nerve agent exposure.  There are two injectors, the first is atropine, and the second contains an antidote for the first. Using the nerve agent antidote if you have not been exposed to nerve gas is very dangerous. BTW, the chemicals in the nerve agent antidote only counteract the effects of the nerve agent – you have to go to a hospital where you will be given the actual antidote (phosgene bromide?). "The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has limits." Einstein

Response:

I don’t think from what I read, that nerve gas works in a way that would be counteracted effectively by a "rescue" inhaler typical for asthma. I suspect that Ipratropium bromide (Atrovent), or something of that nature might work better, this means those with COPD are likely to do better than the asthmatics. I hope I never know. Boyd — "The cure for boredom is curiosity. There is no cure for curiosity." (Ellen Parr- author)

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – If terrorists ever struck a major metropolitan area with nerve gas, the asthmatics would survive because they could use their rescue inhalers. (And offer their inhalers to their friends as well.)  But it would certainly take much more than the usual two puffs to stabilize you after a nerve gas exposure.  In such a case, I would just keep on puffing until I felt better. …and then you would probably die from an inhaler overdose anyway. Chris — Chris King http://www.csking.co.uk

Response:

Yea Steve, Sort of like putting out a forest fire with a water pistol. Signature To Chat With A LIVE Sales Person { NOW ! } Click On The Box To The Right Add the HumanClick "Click to Chat" button to your own e-mails for free at www.humanclick.com

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – . . . . When the child goes to the hospital with an attack what they will do is keep giving this same reliever medicine (in nebulised form), as well as others, until he is better. In this sense it is not likely to O.D. on it and the risks of this certainly are less then the risks of not giving the meds during an acute attack. This is not to say there will be no side effects. You should understand the context. You have recognized that the child is having a severe attack and EMS has been activated. You give these doses while waiting for the ambulance to arrive. This is not the same as saying it is O.K to just give the child high doses of the meds with no contact with the doctor. By the way, with all this talk of terrorism like that nerve gas incident in the Tokyo subway: I heard that nerve gas kills a person by causing severe bronchospasm. The "mother of all asthma attacks," your lungs quickly fill with secretions and you suffocate. If terrorists ever struck a major metropolitan area with nerve gas, the asthmatics would survive because they could use their rescue inhalers. (And offer their inhalers to their friends as well.)  But it would certainly take much more than the usual two puffs to stabilize you after a nerve gas exposure.  In such a case, I would just keep on puffing until I felt better. — Steven D. Litvintchouk "I guess I could have paid a little closer attention when I was in English class, but it all worked out OK.  I’m gainfully employed."      – President George W. Bush

Response:

That was as smart as steves post ! Signature To Chat With A LIVE Sales Person { NOW ! } Click On The Box To The Right Add the HumanClick "Click to Chat" button to your own e-mails for free at www.humanclick.com

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – If terrorists ever struck a major metropolitan area with nerve gas, the asthmatics would survive because they could use their rescue inhalers. (And offer their inhalers to their friends as well.)  But it would certainly take much more than the usual two puffs to stabilize you after a nerve gas exposure.  In such a case, I would just keep on puffing until I felt better. …and then you would probably die from an inhaler overdose anyway. Chris — Chris King http://www.csking.co.uk

Response:

If terrorists ever struck a major metropolitan area with nerve gas, the asthmatics would survive because they could use their rescue inhalers. (And offer their inhalers to their friends as well.)  But it would certainly take much more than the usual two puffs to stabilize you after a nerve gas exposure.  In such a case, I would just keep on puffing until I felt better.

…and then you would probably die from an inhaler overdose anyway. Chris — Chris King http://www.csking.co.uk

Response:

. . . . When the child goes to the hospital with an attack what they will do is keep giving this same reliever medicine (in nebulised form), as well as others, until he is better. In this sense it is not likely to O.D. on it and the risks of this certainly are less then the risks of not giving the meds during an acute attack. This is not to say there will be no side effects. You should understand the context. You have recognized that the child is having a severe attack and EMS has been activated. You give these doses while waiting for the ambulance to arrive. This is not the same as saying it is O.K to just give the child high doses of the meds with no contact with the doctor.

By the way, with all this talk of terrorism like that nerve gas incident in the Tokyo subway: I heard that nerve gas kills a person by causing severe bronchospasm. The "mother of all asthma attacks," your lungs quickly fill with secretions and you suffocate. If terrorists ever struck a major metropolitan area with nerve gas, the asthmatics would survive because they could use their rescue inhalers. (And offer their inhalers to their friends as well.)  But it would certainly take much more than the usual two puffs to stabilize you after a nerve gas exposure.  In such a case, I would just keep on puffing until I felt better. — Steven D. Litvintchouk                   "I guess I could have paid a little closer attention when I was in English class, but it all worked out OK.  I’m gainfully employed."      – President George W. Bush

Response:

Hi Knox, Some of the OTC medications are very dangerous in high dosages, and have caused or contributed to deaths, including one high profile model a few years ago. But I am not aware of any prescription medications that will cause similar problems. Bob McConnell N2SPP – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Hi all, I came across this website which talked about what to do in the case of a bad asthma attack: "(3) Continue taking your reliever medication until help arrives; you cannot overdose on it, only help yourself. You can take 15 to 30 puffs one at a time with about 10 seconds in between each puff." — Source: http://www.asthmaassistant.com/tp3con/attack.html I thought that this wasn’t true… that it’s quite possible and dangerous to overdose on a quick relief inhaler in such a situation.  But then I read this other website after seaching for more info. Q What happens if a child takes too much reliever medication? Reliever medication is extremely safe. Although reliever inhalers should be treated as medication, teachers need not worry that a child may overdose on their reliever inhaler. Parents should be told when a child has used their reliever inhalers. Source: http://www.asthma.org.uk/infoxa07.html Can somebody clarify this?? Knox

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi all, I came across this website which talked about what to do in the case of a bad asthma attack: "(3) Continue taking your reliever medication until help arrives; you cannot overdose on it, only help yourself. You can take 15 to 30 puffs one at a time with about 10 seconds in between each puff." — Source: http://www.asthmaassistant.com/tp3con/attack.html I thought that this wasn’t true… that it’s quite possible and dangerous to overdose on a quick relief inhaler in such a situation.  But then I read this other website after seaching for more info. Q What happens if a child takes too much reliever medication? Reliever medication is extremely safe. Although reliever inhalers should be treated as medication, teachers need not worry that a child may overdose on their reliever inhaler. Parents should be told when a child has used their reliever inhalers. Source: http://www.asthma.org.uk/infoxa07.html

When the child goes to the hospital with an attack what they will do is keep giving this same reliever medicine (in nebulised form), as well as others, until he is better. In this sense it is not likely to O.D. on it and the risks of this certainly are less then the risks of not giving the meds during an acute attack. This is not to say there will be no side effects. You should understand the context. You have recognized that the child is having a severe attack and EMS has been activated. You give these doses while waiting for the ambulance to arrive. This is not the same as saying it is O.K to just give the child high doses of the meds with no contact with the doctor. When people talk about high or frequent dosing of rescue inhalers as being dangerous they mean that it is a marker of a problem that should be better addressed. There is some evidence that chronically high doses of rescue meds may have a more direct detrimental effect. — CBI, MD

Response:

Hi all, I came across this website which talked about what to do in the case of a bad asthma attack: "(3) Continue taking your reliever medication until help arrives; you cannot overdose on it, only help yourself. You can take 15 to 30 puffs one at a time with about 10 seconds in between each puff." — Source: http://www.asthmaassistant.com/tp3con/attack.html I thought that this wasn’t true… that it’s quite possible and dangerous to overdose on a quick relief inhaler in such a situation.  But then I read this other website after seaching for more info. Q What happens if a child takes too much reliever medication? Reliever medication is extremely safe. Although reliever inhalers should be treated as medication, teachers need not worry that a child may overdose on their reliever inhaler. Parents should be told when a child has used their reliever inhalers.

Source: http://www.asthma.org.uk/infoxa07.html Can somebody clarify this?? Knox

Response:

Couhging induced asthma query.

Question:

My 16 yr old recently suffered through a bout with bronchitis.  Since then, she has developed coughing spells which leave her breathless. This A.M., the duratrion and intensity of her incident was quite severe.  Our MD has prescribed an anti inflammatory inhaler as treatment.  My question(s) is (are), has anyone here experienced similar symptoms?  Will these symptoms subside?  Is there a specific terminology used to describe these symptoms?  Most importantly, what can one do to help her regain her breath and comfort her while she is suffering through this quite harrowing experience? TIA Before you buy.

Response:

My 16 yr old recently suffered through a bout with bronchitis.  Since then, she has developed coughing spells which leave her breathless. This A.M., the duratrion and intensity of her incident was quite severe.  Our MD has prescribed an anti inflammatory inhaler as treatment.  My question(s) is (are), has anyone here experienced similar symptoms?  

Oh yes.  I have, a couple of my friends have, and several folks on this NG apparently have, too. Will these symptoms subside?  

I wish I could say "yes," but I can’t be that definite.  In my case, after the bronchitis, I was left with adult-onset cough-variant asthma, which turned out to be permanent.  A friend of mine had a bad acute bronchitis, and she was left with adult-onset asthma too.  Another friend of mine had a bad acute bronchitis, and she was left with chronic bronchitis.  All of these permanent.  It may depend on how much damage and inflammation was done to the bronchial tubes and lungs.  Past a certain point, it seems to become chronic and irreversible.  Just hope, pray, and wait and see. Is there a specific terminology used to describe these symptoms?  

It could be – chronic bronchitis (COPD) – adult-onset cough-variant asthma – asthmatic bronchitis Most importantly, what can one do to help her regain her breath and comfort her while she is suffering through this quite harrowing experience?

Follow your physicians’ recommendations to the letter. If you love her (as I’m sure you do), you will find ways to help her get through it.  I know you will.  Good luck. — Steven D. Litvintchouk                   Disclaimer:  As far as I am aware, the opinions expressed herein             are not those of my employer.

Response:

My 16 yr old recently suffered through a bout with bronchitis.  Since then, she has developed coughing spells which leave her breathless. This A.M., the duratrion and intensity of her incident was quite severe.  Our MD has prescribed an anti inflammatory inhaler as treatment.  My question(s) is (are), has anyone here experienced similar symptoms?  Will these symptoms subside?  Is there a specific terminology used to describe these symptoms?  Most importantly, what can one do to help her regain her breath and comfort her while she is suffering through this quite harrowing experience?

Does she have asthma? Also:  (This Question is VERY important!) Did the doctor prescribe a ‘rescue’ inhaler?  (Typically a medication such as: Ventolin, albuterol, or Proventil.) If she is having coughing spells that are interfering with her ability to breathe then you need to seek medical attention immediately. And if her doctor did not prescribe some sort of rescue medication then you need to get her to a competent doctor – First Thing Tomorrow! "Being responsible sometimes means pissing people off."    General Colin Powell

Response:

My 16 yr old recently suffered through a bout with bronchitis.  Since then, she has developed coughing spells which leave her breathless. This A.M., the duratrion and intensity of her incident was quite severe.  Our MD has prescribed an anti inflammatory inhaler as treatment.  My question(s) is (are), has anyone here experienced similar symptoms?  Will these symptoms subside?  Is there a specific terminology used to describe these symptoms?  Most importantly, what can one do to help her regain her breath and comfort her while she is suffering through this quite harrowing experience? TIA

Acute bronchitis can last for a month or more. Sometimes there is permanent lung damage resulting in asthma. A steroid inhaler [anti-inflammatory] is prescribed for long term treatment. Along with this, a short-term preventor, usually albuterol [Ventolin] inhaler should be prescribed. When she suffers symptoms, she should use the albuterol, which gives relief within 5 minutes from coughing and breathing problems. Only time will tell if the symptoms subside, probably a few months. Links: http://www.njc.org/medfacts/uri.html  URI (Colds) &  Acute Bronchitis http://home.aafp.org/afp/980315ap/hueston.html Acute Bronchitis AAFP Ellis

Response:

I’m 18 and my doctor *thinks* I recently had mild bronchitis, for which he prescribed a relief inhaler.  Last time I went back, although the cough was getting better, he decided that I have asthma, and prescribed me a steroids inhaler.  However, I’ve only been to this doctor twice as I have recently started at university and he is based at the university medical centre, and I don’t think he did sufficient tests to diagnose asthma, so I haven’t been taking any of the new inhaler, and the cough is getting better on its own. However, I was having coughing fits, but I wouldn’t say they left me "breathless", it was just very difficult to stop coughing once I started and I would often end up feeling sick. So, from my own experience, I would say that the symptoms may get better on their own.  But I’m not a doctor, and I’m only speaking from my own experience. Zoe

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’m 18 and my doctor *thinks* I recently had mild bronchitis, for which he prescribed a relief inhaler.  Last time I went back, although the cough was getting better, he decided that I have asthma, and prescribed me a steroids inhaler.  However, I’ve only been to this doctor twice as I have recently started at university and he is based at the university medical centre, and I don’t think he did sufficient tests to diagnose asthma, so I haven’t been taking any of the new inhaler, and the cough is getting better on its own. However, I was having coughing fits, but I wouldn’t say they left me "breathless", it was just very difficult to stop coughing once I started and I would often end up feeling sick. So, from my own experience, I would say that the symptoms may get better on their own.  But I’m not a doctor, and I’m only speaking from my own experience.

You are rolling dice with your life on the line.  If you doubt the diagnosis, then ask for a second opinion.  Until then you need to follow the instructions the doctor gave you. Why does the first stage of asthma always seem to be denial? "Being responsible sometimes means pissing people off."    General Colin Powell

Response:

My 16 yr old recently suffered through a bout with bronchitis.  Since then, she has developed coughing spells which leave her breathless. This A.M., the duratrion and intensity of her incident was quite severe.  Our MD has prescribed an anti inflammatory inhaler as treatment.  My question(s) is (are), has anyone here experienced similar symptoms?  Will these symptoms subside?  Is there a specific terminology used to describe these symptoms?  Most importantly, what can one do to help her regain her breath and comfort her while she is suffering through this quite harrowing experience? TIA Before you buy.

I have had asthma most of my life. (I’m 47)  I’ve been able to help the condition by breathing exercises. (talk to the doctor) I’ve been through the classes as a child, and find that it’s extremely important, when one has the coughing "fits" that they keep their torso erect and their head up.  (also shoulders up)  If possible, sit or stand against a wall.  I also try to use the breathing exercises during my coughing fits.  Not being a doctor, I don’t know if the results will be permanent.  I was told that you can minimize the damage by doing the breathing exercises.  Hope this helps. Michele

Response:

Why does the first stage of asthma always seem to be denial?

It’s a coping mechanism.  It is difficult for a person to simply accept a diagnosis of an illness that doesn’t have an obvious cure.  It makes it even more difficult when the definition of asthma is so elusive.  One consequence of the lack of a widely accepted definition (by the public, at least) is that many people still think of asthma as an illness of the mind, which makes a diagnosis almost a personal insult for some. My denial was a little like the above; it was a result of medical science not really being able to help me.  When I went for my first set of tests (simple lung function tests, not methacholine), almost 15 years ago now, they told me that I had asthma and that I needed to use Ventolin.  That was all they gave me.  Well, the Ventolin did NOTHING. My main symptoms were sharp, burning pain, and ridiculous amounts of mucous.  I did not have attacks where I suddenly found it difficult to breathe, unless I was ill with pneumonia or bronchitis.  The Ventolin actually made the pain worse, so I used it only very rarely.  I went back to complain some more, and was met with an I-don’t-know response. Ever since then, I figured that there really was no hope for people like me.  I lived in denial mostly because I really didn’t believe that my symptoms were typical of asthma (lack of a clear definition), and because of the resulting distrust of doctors who were supposed to help me, but who didn’t (no obvious cure).  Now, there are different meds to try, as well as more understanding of the disease.  I have been using Flovent over the past couple of years.  I still experience pain and mucous production, but my current medication (Advair) does seem to cut that down at least a little bit, which is better than nothing.  The serevent does what Ventolin has always been able to do, but better, and that is to break up what mucous is there so that I can eventually expel it somehow.  Since I have finally been given a drug that actually makes at least a small amount of difference, I am more willing to listen to what my doctor has to say these days.  I still don’t understand why someone with only mild asthma would experience these symptoms that are so hard to treat (maybe I’m just not typical), but at least I’m willing to call myself an asthmatic now.  No more denial.  ;-) Vicky

Response:

So, from my own experience, I would say that the symptoms may get better on their own.  But I’m not a doctor, and I’m only speaking from my own experience. You are rolling dice with your life on the line.  If you doubt the diagnosis, then ask for a second opinion.  Until then you need to follow the instructions the doctor gave you.

I doubt the diagnosis because the cough is going away, I haven’t had to use my inhaler for a good few days now.

Response:

I doubt the diagnosis because the cough is going away, I haven’t had to use my inhaler for a good few days now.

you do know, of course, that not all asthma involves coughing as a symptom? —    PGP/GnuPG key (ID 1024D/BFE0D6D0) available from keyservers everywhere        "Everything I am today, I owe to people whom it is now too late                                    to punish."

Response:

So, from my own experience, I would say that the symptoms may get better on their own.  But I’m not a doctor, and I’m only speaking from my own experience. You are rolling dice with your life on the line.  If you doubt the diagnosis, then ask for a second opinion.  Until then you need to follow the instructions the doctor gave you. I doubt the diagnosis because the cough is going away, I haven’t had to use my inhaler for a good few days now.

Ask for a referral to an asthma specialist and get a full asthma workup. This is a determination that cannot be made by yourself.  Your lungs simply do not care about whether or not you think you have asthma. "Being responsible sometimes means pissing people off."    General Colin Powell

Response:

I doubt the diagnosis because the cough is going away, I haven’t had to use my inhaler for a good few days now. you do know, of course, that not all asthma involves coughing as a symptom?

Coughing is the only symptom I have.  I am not wheezy or short of breath and I have never had an asthma attack and don’t have any of the other symptoms, and I have looked it up on several different websites just to make sure.  I was told I might, note MIGHT have asthma on the basis that I have a cough. I was told to take the inhaler and see if it helped.  I looked at the list of side effects and decided not to start taking it just yet, so I am not taking the inhaler and I am not coughing any more.  If I have no symptoms, then surely it is reasonable to conclude that I am ok and that the MIGHT turned out to be a not.  If I still had the cough or I had other symptoms of asthma then I would consider taking the inhaler.

Response:

you do know, of course, that not all asthma involves coughing as a symptom? Coughing is the only symptom I have.  I am not wheezy or short of breath and I have never had an asthma attack and don’t have any of the other symptoms,

i was mainly concerned that, even though your coughing might be going away, it might be just about to be replaced by some other symptom; or that you might not know what other symptoms you should be on the lookout for. also, if you’ve been taking that relief inhaler steadily, that might be why your coughing is going away – trying a patient out on an asthma medication to see if that makes their possibly-asthma symptoms go away is, AFAIK, standard procedure in diagnosing asthma. and I have looked it up on several different websites just to make sure.  I was told I might, note MIGHT have asthma on the basis that I have a cough. I was told to take the inhaler and see if it helped.  I looked at the list of side effects and decided not to start taking it just yet, so I am not taking the inhaler and I am not coughing any more.  If I have no symptoms, then surely it is reasonable to conclude that I am ok and that the MIGHT turned out to be a not.

not necessarily. it might simply be that whatever triggered the attack went away again; but if you’re fine now, then it might be that if you do have asthma, that it is a fairly mild case and you’re simply not being triggered at the moment. (did that sentence make any sense at all?) still, you should be careful – i’ve seen a bad case getting worse, and it’s no fun. —    PGP/GnuPG key (ID 1024D/BFE0D6D0) available from keyservers everywhere        "Everything I am today, I owe to people whom it is now too late                                    to punish."

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I doubt the diagnosis because the cough is going away, I haven’t had to use my inhaler for a good few days now. you do know, of course, that not all asthma involves coughing as a symptom? Coughing is the only symptom I have.  I am not wheezy or short of breath and I have never had an asthma attack and don’t have any of the other symptoms, and I have looked it up on several different websites just to make sure.  I was told I might, note MIGHT have asthma on the basis that I have a cough. I was told to take the inhaler and see if it helped.  I looked at the list of side effects and decided not to start taking it just yet, so I am not taking the inhaler and I am not coughing any more.  If I have no symptoms, then surely it is reasonable to conclude that I am ok and that the MIGHT turned out to be a not.  If I still had the cough or I had other symptoms of asthma then I would consider taking the inhaler.

Coughing is the only symptom I have and its been that way for years. The way Dr know its asthma is because it responds to ventolin. The cough, when I get it, is way beyond a regular cough sometimes – I have collapsed to the floor and vomited. Other times it drives my co-workers nuts – I work in a cubicled environment. The coughing only occurs after I have had a bad enough cold and can last for 2-3 months. When I am in a "coughing phase" now I keep ventolin with me ( coughing is triggered when I go running too). Since it is apparently asthma I have asked my Drs two questions and I have yet to get a satisfactory answer. The questions are 1) The cough can get pretty bad – what happens when I am a lot older and frail. At that point is it dangerous? Need I worry? 2) Do I need to be concerned that the coughing asthma I have now will morph at sometime into the dangerous, get me to the hospital now kind? J. Freedman,Jr — Creation took 6 days because God didn’t have an installed base Before you buy.

Response:

I understand that coughing can be the only symptom of asthma, but it can be a symptom for lots of different things.  All I am trying to say is that my cough is getting better without any treatment of any kind, so surely it is not asthma.  I am just taking a longer than usual time to get over a cough because it was a bad cough and ripped my lungs to pieces (not literally). If you have a headache and it goes away, you don’t keep taking paracetamol for it. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Coughing is the only symptom I have and its been that way for years. The way Dr know its asthma is because it responds to ventolin. The cough, when I get it, is way beyond a regular cough sometimes – I have collapsed to the floor and vomited. Other times it drives my co-workers nuts – I work in a cubicled environment. The coughing only occurs after I have had a bad enough cold and can last for 2-3 months. When I am in a "coughing phase" now I keep ventolin with me ( coughing is triggered when I go running too). Since it is apparently asthma I have asked my Drs two questions and I have yet to get a satisfactory answer. The questions are 1) The cough can get pretty bad – what happens when I am a lot older and frail. At that point is it dangerous? Need I worry? 2) Do I need to be concerned that the coughing asthma I have now will morph at sometime into the dangerous, get me to the hospital now kind? J. Freedman,Jr — Creation took 6 days because God didn’t have an installed base Before you buy.

Response:

i was mainly concerned that, even though your coughing might be going away, it might be just about to be replaced by some other symptom; or that you might not know what other symptoms you should be on the lookout for. also, if you’ve been taking that relief inhaler steadily, that might be why your coughing is going away – trying a patient out on an asthma medication to see if that makes their possibly-asthma symptoms go away is, AFAIK, standard procedure in diagnosing asthma.

That seems to me like going to the doctor and saying "I have a headache" and him/her saying "well, it might be nothing, but you might have a brain tumour, so lets start you on some chemotherapy and see if that helps". not necessarily. it might simply be that whatever triggered the attack went away again; but if you’re fine now, then it might be that if you do have asthma, that it is a fairly mild case and you’re simply not being triggered at the moment. (did that sentence make any sense at all?) still, you should be careful – i’ve seen a bad case getting worse, and it’s no fun.

I will be careful, don’t worry, I’m not *that* stupid, if my cough starts getting worse again I’ll start taking the inhaler, or if I get some other strange symptoms that I can’t explain I will go back to the doctor. I don’t know what could have triggered it that is not triggering it now, I have not changed my lifestyle and the weather is the same, things seem to be exactly the same as they were when the cough started. Zoe

Response:

I understand that coughing can be the only symptom of asthma, but it can be a symptom for lots of different things.  All I am trying to say is that my cough is getting better without any treatment of any kind, so surely it is not asthma.  I am just taking a longer than usual time to get over a cough because it was a bad cough and ripped my lungs to pieces (not literally). If you have a headache and it goes away, you don’t keep taking paracetamol for it.

My cough went away too. Took a while (2-3 months) but it went away. Its still asthma though. I ventolin gives you relief its probably asthma. That’s what convinced me. J. Freedman — Creation took 6 days because God didn’t have an installed base Before you buy.

Response:

         What I suffer from is exercise induced asthma and emphysema, and I use O2, and  some of the  typical rx’s for relief.        No longer use  Atrovent (ipratropium) regularly, only once in a while as a backup when the albuterol doesn’t seem to be kicking in as well  as I’d  like       OR  (and this is  strictly my experience)  when  I’ m  troubled by a dry and unproductive cough.        So  Atrovent may be a candidate for the above.   What  does  your physican think?

Response:

My cough went away too. Took a while (2-3 months) but it went away. Its still asthma though. I ventolin gives you relief its probably asthma. That’s what convinced me.

There isn’t anything *to* relieve!!! And I wasn’t given ventolin, I was given pulmicort.  I was told to take it when I cough.  I am not coughing any more, therefore, I am not taking it any more. Do you still consider yourself to have asthma even though you don’t have a cough any more?

Response:

That seems to me like going to the doctor and saying "I have a headache" and him/her saying "well, it might be nothing, but you might have a brain tumour, so lets start you on some chemotherapy and see if that helps".

If the doctor suspects asthma, then standard procedure is to start a trial of asthma medications.  If the asthma medications control the symptoms then this is a strong indication that the patient has asthma. I will be careful, don’t worry, I’m not *that* stupid, if my cough starts getting worse again I’ll start taking the inhaler, or if I get some other strange symptoms that I can’t explain I will go back to the doctor. I don’t know what could have triggered it that is not triggering it now, I have not changed my lifestyle and the weather is the same, things seem to be exactly the same as they were when the cough started.

Actually, you are being reckless.  If the problem is asthma then you are risking irreversible damage to your airways. Asthma is a serious illness.  If you doubt the diagnosis, get a second opinion or a referral to a specialist.   You sound like you have already decided what you want to do and are trying to find excuses to justify the decision. "Being responsible sometimes means pissing people off."    General Colin Powell

Response:

There isn’t anything *to* relieve!!! And I wasn’t given ventolin, I was given pulmicort.  I was told to take it when I cough.  I am not coughing any more, therefore, I am not taking it any more.

It sounds like you have an incompetent doctor.  It is negligent for him to not to prescribe a rescue inhaler if he suspects asthma. Find Another Doctor. "Being responsible sometimes means pissing people off."    General Colin Powell

Response:

There isn’t anything *to* relieve!!! And I wasn’t given ventolin, I was given pulmicort.  I was told to take it when I cough.  I am not coughing any more, therefore, I am not taking it any more. It sounds like you have an incompetent doctor.  It is negligent for him to not to prescribe a rescue inhaler if he suspects asthma.

Pulmicort is a relief inhaler, isn’t it?

Response:

I AM NOT COUGHING ANY MORE I AM NOT TAKING ANY MEDICATION IT HAS GOT BETTER ON ITS OWN SO WHY TAKE MEDICATION FOR A PROBLEM THAT IS NO LONGER THERE? Yes I have decided what to do, I am not taking steroids without a good reason.  "Just in case" is not a good enough reason in my opinion. If the problem is not asthma and I take steroids, then I risk serious harm from the steroids.  There is not enough evidence that I have asthma to risk glaucoma or (cataracts which are listed side effects).

Response:

I AM NOT COUGHING ANY MORE I AM NOT TAKING ANY MEDICATION IT HAS GOT BETTER ON ITS OWN SO WHY TAKE MEDICATION FOR A PROBLEM THAT IS NO LONGER THERE?

because, without a thorough examination and a good second opinion, you can’t know that it isn’t there anymore. it’s sort of like how people really should keep taking their antibiotics even though the problems seem to be gone after half the regimen, except asthma – if it’s really there – won’t ever go away, no matter how good you might feel at any given time. Yes I have decided what to do, I am not taking steroids without a good reason.

i quite understand, my wife can’t take steroids at all because of the particular side effects she gets. still, steroids are the most common maintenance meds for asthma for good reason. if you can’t take them because you demonstrably do run into intolerable side effects, or because another pulmonologist disagrees with the diagnosis after careful testing – well and good; but please, do yourself a favour and get that second opinion, and if the diagnosis is the same, at least try the best controlling medication we have for a serious, chronic, incurable illness that could kill you. —    PGP/GnuPG key (ID 1024D/BFE0D6D0) available from keyservers everywhere        "Everything I am today, I owe to people whom it is now too late                                    to punish."

Response:

It sounds like you have an incompetent doctor.  It is negligent for him to not to prescribe a rescue inhaler if he suspects asthma. Pulmicort is a relief inhaler, isn’t it?

no, it’s an oral steroid. it’s a long-duration maintenance medication, it would be useless for an acute attack. —    PGP/GnuPG key (ID 1024D/BFE0D6D0) available from keyservers everywhere        "Everything I am today, I owe to people whom it is now too late                                    to punish."

Response:

Thank you

Question:

I am off to Sacramento to take the American Board of Family Practice certification exam.  I will be gone until Saturday evening. I just wanted to say thank you to all who have encouraged me and to the rest for teaching me about chronic pain from the patient’s point of view. This is not a good-bye…once I start work I will still log on…you just won’t hear as much from me as before (I know some of you are sighing with relief). — Bill Work

Response:

Dr Work I want to thank you for all your help can u answer one more question for me …I need to know why my knee is poping out of place and very painful thank you for all your help have a safe and happy trip                       Terry * Sent from AltaVista http://www.altavista.com Where you can also find related Web Pages, Images, Audios, Videos, News, and Shopping.  Smart is Beautiful

Response:

GOOD LUCK! I know you’ll do fine – Thank you for all your help and compassion Dr. Work ! Take GREAT care – and hurry back : ) — Christi ~*~ Senior Stampin’ Up! Demonstrator ~*~ Exquisite Essentials http://www.eeshops.com Tell me about your PETS! http://www.trilogyonline.com/ChristiConley/ ^,,^<         ^,,^<         ^,,^<         ^,,^<

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am off to Sacramento to take the American Board of Family Practice certification exam.  I will be gone until Saturday evening. I just wanted to say thank you to all who have encouraged me and to the rest for teaching me about chronic pain from the patient’s point of view. This is not a good-bye…once I start work I will still log on…you just won’t hear as much from me as before (I know some of you are sighing with relief). — Bill Work

Response:

Well, I’m back!  Had oodles of fun! As to your knee popping out…what does your doc say?  It can be anywhere from old age to a torn anterior cruciate ligament and lots of stuff in between. Need to have a doc lay his hands on you physically and do an ortho exam. — Bill Work

Dr Work I want to thank you for all your help can u answer one more question for me …I need to know why my knee is poping out of place and very painful thank you for all your help have a safe and happy trip                       Terry * Sent from AltaVista http://www.altavista.com Where you can also find

related Web Pages, Images, Audios, Videos, News, and Shopping.  Smart is Beautiful

Response:

Well did you pass – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well, I’m back!  Had oodles of fun! As to your knee popping out…what does your doc say?  It can be anywhere from old age to a torn anterior cruciate ligament and lots of stuff in between. Need to have a doc lay his hands on you physically and do an ortho exam. — Bill Work message Dr Work I want to thank you for all your help can u answer one more question for me …I need to know why my knee is poping out of place and very painful thank you for all your help have a safe and happy trip                       Terry * Sent from AltaVista http://www.altavista.com Where you can also find related Web Pages, Images, Audios, Videos, News, and Shopping.  Smart is Beautiful

Response:

I’ll find out by October 1. — Bill Work

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Well did you pass Well, I’m back!  Had oodles of fun! As to your knee popping out…what does your doc say?  It can be anywhere from old age to a torn anterior cruciate ligament and lots of stuff in between. Need to have a doc lay his hands on you physically and do an ortho exam. — Bill Work message Dr Work I want to thank you for all your help can u answer one more question for me …I need to know why my knee is poping out of place and very painful thank you for all your help have a safe and happy trip                       Terry * Sent from AltaVista http://www.altavista.com Where you can also find related Web Pages, Images, Audios, Videos, News, and Shopping.  Smart is Beautiful

Response:

Geez that is too long to wait.  So hmmm I guess we can still toss that coin PHIL – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’ll find out by October 1. — Bill Work Well did you pass Well, I’m back!  Had oodles of fun! As to your knee popping out…what does your doc say?  It can be anywhere from old age to a torn anterior cruciate ligament and lots of stuff in between. Need to have a doc lay his hands on you physically and do an ortho exam. — Bill Work message Dr Work I want to thank you for all your help can u answer one more question for me …I need to know why my knee is poping out of place and very painful thank you for all your help have a safe and happy trip                       Terry * Sent from AltaVista http://www.altavista.com Where you can also find related Web Pages, Images, Audios, Videos, News, and Shopping.  Smart is Beautiful

Response:

Newspaper article from Glasgow about the Buteyko method for curing asthma. "Breathe Easily and Learn to Live Again"

Re : Buteyko Method                 This subject keeps  active .  I have mild asthma and often feel with a small improvement I could be clear of meds.  I live in Dublin Ireland. Is there anyone trained in these methods in this city? Yes I will look up the web site… but is it possible to teach oneself?  I often felt that the 10 seconds or so of holding your breath after taking an inhaled med was of positive value in itself. Anne.

Response:

"Breathe Easily and Learn to Live Again" Re : Buteyko Method            This subject keeps  active .  I have mild asthma and often feel with a small improvement I could be clear of meds.  I live in Dublin Ireland. Is there anyone trained in these methods in this city? Yes I will look up the web site… but is it possible to teach oneself?  I often felt that the 10 seconds or so of holding your breath after taking an inhaled med was of positive value in itself. Anne.

test

Response:

"Breathe Easily and Learn to Live Again" Re : Buteyko Method                This subject keeps  active .  I have mild asthma and often feel with a small improvement I could be clear of meds.  I live in Dublin Ireland. Is there anyone trained in these methods in this city? Yes I will look up the web site… but is it possible to teach oneself?  I often felt that the 10 seconds or so of holding your breath after taking an inhaled med was of positive value in itself. Anne. test

From reading the descriptions the author posted, I suspect that you would get the same (or better results) from a well planned excercise program.  20 min a day on an excercise bicycle would imporve lung efficency more.  

Response:

Newspaper article from Glasgow about the Buteyko method for curing asthma. "Breathe Easily and Learn to Live Again" Sally Magnusson is impressed with the experience of seeing chronic asthmatics undergoing an apparently miraculous cure – The Herald, Glasgow, 12th August 1996 I have just watched a roomful of people who have suffered terribly from perhaps the most rampant disease of this generation, long thought to be incurable, begin to recover from it. Dramatically. Almost incredibly. Within five days. I am still reeling from the experience, still finding it hard to take in the possibility that my own son, whom I have been pumping full of asthma medication for five of his eight years, could soon be shot of all of his inhalers for good. Some have gone already. He woke this morning without a wheeze, able to breathe freely through his nose for the first time in ages. As I write he is out playing football without ventolin in his pocket. I honestly wouldn’t have believed it when he and I sat down last week in London’s Hale Clinic with 20 fellow asthmatics, including two other young boys. We had come, like everyone else, because I had heard that the Buteyko method of reconditioning your breathing had been producing amazing results in asthmatics, and I was willing to try anything. But we were all pretty sceptical. How, we wondered, as we sat nervously in rows waiting for the first class to begin, could five one-hour lessons in breathing achieve what a lifetime of inhalers and pills and special vacuum cleaners had failed to do? There were people in that class who need nebulizers two or three times just to get through a normal day, people who could no longer climb stairs, people with medicine cabinets like a pharmacy, people of all ages and both sexes whose whole lives were dominated and ruined by the perpetual fight for air. And how ridiculously simple it turned out to be. It wasn’t, we were told, that our bodies were fighting for air at all; they were getting too much of the stuff. The key to this theory is carbon dioxide. For oxygen to pass efficiently into the blood we need a certain amount of carbon dioxide; this is lost when we over-breathe. In other words – and this is standard textbook stuff – by breathing too much we actually get less oxygen. The radical claim made by the Russian physiologist, Professor Konstantin Buteyko, is that asthmatics are three or four times more than they should. They’re not doing it in an acute, obvious way; the crux of Buteyko’s theory is that this over-breathing is often not clearly visible in the patient; it is "hidden hyperventilation". He suggests that diseases such as asthma, hypertension, stenocardia, strokes, haemorrhoids, eczema, and a good many others are the body’s defence mechanisms against the excessive loss of CO2 through over-breathing. So an asthmatic spasm is not a message to the body to breathe more; it’s a plea to breathe less. And the more we force open the airways with bronchodilators like ventolin and take big, deep gulps of air, the more harm we do in the long run. The body simply strengthens its defences and tries to get the message across again, and again, and again. I’m no scientist; I’m certainly no doctor. I’ll leave it to those who are better qualified to assess whether Christopher Drake, the Buteyko practitioner who ran our course, is right to assert that "you can’t have shallow breathing and asthma – the two simply cannot go together". All I can say, mustering as much journalistic detachment as I can, is that it seems to work. And, if he’s right, any asthmatic with the not inconsiderable willpower required to sustain the breathing exercises could be off medications in a matter of weeks. A Multi-million pound pharmaceutical industry would feel the pinch, of course, but I dare say the country’s three million asthmatics could live with that. Sharon Cutler, a 39-year-old teacher from Kent, certainly could. Even I, who had watched her struggle with the Buteyko exercises each evening and gradually begin to master them, was taken aback by the changes she reported at the end of the week. My shorthand could hardly keep up with the outpouring of emotion when I asked her what she thought. "I feel fantastic," she said, "and extraordinarily happy. I’ve had no asthma since the second day. I feel so much more energetic. My appetite’s fallen and my weight has just dropped off. I can walk distances. I can manage stairs. "My life until this week has consisted of going to work, coming home collapsing in a chair, and wheezing. Now I feel as if I’ve got my life back. The only time I felt this good before was in the two or three minutes after I came off the nebulizer. I feel as if I’ve had a body transplant. What have I been doing this past forty years?" Angela McAnally, from Glasgow, said she felt wonderful. "I can’t say how tremendous I feel already." Gary Phillips, from Wales, said he could breathe through his nose for the first time in years. Similar responses were coming from all sides, with the most dramatic results being reported by the most seriously affected asthmatics. One lady told Drake: "Thank you for giving me my life back." Of course only time will tell whether the improvrement continues, especially once the long-term steroid inhalers, which we were urged not to discard too hastily, are reduced. But Christopher Drake claims a 97% long-term success rate, and the tributes of his former pupils certainly back him up. He showed me a letter from Nick Jacobs (34) of London, a chronic asthmatic since the age of six who was on steroids, repeated antibiotics, Serevent twice a day – and felt in a state of permanent decline. "I stopped taking the Ventolin on the third day of your course and have not taken it since", he wrote, "I am now taking no medication whatsoever and I am in control of my asthma. I am beginning to forget that I have asthma at all. "I am shocked and delighted by the efficacy of the method. ‘Miraculous’ is an emotive and non-scientific word but comes closest to describing how I view the application of this simple and logically founded method. I am grateful beyond my ability of expression." So, what happens to achieve such dramatic results so quickly? Well, remarkably little, actually. On each of the five evenings we learned to forget everything we ever imbibed at our mother’s knee about the efficacy of breathing and practiced instead how to take infinitesimal, almost suffocation breaths through the nose. And we learned to stop asthma attacks – which we’re told will happen less and less as shallow breathing becomes second nature – by holding our breath for an inordinate time to get carbon dioxide levels up. As many of the class were soon discovering, these exercises at the first hint of a wheeze will diperse it completely. Within a couple of days, the elderly man on the nebulizer had abandoned it for one puff of ventolin, and by the third day he reported that he had got through a 5am asthma attack spasm with the exercise alone. He felt he was on his way. We were told not to come of steroids too fast. We should wait until we had been clear of symptoms and breathing well for a few weeks and then reduce gradually in consultation with a GP. Christopher Drake, who has overseen the recovery of so many blighted lives in this way, is an angry man. Despite the conclusion of the chair of childhood diseases at the First Moscow Institute that "Buteyko’s method proved to be very efficient in the complex treatment of bronchial asthma", despite authoritative trials in Australia and a success rate of over 90%, Drake can’t get a hearing in Britain. The National Asthma Campaign is dismissive. "There is no medical evidence that a person with stable asthma is consistently over-breathing" it says. Christopher Drake wants to set up British trials to provide the evidence. He wants Buteyko’s reasoning assessed by independent scientists. Above all he wants open minds. Perhaps Scotland’s medical establishment, with it’s proud indepent history, could provide these. "Everyone believes asthma is a complicated, mysterious, disease", he says, "So we spend millions of pounds researching the dust mite that has been with us forever, we clean carpets, we sell the dog, we buy special bedding and afterwards – more asthma. These are only triggers. The simple fact is that asthmatics breathe three or four times more than the physiology books say they should and the medications make it worse." Next month Drake is holding Scotland’s first Buteyko course in Glasgow, preceded by an explanatory seminar that is free and open to all. Every GP, every asthma nurse, everybody who has ever looked into the asthma abyss, and despaired, ought to be there. To find out more take a look at http://www.cix.co.uk/~reardo/buteyko.htm

Response:

Hi.  I had a similar experience, so I know something about how you feel. I worked in a small office (around 25 people) where they put up a Christmas tree every year.  Since I am highly allergic to mold, I react quite dramatically to Christmas trees.  My doctor explained this to me by telling me that most trees that are sold are cut down in September and October, bundled up, and then shipped to be sold in December.  During this time mold proliferates and can later cause many problems for those who are sensitive.  Anyway, I explained this to the people that I worked with and offered to purchase a realistic looking artificial tree.  They refused. Needless to say, when I came into the office the morning after they had set up the tree I had an immediate reaction.  I called my doctor who asked me to come into his office right away.   He was concerned that I might have suffered permanent lung damage from the experience.  He wrote a letter to my boss explaining my sensitivity and the fact that  I couldn’t return to work until the tree was removed.  Unfortunately, they wouldn’t remove the tree.  Although I was paid during my time off, I spent the next three weeks at home feeling just awful that a tree was more important than me.  Since I worked for a direct marketing firm and Christmas was our busiest season, I felt even worse that I wasn’t needed.  On the bright side, during this time I realized that I really didn’t enjoy my career and quit my job to return to graduate school.  (In the long run, my new career wasn’t a good choice for someone with asthma, but that’s another story.) In any case, please realize that you’re not the one with the problem. They are.  Good luck.  Keep your chin up. Lisa in Chicago " ‘Hope’ is the thing with feathers ~ That perches in the soul ~ And sings the tune without the words ~ And never stops ~ at all."  Emily Dickenson, #254, 1861.

Response:

Such a sad story!  Maybe if you explain how the cat aggravates your asthma, your employer can make some consessions for you.   If you are a good employee they will want to keep you rather than train someone else.  Certainly they aren’t so mean-hearted that they won’t work with you.  At least you can try.  (maybe the cat can be kept out of your work area or given a home with someone from the company.) Good luck. Sarah. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – A big thanks to those of you that responded to my post.  It does seem rather overwhelming when I think of all the changes asthma is making in my life.  I feel very unsettled in some ways.  Another thing I am allergic to I recently found out is cats.  VERY allergic.  My allergist told me there is no way I can work in a house where there is a cat.  So now I will be looking for a different job because where I work they have a cat.  It’s the best job I’ve ever had, my employers are wonderful and it’s very sad for me to leave.  Given the choice between my job and being able to breathe with alot less struggle you all know which wins.  Perhaps I’m just feeling sorry for myslef and finding life unfair at the moment but with the hope my asthma will settle down over time and life become more normal it makes it more bearable. Thanks again for your support, Vicky

Response:

A big thanks to those of you that responded to my post.  It does seem rather overwhelming when I think of all the changes asthma is making in my life.  I feel very unsettled in some ways.  Another thing I am allergic to I recently found out is cats.  VERY allergic.  My allergist told me there is no way I can work in a house where there is a cat.  So now I will be looking for a different job because where I work they have a cat.  It’s the best job I’ve ever had, my employers are wonderful and it’s very sad for me to leave.  Given the choice between my job and being able to breathe with alot less struggle you all know which wins.  Perhaps I’m just feeling sorry for myslef and finding life unfair at the moment but with the hope my asthma will settle down over time and life become more normal it makes it more bearable. Thanks again for your support, Vicky

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – A big thanks to those of you that responded to my post.  It does seem rather overwhelming when I think of all the changes asthma is making in my life.  I feel very unsettled in some ways.  Another thing I am allergic to I recently found out is cats.  VERY allergic.  My allergist told me there is no way I can work in a house where there is a cat.  So now I will be looking for a different job because where I work they have a cat.  It’s the best job I’ve ever had, my employers are wonderful and it’s very sad for me to leave.  Given the choice between my job and being able to breathe with alot less struggle you all know which wins.  Perhaps I’m just feeling sorry for myslef and finding life unfair at the moment but with the hope my asthma will settle down over time and life become more normal it makes it more bearable. Thanks again for your support, Vicky

Dear Vicky, I’d feel sorry for myself too if I had to leave a job I liked.  However, if the cat stays and you are having big problems with asthma because of the cat, you made the right (but tough) decision.  This shows great maturity on your part.  congratulations to you!!!  Sometimes it helps to know that others have had to make similiar choices.  I had to give up my cat (a teary situation), but I know I made the right decision.  You’re headed in the right direction, and I commend you for your wisdom.

Response:

This post not CC’d by email I just had to post that Chris got his results from all his bloodwork today and after being at 17- something a year ago when he was diagnosed, he came in at 5.6 for his HbA1c. He has really been watching what he eats, lost 70 pounds, has a very  physical job, and I nag the heck out of him about what he can and can’t eat.

G’day G’day Lori, IMHO anyone who says "I nag the heck out of him" must be doing it nicely.  The ones to watch are those who have to admit they nag a bit. Life with them is being nagged, been nagged and about to be nagged.   Obviously you are comfortable with it and so I expect is he. I have changed our eating habits to include everything he can eat and also what my kids will tolerate…and that is not salad!!!

Since "our" include yourself it is easy to see he is lucky in having someone who will walk the extra mile with him.  Men aren’t as stupid as they something appear.  The actions matter more than the words in setting the frame for interpreting what is said to them. Do you make salads with lettuce?  We seldom do or it is a minor component.  Often I dice tomatoes, cucumbers, tender courgettes, capsicum (bell peppers) and toss on some goat feta and perhaps some slice hard boiled eggs.  Locally we have some white garlic source to which I add orange blossom water which for reason gets people who swear they don’t eat salads eating my salads. When I started reading this newsgroup a couple of months ago, I read up on every little idea or hint everyone posted. After his results today, I want to thank all of you for all your suggestions and help.

Hey we were just nagging …. Changing our diet is not something I dread, it is something I find as a challenge. And thankfully he is willing to try any concoction I dream up….and believe me, some of them have been horrid!!

LOL.  Good to see you also laugh.   Laughter changes situations faster than logic.   Lori

– Quentin Grady       ^  ^  / New Zealand,       #,#< [                     / /     "... and the blind dog was leading." http://homepages.paradise.net.nz/quentin

Response:

This post not CC'd by email I just had to post that Chris got his results from all his bloodwork today and after being at 17- something a year ago when he was diagnosed, he came in at 5.6 for his HbA1c.

G'day G'day Lori,    If it is OK with you the ladies here will do a Snoopy dance for him.  It's not quite like lap dancing but we all get a bit excited when people get their A1c below 6.   Congratulations to you both. I just think it is fantastic the way you have both dealt with the problem. Somewhere in the remote corners of cyberspace is a secret printing press creating a membership card for the 5% club.   In this case I think it should be a family membership.   He has really been watching what he eats, lost 70 pounds, has a very  physical job, and I nag the heck out of him about what he can and can't eat.

70 lbs = 32 kg. It adds a whole new meaning to vowing to stick together through thick and thin.   I have changed our eating habits to include everything he can eat and also what my kids will tolerate...and that is not salad!!! When I started reading this newsgroup a couple of months ago, I read up on every little idea or hint everyone posted. After his results today, I want to thank all of you for all your suggestions and help. Changing our diet is not something I dread, it is something I find as a challenge. And thankfully he is willing to try any concoction I dream up....and believe me, some of them have been horrid!!

One thing I was really impressed with was the willingness to make mistakes in order to learn.  It seems sometimes as if we live in a society where people have rather fragile egos when it comes to taking the risk of making mistakes.  Such dramatic lifestyle changes as you have made need that sort of courage and the sense of humour to weather the inevitable disasters that happen along the way.   He is one lucky bloke.   Lori

Best wishes and heaps of further successes in whatever you do together next.   -- Quentin Grady       ^  ^  / New Zealand,       #,#< [                     / /     "... and the blind dog was leading." http://homepages.paradise.net.nz/quentin

Response:

i see you are in the same city as me...... hi ya! who's your endo?? i love Ross k  Shaw is based in Calgary, which is why it comes across that way,  but I am in BC.

good to meet you, Lori and BIG CONGRATS to Chris for his lifestyle changes (i just read the chocolate thing) kate

Response:

I just had to post that Chris got his results from all his bloodwork today and after being at 17- something a year ago when he was diagnosed, he came in at 5.6 for his HbA1c. snoopy happy dance, congrats to Chris i see you are in the same city as me...... hi ya! who's your endo?? i love Ross k

 Shaw is based in Calgary, which is why it comes across that way,  but I am in BC. Lori

Response:

I just had to post that Chris got his results from all his bloodwork today and after being at 17- something a year ago when he was diagnosed, he came in at 5.6 for his HbA1c.

snoopy happy dance, congrats to Chris i see you are in the same city as me...... hi ya! who's your endo?? i love Ross k

Response:

I just had to post that Chris got his results from all his bloodwork today and after being at 17- something a year ago when he was diagnosed, he came in at 5.6 for his HbA1c. snoopy happy dance, congrats to Chris i see you are in the same city as me...... hi ya! who's your endo?? i love Ross k

My oh my, congratulations. If you get an earthquack it is me jumping for joy for you. IraT2

Response:

I just had to post that Chris got his results from all his bloodwork today and after being at 17- something a year ago when he was diagnosed, he came in at 5.6 for his HbA1c. He has really been watching what he eats, lost 70 pounds, has a very  physical job, and I nag the heck out of him about what he can and can't eat. I have changed our eating habits to include everything he can eat and also what my kids will tolerate...and that is not salad!!! When I started reading this newsgroup a couple of months ago, I read up on every little idea or hint everyone posted. After his results today, I want to thank all of you for all your suggestions and help. Changing our diet is not something I dread, it is something I find as a challenge. And thankfully he is willing to try any concoction I dream up....and believe me, some of them have been horrid!! Lori

Response:

After his results today, I want to thank all of you for all your suggestions and help. Changing our diet is not something I dread, it is something I find as a challenge. And thankfully he is willing to try any concoction I dream up....and believe me, some of them have been horrid!! Lori

Tell Chris congrats on his great numbers and on having such a great better half. VBS As always YMMV and this is JMO Jeanne Type 2  Diagnosed 05/28/02 189/159/120

Response:

- Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - I just had to post that Chris got his results from all his bloodwork today and after being at 17- something a year ago when he was diagnosed, he came in at 5.6 for his HbA1c. He has really been watching what he eats, lost 70 pounds, has a very  physical job, and I nag the heck out of him about what he can and can't eat. I have changed our eating habits to include everything he can eat and also what my kids will tolerate...and that is not salad!!! When I started reading this newsgroup a couple of months ago, I read up on every little idea or hint everyone posted. After his results today, I want to thank all of you for all your suggestions and help. Changing our diet is not something I dread, it is something I find as a challenge. And thankfully he is willing to try any concoction I dream up....and believe me, some of them have been horrid!! Lori

Both of your deserve hearty congratulations. You, for being so supportive and challenging, and Chris for his achievement. It has been hard for both of you, and now you can reap the rewards - an easing up for you, and a better prognosis for him, not to mention how much better he must be feeling.  Don't freak out if he lapses on the odd occasion, we all do, and it happens.  Don't become a "diabetic police" person. I may sound a bit tough on you, but if he hasn't got the message by now, somethings not right. After 12 mths he should be well into new habits of eating, as long as the right foods are there.  And I bet he never wants to go back to feling as sick and miserable as he surely did before. My concern is that if you don't start to let up, he will either become dependant on you to be his concience, or resent you for always checking up on him like a kid. Of course, I am presuming this has not already happened.  In that case, ignore my remonstrances - you've done so well to date, who am I to judge? All the best to you both. Annette The best revenge is doing well.

Response:

My concern is that if you don't start to let up, he will either become dependant on you to be his concience, or resent you for always checking up on him like a kid. Of course, I am presuming this has not already happened.  In that case, ignore my remonstrances - you've done so well to date, who am I to judge?

It's you being the judges that have helped, so keep on judging! He knows only too well the consequences of not eating properly, his mom had both legs amputated, repeatedly,  and died of heart complications from diabetes. The nagging I have to do is to get him to eat when he is working, seems like he gets too pre-occupied and goes too long between eating. I wrote that post on the day I had gone to work with him. I said it's lunch time, knowing he had to eat,  and he said I am not hungry. I had a very long conversation with him about not getting too absorbed to eat and waiting until he felt low.  Working in the woods, on top of a mountain, with no time limits, clocks, or set meal times, is the hardest part of his diet. There is no breakfast, lunch, dinner like on the weekends.  It is 12 hour days, and depending on the amount of physical energy used, eating can sometimes be needed every two hours. Sometimes they consume over 4000 calories a day, due to the altitude and physical aspect. (That is not too much, or unusual, BTW) You should see the size of his lunch box!!! All the best to you both.

Thanks, I plan on growing very old with this guy. :) - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Annette The best revenge is doing well.

Response:

I would like to thank all of the people in this group for the loving and caring support given regarding my recent stroke.  What a wonderful family I have found here.  Thanks so much to all of you.  HUGS! and lots of warm fuzzies. Buck

Response:

        Buck that's what friends and family are for :)  how's the song go? Lean on me when your not strong, and I'll be your friend, I'll help you lean on.                                 Pam

- Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - I would like to thank all of the people in this group for the loving and caring support given regarding my recent stroke.  What a wonderful family I have found here.  Thanks so much to all of you.  HUGS! and lots of warm fuzzies. Buck

Response:

I love that song.  Thanks for reminding me about it. Buck - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text -         Buck that's what friends and family are for :)  how's the song go? Lean on me when your not strong, and I'll be your friend, I'll help you lean on.                                 Pam I would like to thank all of the people in this group for the loving and caring support given regarding my recent stroke.  What a wonderful family I have found here.  Thanks so much to all of you.  HUGS! and lots of warm fuzzies. Buck

Response:

Thank ya, hope and pray you are feeling better. Buck

- Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Buck I didn't answer in your other thread a sI have been rather sick this week but I was admiring you from afar anyway. Here's the warm fuzzies back at you.  And some for your lovely wife. I would like to thank all of the people in this group for the loving and caring support given regarding my recent stroke.  What a wonderful family I have found here.  Thanks so much to all of you.  HUGS! and lots of warm fuzzies. Buck

Response:

Buck I didn't answer in your other thread a sI have been rather sick this week but I was admiring you from afar anyway. Here's the warm fuzzies back at you.  And some for your lovely wife.

- Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - I would like to thank all of the people in this group for the loving and caring support given regarding my recent stroke.  What a wonderful family I have found here.  Thanks so much to all of you.  HUGS! and lots of warm fuzzies. Buck

Response:

                    No problem Buck, its one of my favorites also, has such a true meaning :)

- Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - I love that song.  Thanks for reminding me about it. Buck         Buck that's what friends and family are for :)  how's the song go? Lean on me when your not strong, and I'll be your friend, I'll help you to lean on.                                 Pam I would like to thank all of the people in this group for the loving and caring support given regarding my recent stroke.  What a wonderful family I have found here.  Thanks so much to all of you.  HUGS! and lots of warm fuzzies. Buck

Response:

 Back at ya, Buck! :) I would like to thank all of the people in this group for the loving and caring support given regarding my recent stroke.  What a wonderful family I have found here.  Thanks so much to all of you.  HUGS! and lots of warm fuzzies. Buck

--  T2 - Glucophage, diet, and exercise - March '98  Born '47  Another Soggy Seattle Sysop!  ICQ #75977612

Response:

Thanks to those of you who answered my questions.  We came here knowing more about pumping than those who live in the u.s.  For so advanced a country (supposedly) you seem to be so far behind in technology and medicine. It is no wonder that Europe and the Middle East look upon the u.s. as rather mindless children with no direction other than by politician who look foolish to the rest of us. So for now shalem alekium!  We go to England tomorrow for a dig for a couple of months and then on to Iraq for another dig and then back to King Faid University. This has been very interesting!  Visiting prople who are so provincial is always an experience. Good luck in your various treatments for your diseases. Maris "Save the children of the Desert those not of the house of the infidel"

Ignore the troll.

Response:

(Jmmbear) writes: Not sure if I should be insulted or just say goodbye. :-( Jeanne Type 2  Diagnosed 05/28/02 189/177/120

oh well, after really looking at her post. I decided to be insulted.  So Just go away. You are not even worth my time. Jeanne Type 2  Diagnosed 05/28/02 189/177/120

Response:

Thanks to those of you who answered my questions.  We came here knowing more about pumping than those who live in the u.s.  For so advanced a country (supposedly) you seem to be so far behind in technology and medicine. It is no wonder that Europe and the Middle East look upon the u.s. as rather mindless children with no direction other than by politician who look foolish to the rest of us. So for now shalem alekium!  We go to England tomorrow for a dig for a couple of months and then on to Iraq for another dig and then back to King Faid University. This has been very interesting!  Visiting prople who are so provincial is always an experience. Good luck in your various treatments for your diseases. Maris "Save the children of the Desert those not of the house of the infidel"

I worked with a brilliant Hungarian Engineer.  He admitted he had not understood the US.  He had not seen the hard working people in the real US. I worked with another European and he though we were clods. The list projects he screwed up was very long.  He always had an excuse and was good at excuses and buck passing. All other people see is the publicity hounds and money chasers. Behind that is a majority of good hard working people. And a group of very good scientists.  They are not great at bragging.                                               Guy

Response:

You have a terrible attitude.  I feel sad for you.  Possbily you should quit messing around with "digging up bones" and start educating yourself on how to deal with the living.  This is not a "provincial" country.  The United States is a country that consists of many ethnic groups, and as such, we can hardly be called narrow or limited, if that is the meaning you were aiming for in your use of the word "provincial". Also, if we know so little about medicine and how to treat certain diseases, than why do many from other countries come here for their treatment?  Of course, there is always room for improvement no matter where you live, but I doubt that you would admit that.  Just a thought. Dot Type 2  Diag 8/2001 - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Thanks to those of you who answered my questions.  We came here knowing more about pumping than those who live in the u.s.  For so advanced a country (supposedly) you seem to be so far behind in technology and medicine. It is no wonder that Europe and the Middle East look upon the u.s. as rather mindless children with no direction other than by politician who look foolish to the rest of us. So for now shalem alekium!  We go to England tomorrow for a dig for a couple of months and then on to Iraq for another dig and then back to King Faid University. This has been very interesting!  Visiting prople who are so provincial is always an experience. Good luck in your various treatments for your diseases. Maris "Save the children of the Desert those not of the house of the infidel"

Response:

Not to mention that this horrid country was good enough to give Maris a formal education. Maris, God loves you even with all that hatred in your heart, so don't give up hope. Love conquers all. Have a safe trip home. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text -You have a terrible attitude.  

Response:

Maris said.... - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Thanks to those of you who answered my questions.  We came here knowing more about pumping than those who live in the u.s.  For so advanced a country (supposedly) you seem to be so far behind in technology and medicine. It is no wonder that Europe and the Middle East look upon the u.s. as rather mindless children with no direction other than by politician who look foolish to the rest of us. So for now shalem alekium!  We go to England tomorrow for a dig for a couple of months and then on to Iraq for another dig and then back to King Faid University. This has been very interesting!  Visiting prople who are so provincial is always an experience. Good luck in your various treatments for your diseases. Maris "Save the children of the Desert those not of the house of the infidel"

Rather than visit England for a couple of months, could you possibly just fuck off back where you came from? Britain is a broadly tolerant society. We welcome many different nationalities. People with their head shoved up their Islamic terrorist brainwashed arses are not exactly welcome here. True believers in the Koran are always welcome. Not shit like you. As for "children of the desert", the Koran says that the "people of the book" are to be cherished. Meaning Christians and Jews. Let's see your terrorist-loving sensibility worm out of that one. Ratty -- All killer no filler ratty at flyingrat.net New webthingy is www.flyingrat.net

Response:

This has been very interesting!  Visiting prople who are so provincial is always an experience. Good luck in your various treatments for your diseases. Maris "Save the children of the Desert those not of the house of the infidel"

Not sure if I should be insulted or just say goodbye. :-( Jeanne Type 2  Diagnosed 05/28/02 189/177/120

Response:

What country are you from, Maris??? Let something happen in Europe & the Middle East & see who they come running to for protection. The next time Iraq attacks a Middle East country I hope the U.S. stays out of it & lets them get their ass kicked. Of course I don't mean Israel, they can take on the Middle East. I do take exception to your post.

- Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Thanks to those of you who answered my questions.  We came here knowing more about pumping than those who live in the u.s.  For so advanced a country (supposedly) you seem to be so far behind in technology and medicine. It is no wonder that Europe and the Middle East look upon the u.s. as rather mindless children with no direction other than by politician who look foolish to the rest of us. So for now shalem alekium!  We go to England tomorrow for a dig for a couple of months and then on to Iraq for another dig and then back to King Faid University. This has been very interesting!  Visiting prople who are so provincial is always an experience. Good luck in your various treatments for your diseases. Maris "Save the children of the Desert those not of the house of the infidel"

Response:

Thanks to those of you who answered my questions.  We came here knowing more about pumping than those who live in the u.s.  For so advanced a country (supposedly) you seem to be so far behind in technology and medicine. It is no wonder that Europe and the Middle East look upon the u.s. as rather mindless children with no direction other than by politician who look foolish to the rest of us. So for now shalem alekium!  We go to England tomorrow for a dig for a couple of months and then on to Iraq for another dig and then back to King Faid University. This has been very interesting!  Visiting prople who are so provincial is always an experience. Good luck in your various treatments for your diseases. Maris "Save the children of the Desert those not of the house of the infidel"

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don't intend to desert it, and hope the 'experienced hands' will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." - Zen proverb

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don't intend to desert it, and hope the 'experienced hands' will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." - Zen proverb

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don't intend to desert it, and hope the 'experienced hands' will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." - Zen proverb

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don't intend to desert it, and hope the 'experienced hands' will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." - Zen proverb

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don't intend to desert it, and hope the 'experienced hands' will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." - Zen proverb

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don't intend to desert it, and hope the 'experienced hands' will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." - Zen proverb

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don't intend to desert it, and hope the 'experienced hands' will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." - Zen proverb

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don't intend to desert it, and hope the 'experienced hands' will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." - Zen proverb

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Thank you too Mary Beth. I feel blessed to be part of this group too. Sometimes it is nice just to know that there are still people in this world that 'care' about you and coming here is a bonus. The people here care about this special love we share with these companions of ours. Coming here has also afforded me the chance to learn. I am trying to learn how to be less judgemental. I am trying to learn how to listen with a more understanding heart and a less critical ear. It takes practice though and I'm not there yet. Thanks for your support MaryBeth. Thanks to everyone else too for all of their support, especially when my brave little friend and soulmate Lucky lost his long fight for more life. It was so nice to know there were others who understood that FOREVER wouldn't have been long enough. Not one person here said, "Be happy he lived so long!" That...is amazing. That...is proof of man's compassionate soul.

Response:

But the joy was endless and so if pain is the price we must pay for the chance to share so much **magic and pure love**

    Oh geeeze KP, even tho I haven't gone thru the loss of a dog, I do know what you mean here.     I was laying in bed last nite, with Rudy, and we were 'talking' to each other, a lot. He does this kind of weird different inflection type moaning. Not sure how to explain it, but it seems that no matter what I say to him, his response is just like a regular conversation. He answers with different sounds to match exactly my thoughts. I TREASURE this time with him so much.     While we were there last nite, I kept looking at him and just running my fingers softly down his face, (which he *loves*), and telling him just how lucky I felt having him in my life. I've had such a hard time since I've adopted him at 8 weeks old, he's been thru all of it with me, he now will be 9 in Feb. and it breaks my heart, to think ahead. But then I think of how lucky I am to have him with me, NOW.     I truly believe that the powers that be, wherever, have sent him to me, to help me thru this time, and for him to have a very loving and adoring companion in me, too. I worship the ground he walks on, and I would literally give my right arm if I could keep him with me forever. I never knew such love before, and never thought I would love a dog like this. I have others, but he's my special once in a life time dog. I'm sure you and Sue know what I mean.     I am so very sorry for all the losses of beloved pets, and can only try and stay in the now, and not project into the future, I'll have enough of that when that time comes. But I just get so overwhelmed by the love I have for him, and it blows me away. I feel so grateful to have this group to share with and to comfort and to just let it out.     I'm really proud and honored by what you and Sue and many others have shared about your lives with your dogs. Thanks, MaryBeth

Response:

Sue, I am sure sorry to hear about your baby "Jadee". Of course there is nothing I can say to ease this pain, and I'm living proof that the amount of time we have with these angels has no impact on the grief that comes when we lose them. My "Lucky" was old and if he lived to be 100 I'm sure I'd think we were short-changed because 100 yrs. wasn't long enough! There IS no "long enough"...just as having them for a short amount of time is no measure for that same unmeasurable grief that soaks the heart to a point that the sorrow seems like Forever. The way I look at is this:   Sure the pain is horrible. But the joy was endless and so if pain is the price we must pay for the chance to share so much magic and pure love, then believe me...I will consider it worth every ounce of that sorrow FOREVER. And because of your love and the courage of the battle you waged against Jadee's illness...others, like me, will remember Jadee and already, a 'good thing' has come from this experience. Jadee; Lucky; so many other Little Angels...all off on the next leg of their own journey...all off to find their Destiny. Thanks for letting us in on a small part of it all.

Response:

He is also still on his Rimadyl too.

There has been alot of controversy on the use of Rimadly!  Just wanted to point this out to you.  I had a good link for info but I think it's on another screenname.  If interested, email me, and I'll try to find it.  Or, just do an online search on it.   Wondering if you considered the femoral head removal?  Not sure how that would work in your situation but thought I'd mention it.  My dog had this surgery on both sides and it did help him alot. Debbie

Response:

I just want to say thank you to all of you who answered my posts awhile back.  It was quite awhile ago.  It was in regards to Desi having a hip replacement surgery for dysplasia and about the bad time he had at the vet hospital. To remind you, Desi was supposed to be at the University for only 10 days and he was there for 3 weeks.  He had softer bones than they expected and they accidentally drilled the hole for the socket to big.  They also broke his leg when they drilled the hole.  He then developed a fever ranging from 103 to 104.5. Desi has been at home now for the past year and the hip has not compensated for the other hip like we hoped it would. He had hip dysplasia in both hips. He is still having problems with the other hip. Because of the problems from before we will not have the other hip replaced. So now he is on Glucosamine and Chronditin (sp.) 3 times a day.  His attitude is great but he has his bad days too.  He is also still on his Rimadyl too. I just wanted to update you and say thank you to you all. Sue E. & Desi

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last....  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can't thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin' strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn't even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn't have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don't desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don't intend to desert it, and hope the 'experienced hands' will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." - Zen proverb

Response:

To the many people here who are sincere in your efforts to help thank you. For those just interested in judging I'm sorry you have such a sad life with no room for compassion and understanding for others.

Response:

I have no compassion for people who try to unload a very ill dog onto someone else because they can't or WON'T handle it, INSTEAD of having said animal put down, as it should be. A dog who has 7-8 seizures in a 24 hour period WHILE it's taking medication AND attacks people because of said disease can not and will not have a normal or happy life no matter what situation you put it in. In fact a change in its everyday routine or situation (ie; "rehoming") can potentially make the problem worse and unfortunately, probably will. - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - To the many people here who are sincere in your efforts to help thank you. For those just interested in judging I'm sorry you have such a sad life with no room for compassion and understanding for others.

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I'd appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Great! Gail - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - I want to thank everyone who gave me advice on how to make Shadow company in our new house. He was scared for the first two days then he finally left the bathroom and has gone back to his normal routines, and loves the screen porch. In case anyone else going to move their indoor cat what I did was. 1) on moving day I brought him over to the bathroom and put his favorite blanket, food dish, water dish, and litter box so he had something familiar and he was out of the way. 2) I put all the furnature in the living room in the exact position we had it in the apartment. He would not come out of the bathroom for day one. Day two h tired expolring but would only go in the living room on the couch then back in the bathroom. Day 3 he greated me when my alarm went off upstarirs:). He has been in everyroom and on every window sill and even wanted to play fetch. H's completly back to normal and didn't seem to mind when I moved the living room furnatto where I wanted it and then put his things where they belong. -Margaret --     \    o o |/    o  o |/     /         Let it snow!!               http://www.oswego.edu/~es_ind04     ///          "There is such a thing as a stupid question.                   Its the one that is never asked." - MMS

Response:

I want to thank everyone who gave me advice on how to make Shadow company in our new house. He was scared for the first two days then he finally left the bathroom and has gone back to his normal routines, and loves the screen porch. In case anyone else going to move their indoor cat what I did was. 1) on moving day I brought him over to the bathroom and put his favorite blanket, food dish, water dish, and litter box so he had something familiar and he was out of the way. 2) I put all the furnature in the living room in the exact position we had it in the apartment. He would not come out of the bathroom for day one. Day two h tired expolring but would only go in the living room on the couch then back in the bathroom. Day 3 he greated me when my alarm went off upstarirs:). He has been in everyroom and on every window sill and even wanted to play fetch. H's completly back to normal and didn't seem to mind when I moved the living room furnatto where I wanted it and then put his things where they belong. -Margaret --     \    o o |/    o  o    

|/     /         Let it snow!!               http://www.oswego.edu/~es_ind04     ///          "There is such a thing as a stupid question.                   Its the one that is never asked." - MMS          

Response:

Hi all, Thank you for all your great ideas to keep my cat out of the plants.  Hope something will work.  She is also eating the plant and putting her kittylitter out of her box.  She has all the toys a cat can get(scratching post, boxes, toys...) and we play with her all day long to get her tired but she is still acting like this.  She would never let me get any sleep at night.  I love my cat but just dont know how to deal with her anymore.  She is destroying everything she can and she is only 5 months old.  Sometimes I try to convince myself that she will grow out of it but some other times I am really wondering if it will happen.  That cat mean a lot to me but I also need to sleep and try to keep our apt in shape.  Thanks for everything to you all... JB  

Response:

I love my cat but just dont know how to deal with her anymore.  She is destroying everything she can and she is only 5 months old.  Sometimes I try to convince myself that she will grow out of it but some other times I am really wondering if it will happen.

At 5 months, my younger cat did an incredible (expensive) amount of damage. She did grow out of it. Good luck! Alice

Response:

   To those who responded with caring and concern to my last post, I want to say a heartfelt thank-you.  As it turned out, my cat was all right, and almost immediately stopped coughing blood after I posted. I did take her to the vet the day after, and she was given a clean bill of health. Her activity and appitite have been fine since, and I can honestly say I am clueless as to why an otherwise healthy animal was coughing blood to begin with.    To those who felt the need to berate me, and my honest request in a time of great stress and anxiety, I can only say I hope you are never put in the same situation.  It certainly did not help make a bad situation any better.

I'm glad your cat is alright, Jamie, but quite honestly, if I ever found myself in the same situation, I would be getting my cat to the vet, not wasting time posting to the newsgoup. I feel quite strongly that you were dead wrong and have no remorse about berating you.

Response:

        To those who responded with caring and concern to my last post, I want to say a heartfelt thank-you.  As it turned out, my cat was all right, and almost immediately stopped coughing blood after I posted. I did take her to the vet the day after, and she was given a clean bill of health. Her activity and appitite have been fine since, and I can honestly say I am clueless as to why an otherwise healthy animal was coughing blood to begin with.         To those who felt the need to berate me, and my honest request in a time of great stress and anxiety, I can only say I hope you are never put in the same situation.  It certainly did not help make a bad situation any better.         Yours sincerely,         Jamie Riemersma

Response:

Melanie.......    Your search will complete itself when you least expect it. They have a way of finding us at the weirdest times. If you wish to ask any advice about Sibes, please feel free to contact us at your convenience. We have four of the little beauties and there are things you should know about them. They are the most wonderous dogs you could imagine....smart, loving, energetic (!)...but...they aren't for everyone. But on them cold nights.......can't be beat! LOL    Rich and Karen Mahn    Quinn, 'Kasha, Cyrrah and Junior Just remove the spamout I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.

I am contacting rescues for Shibas, - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn't take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone.

Response:

- Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text -I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  And I had never in my life known a relationship with anyone -- human, male, female, canine, whatever -- like I had with Harley.  Most of my memories are happy ones.  I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.  Yeah, just a dog I would rescue from a burning building one million times over before I would risk singing a hair of my head over you. What I need to do is to find a dog (bitch, actually -- I don't know why -- I like girl dogs) who has some of the qualities I loved in Harley without being anything like her.  I know I could not have another Pom.  After all, I already had the best one ever made.  I am contacting rescues for Shibas, Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn't take too long.  My leash hand is empty.

Melanie - Your tribute to Harley was so beautiful and touching - the special bond you shared is something that you will always treasure.  They are never here long enough, but the happiness they bring and their unquestioning devotion are so enriching that we are always ready to open our hearts to another.  You will know when you meet the right girl.  I'll keep my eyes open - State College isn't too far away. Take care.   Carla H. State College, PA Centre County PAWS http://epimedia.com/PAWS

Response:

 (Harley, forgive me.)

You'll find there's nothing that needs forgiving. Getting your next dog is a celebration of the good times you had with the last one. You never forget the first dog, because she's the one who taught you about loving and caring for dogs. Getting your next dog is just the natural process of applying what your first dog has taught you. It isn't easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.

Don't worry about comparisons - the new dog is an addition to your life full of dogs, not a replacement. - ANDREA --                     Get paid to surf the Web!          http://www.alladvantage.com/go.asp?refid=BFN610                   ANDROMEDA - Internet Goddess Bloodaxe's History Links:   http://www.geocities.com/Athens/5055/ The Loony Bin Archive:               http://loonies.net800.co.uk/

Response:

-She said that maybe Harley was a person in her -last life, who just messed up a little bit and had to come back as a dog, -but as a dog with a nice cushy life. I love this idea.  Now I have to figure out what I can do to *mess up* just enough so that I have a life like Harley's next time 'round.  I'd take it over being a people any day! :) Good luck in your search for a new furbaby.  I would suggest not ruling out males, though.  My family has always had female dogs, but now that I have boys I doubt I will ever go back.  I know the right dog is out there for you, and there's always the chance it might be a boy.  You wouldn't want to overlook him if it is!

Response:

Melaine, don't ever feel like you're betraying Harley by wanting another beastie, she'd want you to share the love. There are no replacements, only additions. I'm with you on meeting them again one day, am unable to believe that such pure and unconditional love is given to us and then taken away forever.   Good luck on your search! Trish

Response:

I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.

Oh Melanie, you and Harley fought so bravely. I'm so sorry for you, but happy that you and little Harley found each other and that you have such good memories. The bad will fade but the good will be with you always. Take care of yourself now, and know that we have no control over the creator, but that you did the very best you could for her. Lois E. Posted Via Uncensored-News.Com - Still Only $9.95 - http://www.uncensored-news.com  With Servers In California, Texas And Virginia - The Worlds Uncensored News Source

Response:

: I played with a border collie cross they had there and while she wasn't : the dog for me, I think that I can love another dog.   It really does happen. You can love another dog. They are all so special and unique. A little over 5 years ago I had to put down my English Springer Spaniel of 13 years. Even though I've loved all of my dogs, he was the one that was extra special. I couldn't believe that horrible day had finally come. I was just standing there in the vet's office with an empty collar and leash in my hand and I couldn't hold back the tears. A woman who was waiting to see the vet came up to me and put her arms around me and gave me a hug. After she expressed her condolences, she whispered in my ear, "There are so many more out there that need your love." I have no idea who that woman was. I never will. But I will never forget her or her kindness or her words that ultimately rang so true. I really didn't believe her at the time. I thought my world was over. But she was right, and I'm sure you'll find that out too, if you haven't already.

Response:

Melanie, I know I have responded to another message, but this message really has me so torn up. I hope you find your little furface soon. I can certainly feel and relate to your pain. There is little I can say or do to really comfort you, but I wish I could. I can only pray that Harley sends you another friend soon. Gwen - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn't take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone.

Response:

Melanie - Any dog who finds you to be the owner will be very lucky. And tell your mom from me I think people who are lucky in this life get to come back as dogs belonging to good people :-) instead of being stuck as striving humans ;-)

This is what I'm thinking. Maybe in my next life I'll catch a break and come back as a well loved Basenji. 'Til then I gotta keep racking up that good karma. -- Andrea Stone Saorsa Basenjis "The average dog is a nicer person than the average person." -- Andrew A. Rooney

Response:

I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.

  Refer them to old Sigmund ( a chow-person, I believe).  Freud said our dog is "the one being we never, for a moment, wished dead."   Melanie, please try to avoid the trap, when you think about Harley, of seeking out little lapses you can blame yourself for.  I still do that about my OES who died years ago: "If only I had found the _perfect diet, if only I had, if only....."

Response:

Melanie - Any dog who finds you to be the owner will be very lucky. And tell your mom from me I think people who are lucky in this life get to come back as dogs belonging to good people :-) instead of being stuck as striving humans ;-) Remember the new companion to be should be carefully chosen with lots of logic and realistic consideration of circumstances and then a goodly sized addition of instinct and heart. None will be like Harley but a new friend can help you change from sorrowful thoughts only to fond and happy memories. Nancy - Hide quoted text -- Show quoted text - I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  And I had never in my life known a relationship with anyone -- human, male, female, canine, whatever -- like I had with Harley.  Most of my memories are happy ones.  I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.  Yeah, just a dog I would rescue from a burning building one million times over before I would risk singing a hair of my head over you. Harley was my first dog.  I guess I just got real lucky that I started out with such a special one.  For those of you who haven't known us or heard the story, I actually found Harley on rec.pets.dogs (back when it was all one newsgroup).  So, this little corner of Usenet is pretty special to me for a number of reasons.  When I started looking for a dog in late 1993, I was thinking 80-pound malamute.  Back then, I thought if it didn't weigh over 50 pounds, it wasn't a dog.  (Isn't that funny?) I posted something to the effect of "I'm starting graduate school in the fall and want to adopt a puppy.  I like [every huge spitz breed] and Border Collies.  I am going to take the puppy to school with me and have it sleep under the desk while I am in class."  After being roundly lambasted for my stupidity and naivete, I realized that my plan was a little bit unrealistic.  What puppy was going to sleep through class?  I also realized that with apartment living a smaller dog was going to be a better idea (mostly due to landlord restrictions — heh).  Still committed to the spitz concept, I started looking at smaller ones.  Pomeranians were a bit smaller than I had bargained for, but I liked that they were all spitz, just scaled down.  And, I had to admit, they were pretty damn cute. Then, one day, I saw a post on the newsgroup: "Pomeranian needs home." "A friend of mine is caring for a one-year-old spayed Pom dog, she is a doll.  She loves to cuddle, and go for rides." And it was true. And everyone thought I would never be able to train a dog to go to class with me.  Well, actually, I guess I can’t really take the credit for that.  I just got lucky, again.  Harley came that way.  (She also came with the name "Muffie," but we did something about that right away.) Harley was carrying a special soul and even my mother, a card-carrying Buddhist, agrees.  (And Mom doesn’t even really like dogs.  She loved Harley though.  She used to say that Harley was "yangban," or high class, because everything she did was so tidy and perfect and she carried herself like a lady.  It was true.) She said that maybe Harley was a person in her last life, who just messed up a little bit and had to come back as a dog, but as a dog with a nice cushy life.  And the reason she had to go so soon is that she had more than made up for whatever she did before.  Even though I have never subscribed to any religion, of any flavor, I think that I will meet Harley again.  My mother said Harley might even come back as my daughter.  It might almost be worth having a kid for that.  Right? Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.  While I was in Virginia during the weekend, I went to the animal shelter to see if I could love another dog. I played with a border collie cross they had there and while she wasn’t the dog for me, I think that I can love another dog.  (Actually I am pretty certain she was a collie/BC mix.  This shelter is notorious for horrifying breed misidentifications: the tag on the kennel said "German Shepherd/Cocker Spaniel mix."  !!!  Anyone looking for a nice BC cross in Northern Virginia?  Call Fairfax County Animal Control and ask them about Emma.) What I need to do is to find a dog (bitch, actually — I don’t know why — I like girl dogs) who has some of the qualities I loved in Harley without being anything like her.  I know I could not have another Pom.  After all, I already had the best one ever made.  I am contacting rescues for Shibas, Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn’t take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone. * By the way, if anyone wants an honest-to-God lurcher in the Philly area, they have a nice one at the Morris Animal Refuge.  Her name is Nadia and she is listed as a "terrier X" which I am sure she is, but I am certain the other half is whippet or greyhound.  She’s like a little golden wire-haired gazelle.  I can’t adopt from this shelter because they actually do call your landlord to see if you can have a dog.  But I figured someone who can might like Nadia. —   Melanie Lee Chang                        |  Repetition is the death   Departments of Anthropology and Biology  |  of art.   University of Pennsylvania               |

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.   So we will bring another into our house who will fill the common physical things that the loss of Schautzie has created, but they will never fill any of the loss that is there from not having our unique loving girl here with us any longer.  What they will do however is start to create another space in our lives which doesn’t exist right now that only they can fill. Gary

Oh Gary and Melanie, Both of your messages have me in tears. I know so well the pain. I am so sorry to hear about both of your dogs. You are right about never being able to replace the one and yet you have opened your heart up and your home to another who needs your love and devotion in exchange for the same. I had a terrible experience that occured in late August the pain is still very much there and will be for a lifetime. I have gone to the pet grieving group for kind support and it has helped, but it will never get me over what I did. Take care both of you and open your hearts up to another furface soon. Gwen

Response:

Melanie, I wish I could be lucky enough to return to this earth as your dog. :o ) Carol – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  And I had never in my life known a relationship with anyone — human, male, female, canine, whatever — like I had with Harley.  Most of my memories are happy ones.  I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.  Yeah, just a dog I would rescue from a burning building one million times over before I would risk singing a hair of my head over you. Harley was my first dog.  I guess I just got real lucky that I started out with such a special one.  For those of you who haven’t known us or heard the story, I actually found Harley on rec.pets.dogs (back when it was all one newsgroup).  So, this little corner of Usenet is pretty special to me for a number of reasons.  When I started looking for a dog in late 1993, I was thinking 80-pound malamute.  Back then, I thought if it didn’t weigh over 50 pounds, it wasn’t a dog.  (Isn’t that funny?) I posted something to the effect of "I’m starting graduate school in the fall and want to adopt a puppy.  I like [every huge spitz breed] and Border Collies.  I am going to take the puppy to school with me and have it sleep under the desk while I am in class."  After being roundly lambasted for my stupidity and naivete, I realized that my plan was a little bit unrealistic.  What puppy was going to sleep through class?  I also realized that with apartment living a smaller dog was going to be a better idea (mostly due to landlord restrictions — heh).  Still committed to the spitz concept, I started looking at smaller ones.  Pomeranians were a bit smaller than I had bargained for, but I liked that they were all spitz, just scaled down.  And, I had to admit, they were pretty damn cute. Then, one day, I saw a post on the newsgroup: "Pomeranian needs home." "A friend of mine is caring for a one-year-old spayed Pom dog, she is a doll.  She loves to cuddle, and go for rides." And it was true. And everyone thought I would never be able to train a dog to go to class with me.  Well, actually, I guess I can’t really take the credit for that.  I just got lucky, again.  Harley came that way.  (She also came with the name "Muffie," but we did something about that right away.) Harley was carrying a special soul and even my mother, a card-carrying Buddhist, agrees.  (And Mom doesn’t even really like dogs.  She loved Harley though.  She used to say that Harley was "yangban," or high class, because everything she did was so tidy and perfect and she carried herself like a lady.  It was true.) She said that maybe Harley was a person in her last life, who just messed up a little bit and had to come back as a dog, but as a dog with a nice cushy life.  And the reason she had to go so soon is that she had more than made up for whatever she did before.  Even though I have never subscribed to any religion, of any flavor, I think that I will meet Harley again.  My mother said Harley might even come back as my daughter.  It might almost be worth having a kid for that.  Right? Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.  While I was in Virginia during the weekend, I went to the animal shelter to see if I could love another dog. I played with a border collie cross they had there and while she wasn’t the dog for me, I think that I can love another dog.  (Actually I am pretty certain she was a collie/BC mix.  This shelter is notorious for horrifying breed misidentifications: the tag on the kennel said "German Shepherd/Cocker Spaniel mix."  !!!  Anyone looking for a nice BC cross in Northern Virginia?  Call Fairfax County Animal Control and ask them about Emma.) What I need to do is to find a dog (bitch, actually — I don’t know why — I like girl dogs) who has some of the qualities I loved in Harley without being anything like her.  I know I could not have another Pom.  After all, I already had the best one ever made.  I am contacting rescues for Shibas, Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn’t take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone. * By the way, if anyone wants an honest-to-God lurcher in the Philly area, they have a nice one at the Morris Animal Refuge.  Her name is Nadia and she is listed as a "terrier X" which I am sure she is, but I am certain the other half is whippet or greyhound.  She’s like a little golden wire-haired gazelle.  I can’t adopt from this shelter because they actually do call your landlord to see if you can have a dog.  But I figured someone who can might like Nadia. —   Melanie Lee Chang                        |  Repetition is the death   Departments of Anthropology and Biology  |  of art.   University of Pennsylvania               |

Response:

Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.

Both statements are true and separate.  We had to put our Schautzie to sleep eleven days ago.  There are two separate components that occur, the grieving over the unique life that has been lost, and the loss of the companionship and all the common physical things that go with having a good dog, the companionship, the areas of the house that just don’t look right without a dog lieing there, and millions of others.  In getting a new dog, those are the things we replace, not the unique life we were privleged to share. I went to the shelter a couple of days ago to pick up some German Shepherd Dog mugs that they had that no place else did.  In spite of the pain, I had to look at the available dogs that were there, dog after dog wagging and kissing and wanting what we had available, a home that could give them love and people to be with.  So we will bring another into our house who will fill the common physical things that the loss of Schautzie has created, but they will never fill any of the loss that is there from not having our unique loving girl here with us any longer.  What they will do however is start to create another space in our lives which doesn’t exist right now that only they can fill. Gary

Response:

I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  And I had never in my life known a relationship with anyone — human, male, female, canine, whatever — like I had with Harley.  Most of my memories are happy ones.  I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.  Yeah, just a dog I would rescue from a burning building one million times over before I would risk singing a hair of my head over you. Harley was my first dog.  I guess I just got real lucky that I started out with such a special one.  For those of you who haven’t known us or heard the story, I actually found Harley on rec.pets.dogs (back when it was all one newsgroup).  So, this little corner of Usenet is pretty special to me for a number of reasons.  When I started looking for a dog in late 1993, I was thinking 80-pound malamute.  Back then, I thought if it didn’t weigh over 50 pounds, it wasn’t a dog.  (Isn’t that funny?) I posted something to the effect of "I’m starting graduate school in the fall and want to adopt a puppy.  I like [every huge spitz breed] and Border Collies.  I am going to take the puppy to school with me and have it sleep under the desk while I am in class."  After being roundly lambasted for my stupidity and naivete, I realized that my plan was a little bit unrealistic.  What puppy was going to sleep through class?  I also realized that with apartment living a smaller dog was going to be a better idea (mostly due to landlord restrictions — heh).  Still committed to the spitz concept, I started looking at smaller ones.  Pomeranians were a bit smaller than I had bargained for, but I liked that they were all spitz, just scaled down.  And, I had to admit, they were pretty damn cute. Then, one day, I saw a post on the newsgroup: "Pomeranian needs home." "A friend of mine is caring for a one-year-old spayed Pom dog, she is a doll.  She loves to cuddle, and go for rides." And it was true. And everyone thought I would never be able to train a dog to go to class with me.  Well, actually, I guess I can’t really take the credit for that.  I just got lucky, again.  Harley came that way.  (She also came with the name "Muffie," but we did something about that right away.) Harley was carrying a special soul and even my mother, a card-carrying Buddhist, agrees.  (And Mom doesn’t even really like dogs.  She loved Harley though.  She used to say that Harley was "yangban," or high class, because everything she did was so tidy and perfect and she carried herself like a lady.  It was true.) She said that maybe Harley was a person in her last life, who just messed up a little bit and had to come back as a dog, but as a dog with a nice cushy life.  And the reason she had to go so soon is that she had more than made up for whatever she did before.  Even though I have never subscribed to any religion, of any flavor, I think that I will meet Harley again.  My mother said Harley might even come back as my daughter.  It might almost be worth having a kid for that.  Right? Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.  While I was in Virginia during the weekend, I went to the animal shelter to see if I could love another dog. I played with a border collie cross they had there and while she wasn’t the dog for me, I think that I can love another dog.  (Actually I am pretty certain she was a collie/BC mix.  This shelter is notorious for horrifying breed misidentifications: the tag on the kennel said "German Shepherd/Cocker Spaniel mix."  !!!  Anyone looking for a nice BC cross in Northern Virginia?  Call Fairfax County Animal Control and ask them about Emma.) What I need to do is to find a dog (bitch, actually — I don’t know why — I like girl dogs) who has some of the qualities I loved in Harley without being anything like her.  I know I could not have another Pom.  After all, I already had the best one ever made.  I am contacting rescues for Shibas, Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn’t take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone. * By the way, if anyone wants an honest-to-God lurcher in the Philly area, they have a nice one at the Morris Animal Refuge.  Her name is Nadia and she is listed as a "terrier X" which I am sure she is, but I am certain the other half is whippet or greyhound.  She’s like a little golden wire-haired gazelle.  I can’t adopt from this shelter because they actually do call your landlord to see if you can have a dog.  But I figured someone who can might like Nadia. —   Melanie Lee Chang                        |  Repetition is the death   Departments of Anthropology and Biology  |  of art.   University of Pennsylvania               |  

Response:

Thank you too Mary Beth. I feel blessed to be part of this group too. Sometimes it is nice just to know that there are still people in this world that ‘care’ about you and coming here is a bonus. The people here care about this special love we share with these companions of ours. Coming here has also afforded me the chance to learn. I am trying to learn how to be less judgemental. I am trying to learn how to listen with a more understanding heart and a less critical ear. It takes practice though and I’m not there yet. Thanks for your support MaryBeth. Thanks to everyone else too for all of their support, especially when my brave little friend and soulmate Lucky lost his long fight for more life. It was so nice to know there were others who understood that FOREVER wouldn’t have been long enough. Not one person here said, "Be happy he lived so long!" That…is amazing. That…is proof of man’s compassionate soul.

Response:

But the joy was endless and so if pain is the price we must pay for the chance to share so much **magic and pure love**

    Oh geeeze KP, even tho I haven’t gone thru the loss of a dog, I do know what you mean here.     I was laying in bed last nite, with Rudy, and we were ‘talking’ to each other, a lot. He does this kind of weird different inflection type moaning. Not sure how to explain it, but it seems that no matter what I say to him, his response is just like a regular conversation. He answers with different sounds to match exactly my thoughts. I TREASURE this time with him so much.     While we were there last nite, I kept looking at him and just running my fingers softly down his face, (which he *loves*), and telling him just how lucky I felt having him in my life. I’ve had such a hard time since I’ve adopted him at 8 weeks old, he’s been thru all of it with me, he now will be 9 in Feb. and it breaks my heart, to think ahead. But then I think of how lucky I am to have him with me, NOW.     I truly believe that the powers that be, wherever, have sent him to me, to help me thru this time, and for him to have a very loving and adoring companion in me, too. I worship the ground he walks on, and I would literally give my right arm if I could keep him with me forever. I never knew such love before, and never thought I would love a dog like this. I have others, but he’s my special once in a life time dog. I’m sure you and Sue know what I mean.     I am so very sorry for all the losses of beloved pets, and can only try and stay in the now, and not project into the future, I’ll have enough of that when that time comes. But I just get so overwhelmed by the love I have for him, and it blows me away. I feel so grateful to have this group to share with and to comfort and to just let it out.     I’m really proud and honored by what you and Sue and many others have shared about your lives with your dogs. Thanks, MaryBeth

Response:

Sue, I am sure sorry to hear about your baby "Jadee". Of course there is nothing I can say to ease this pain, and I’m living proof that the amount of time we have with these angels has no impact on the grief that comes when we lose them. My "Lucky" was old and if he lived to be 100 I’m sure I’d think we were short-changed because 100 yrs. wasn’t long enough! There IS no "long enough"…just as having them for a short amount of time is no measure for that same unmeasurable grief that soaks the heart to a point that the sorrow seems like Forever. The way I look at is this:   Sure the pain is horrible. But the joy was endless and so if pain is the price we must pay for the chance to share so much magic and pure love, then believe me…I will consider it worth every ounce of that sorrow FOREVER. And because of your love and the courage of the battle you waged against Jadee’s illness…others, like me, will remember Jadee and already, a ‘good thing’ has come from this experience. Jadee; Lucky; so many other Little Angels…all off on the next leg of their own journey…all off to find their Destiny. Thanks for letting us in on a small part of it all.

Response:

He is also still on his Rimadyl too.

There has been alot of controversy on the use of Rimadly!  Just wanted to point this out to you.  I had a good link for info but I think it’s on another screenname.  If interested, email me, and I’ll try to find it.  Or, just do an online search on it.   Wondering if you considered the femoral head removal?  Not sure how that would work in your situation but thought I’d mention it.  My dog had this surgery on both sides and it did help him alot. Debbie

Response:

I just want to say thank you to all of you who answered my posts awhile back.  It was quite awhile ago.  It was in regards to Desi having a hip replacement surgery for dysplasia and about the bad time he had at the vet hospital. To remind you, Desi was supposed to be at the University for only 10 days and he was there for 3 weeks.  He had softer bones than they expected and they accidentally drilled the hole for the socket to big.  They also broke his leg when they drilled the hole.  He then developed a fever ranging from 103 to 104.5. Desi has been at home now for the past year and the hip has not compensated for the other hip like we hoped it would. He had hip dysplasia in both hips. He is still having problems with the other hip. Because of the problems from before we will not have the other hip replaced. So now he is on Glucosamine and Chronditin (sp.) 3 times a day.  His attitude is great but he has his bad days too.  He is also still on his Rimadyl too. I just wanted to update you and say thank you to you all. Sue E. & Desi

Response:

Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last….  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

I am so sorry for your lost. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi everyone, I just wanted to thank you all for the numerous emails and posts that you have sent since we lost Jadee (and during the whole ordeal).  I know I am not the first to have gone through this, nor will I be the last….  but it was a first for me.  My first dog who you all helped me raise, and my first dog, who you all helped me say good-bye to. Thank you for letting me brag. Thank you for letting me cry. Thank you for helping me heal. We are not over the loss, nor will we ever be, I suspect.  But I have been able to cope, greatly due to the incredible support we received both online and IRL. Please give your pups a hug and a kiss for me, and throw the ball a few times for Jadee. Sue  missing Jadee

Response:

   A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can’t thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin’ strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn’t even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn’t have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don’t desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.          Anne

Response:

  A few months ago I asked the NG for help in training my partially blind Shih Tzu puppy. I can’t thank you enough times for all the helpful suggestions, Bob Maida, thank you for turning me on to clicker training I am using it for the puppy and it took no time at all for the adults, I have a Std Poodle and 4 maltese, to pick it up. I use Beggin’ strips as reward and of course they have to have thier "fair" share and are training right along with Tank. Lorrie thank you for suggesting I talk to him before I pick him up it didn’t even cross my mind I was scaring him. I hope this group remembers all of us luckers who would lose so much if we didn’t have the helpful, experienced, kind people who give such needed and appreciated advice. Please don’t desert the NG those of us who care will learn to watch, and know a pile of sh*t when we see it.         Anne

I echo Anne. I appreciate RPDB and I don’t intend to desert it, and hope the ‘experienced hands’ will hang in there with us newbies!!!! ****** KimBoo "After ecstacy, the laundry." – Zen proverb

Response:

To the many people here who are sincere in your efforts to help thank you. For those just interested in judging I’m sorry you have such a sad life with no room for compassion and understanding for others.

Response:

I have no compassion for people who try to unload a very ill dog onto someone else because they can’t or WON’T handle it, INSTEAD of having said animal put down, as it should be. A dog who has 7-8 seizures in a 24 hour period WHILE it’s taking medication AND attacks people because of said disease can not and will not have a normal or happy life no matter what situation you put it in. In fact a change in its everyday routine or situation (ie; "rehoming") can potentially make the problem worse and unfortunately, probably will. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – To the many people here who are sincere in your efforts to help thank you. For those just interested in judging I’m sorry you have such a sad life with no room for compassion and understanding for others.

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Response:

Hello everybody! I am just back from my trip to Australia. Thanks to everybody who gave me useful hints, I received many of them! To all Australians: you are living in a really wonderful country! Corina

Where did you go and what did you do ? Only 5 weeks to go until we set off. Via Aukland (4 days) into Cairns (5 or so days) down to the Whitsundays (live aboard cruise ?) into Brisbane (3 days) then down to Sydney (4/5 days) and back via Fiji (3 days). Anything you can recommend doing ? I’d appreciate your thoughts. Thanks Dave

Response:

Great! Gail – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I want to thank everyone who gave me advice on how to make Shadow company in our new house. He was scared for the first two days then he finally left the bathroom and has gone back to his normal routines, and loves the screen porch. In case anyone else going to move their indoor cat what I did was. 1) on moving day I brought him over to the bathroom and put his favorite blanket, food dish, water dish, and litter box so he had something familiar and he was out of the way. 2) I put all the furnature in the living room in the exact position we had it in the apartment. He would not come out of the bathroom for day one. Day two h tired expolring but would only go in the living room on the couch then back in the bathroom. Day 3 he greated me when my alarm went off upstarirs:). He has been in everyroom and on every window sill and even wanted to play fetch. H’s completly back to normal and didn’t seem to mind when I moved the living room furnatto where I wanted it and then put his things where they belong. -Margaret —     \    o o |/    o  o |/     /         Let it snow!!               http://www.oswego.edu/~es_ind04     ///          "There is such a thing as a stupid question.                   Its the one that is never asked." – MMS

Response:

I want to thank everyone who gave me advice on how to make Shadow company in our new house. He was scared for the first two days then he finally left the bathroom and has gone back to his normal routines, and loves the screen porch. In case anyone else going to move their indoor cat what I did was. 1) on moving day I brought him over to the bathroom and put his favorite blanket, food dish, water dish, and litter box so he had something familiar and he was out of the way. 2) I put all the furnature in the living room in the exact position we had it in the apartment. He would not come out of the bathroom for day one. Day two h tired expolring but would only go in the living room on the couch then back in the bathroom. Day 3 he greated me when my alarm went off upstarirs:). He has been in everyroom and on every window sill and even wanted to play fetch. H’s completly back to normal and didn’t seem to mind when I moved the living room furnatto where I wanted it and then put his things where they belong. -Margaret —     \    o o |/    o  o    

|/     /         Let it snow!!               http://www.oswego.edu/~es_ind04     ///          "There is such a thing as a stupid question.                   Its the one that is never asked." – MMS          

Response:

Hi all, Thank you for all your great ideas to keep my cat out of the plants.  Hope something will work.  She is also eating the plant and putting her kittylitter out of her box.  She has all the toys a cat can get(scratching post, boxes, toys…) and we play with her all day long to get her tired but she is still acting like this.  She would never let me get any sleep at night.  I love my cat but just dont know how to deal with her anymore.  She is destroying everything she can and she is only 5 months old.  Sometimes I try to convince myself that she will grow out of it but some other times I am really wondering if it will happen.  That cat mean a lot to me but I also need to sleep and try to keep our apt in shape.  Thanks for everything to you all… JB  

Response:

I love my cat but just dont know how to deal with her anymore.  She is destroying everything she can and she is only 5 months old.  Sometimes I try to convince myself that she will grow out of it but some other times I am really wondering if it will happen.

At 5 months, my younger cat did an incredible (expensive) amount of damage. She did grow out of it. Good luck! Alice

Response:

   To those who responded with caring and concern to my last post, I want to say a heartfelt thank-you.  As it turned out, my cat was all right, and almost immediately stopped coughing blood after I posted. I did take her to the vet the day after, and she was given a clean bill of health. Her activity and appitite have been fine since, and I can honestly say I am clueless as to why an otherwise healthy animal was coughing blood to begin with.    To those who felt the need to berate me, and my honest request in a time of great stress and anxiety, I can only say I hope you are never put in the same situation.  It certainly did not help make a bad situation any better.

I’m glad your cat is alright, Jamie, but quite honestly, if I ever found myself in the same situation, I would be getting my cat to the vet, not wasting time posting to the newsgoup. I feel quite strongly that you were dead wrong and have no remorse about berating you.

Response:

        To those who responded with caring and concern to my last post, I want to say a heartfelt thank-you.  As it turned out, my cat was all right, and almost immediately stopped coughing blood after I posted. I did take her to the vet the day after, and she was given a clean bill of health. Her activity and appitite have been fine since, and I can honestly say I am clueless as to why an otherwise healthy animal was coughing blood to begin with.         To those who felt the need to berate me, and my honest request in a time of great stress and anxiety, I can only say I hope you are never put in the same situation.  It certainly did not help make a bad situation any better.         Yours sincerely,         Jamie Riemersma

Response:

Melanie…….    Your search will complete itself when you least expect it. They have a way of finding us at the weirdest times. If you wish to ask any advice about Sibes, please feel free to contact us at your convenience. We have four of the little beauties and there are things you should know about them. They are the most wonderous dogs you could imagine….smart, loving, energetic (!)…but…they aren’t for everyone. But on them cold nights…….can’t be beat! LOL    Rich and Karen Mahn    Quinn, ‘Kasha, Cyrrah and Junior Just remove the spamout I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.

I am contacting rescues for Shibas, – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn’t take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  And I had never in my life known a relationship with anyone — human, male, female, canine, whatever — like I had with Harley.  Most of my memories are happy ones.  I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.  Yeah, just a dog I would rescue from a burning building one million times over before I would risk singing a hair of my head over you. What I need to do is to find a dog (bitch, actually — I don’t know why — I like girl dogs) who has some of the qualities I loved in Harley without being anything like her.  I know I could not have another Pom.  After all, I already had the best one ever made.  I am contacting rescues for Shibas, Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn’t take too long.  My leash hand is empty.

Melanie – Your tribute to Harley was so beautiful and touching – the special bond you shared is something that you will always treasure.  They are never here long enough, but the happiness they bring and their unquestioning devotion are so enriching that we are always ready to open our hearts to another.  You will know when you meet the right girl.  I’ll keep my eyes open – State College isn’t too far away. Take care.   Carla H. State College, PA Centre County PAWS http://epimedia.com/PAWS

Response:

 (Harley, forgive me.)

You’ll find there’s nothing that needs forgiving. Getting your next dog is a celebration of the good times you had with the last one. You never forget the first dog, because she’s the one who taught you about loving and caring for dogs. Getting your next dog is just the natural process of applying what your first dog has taught you. It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.

Don’t worry about comparisons – the new dog is an addition to your life full of dogs, not a replacement. – ANDREA —                     Get paid to surf the Web!          http://www.alladvantage.com/go.asp?refid=BFN610                   ANDROMEDA – Internet Goddess Bloodaxe’s History Links:   http://www.geocities.com/Athens/5055/ The Loony Bin Archive:               http://loonies.net800.co.uk/

Response:

-She said that maybe Harley was a person in her -last life, who just messed up a little bit and had to come back as a dog, -but as a dog with a nice cushy life. I love this idea.  Now I have to figure out what I can do to *mess up* just enough so that I have a life like Harley’s next time ’round.  I’d take it over being a people any day! :) Good luck in your search for a new furbaby.  I would suggest not ruling out males, though.  My family has always had female dogs, but now that I have boys I doubt I will ever go back.  I know the right dog is out there for you, and there’s always the chance it might be a boy.  You wouldn’t want to overlook him if it is!

Response:

Melaine, don’t ever feel like you’re betraying Harley by wanting another beastie, she’d want you to share the love. There are no replacements, only additions. I’m with you on meeting them again one day, am unable to believe that such pure and unconditional love is given to us and then taken away forever.   Good luck on your search! Trish

Response:

I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.

Oh Melanie, you and Harley fought so bravely. I’m so sorry for you, but happy that you and little Harley found each other and that you have such good memories. The bad will fade but the good will be with you always. Take care of yourself now, and know that we have no control over the creator, but that you did the very best you could for her. Lois E. Posted Via Uncensored-News.Com – Still Only $9.95 – http://www.uncensored-news.com  With Servers In California, Texas And Virginia – The Worlds Uncensored News Source

Response:

: I played with a border collie cross they had there and while she wasn’t : the dog for me, I think that I can love another dog.   It really does happen. You can love another dog. They are all so special and unique. A little over 5 years ago I had to put down my English Springer Spaniel of 13 years. Even though I’ve loved all of my dogs, he was the one that was extra special. I couldn’t believe that horrible day had finally come. I was just standing there in the vet’s office with an empty collar and leash in my hand and I couldn’t hold back the tears. A woman who was waiting to see the vet came up to me and put her arms around me and gave me a hug. After she expressed her condolences, she whispered in my ear, "There are so many more out there that need your love." I have no idea who that woman was. I never will. But I will never forget her or her kindness or her words that ultimately rang so true. I really didn’t believe her at the time. I thought my world was over. But she was right, and I’m sure you’ll find that out too, if you haven’t already.

Response:

Melanie, I know I have responded to another message, but this message really has me so torn up. I hope you find your little furface soon. I can certainly feel and relate to your pain. There is little I can say or do to really comfort you, but I wish I could. I can only pray that Harley sends you another friend soon. Gwen – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn’t take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone.

Response:

Melanie – Any dog who finds you to be the owner will be very lucky. And tell your mom from me I think people who are lucky in this life get to come back as dogs belonging to good people :-) instead of being stuck as striving humans ;-)

This is what I’m thinking. Maybe in my next life I’ll catch a break and come back as a well loved Basenji. ‘Til then I gotta keep racking up that good karma. — Andrea Stone Saorsa Basenjis "The average dog is a nicer person than the average person." — Andrew A. Rooney

Response:

I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.

  Refer them to old Sigmund ( a chow-person, I believe).  Freud said our dog is "the one being we never, for a moment, wished dead."   Melanie, please try to avoid the trap, when you think about Harley, of seeking out little lapses you can blame yourself for.  I still do that about my OES who died years ago: "If only I had found the _perfect diet, if only I had, if only….."

Response:

Melanie – Any dog who finds you to be the owner will be very lucky. And tell your mom from me I think people who are lucky in this life get to come back as dogs belonging to good people :-) instead of being stuck as striving humans ;-) Remember the new companion to be should be carefully chosen with lots of logic and realistic consideration of circumstances and then a goodly sized addition of instinct and heart. None will be like Harley but a new friend can help you change from sorrowful thoughts only to fond and happy memories. Nancy – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  And I had never in my life known a relationship with anyone — human, male, female, canine, whatever — like I had with Harley.  Most of my memories are happy ones.  I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.  Yeah, just a dog I would rescue from a burning building one million times over before I would risk singing a hair of my head over you. Harley was my first dog.  I guess I just got real lucky that I started out with such a special one.  For those of you who haven’t known us or heard the story, I actually found Harley on rec.pets.dogs (back when it was all one newsgroup).  So, this little corner of Usenet is pretty special to me for a number of reasons.  When I started looking for a dog in late 1993, I was thinking 80-pound malamute.  Back then, I thought if it didn’t weigh over 50 pounds, it wasn’t a dog.  (Isn’t that funny?) I posted something to the effect of "I’m starting graduate school in the fall and want to adopt a puppy.  I like [every huge spitz breed] and Border Collies.  I am going to take the puppy to school with me and have it sleep under the desk while I am in class."  After being roundly lambasted for my stupidity and naivete, I realized that my plan was a little bit unrealistic.  What puppy was going to sleep through class?  I also realized that with apartment living a smaller dog was going to be a better idea (mostly due to landlord restrictions — heh).  Still committed to the spitz concept, I started looking at smaller ones.  Pomeranians were a bit smaller than I had bargained for, but I liked that they were all spitz, just scaled down.  And, I had to admit, they were pretty damn cute. Then, one day, I saw a post on the newsgroup: "Pomeranian needs home." "A friend of mine is caring for a one-year-old spayed Pom dog, she is a doll.  She loves to cuddle, and go for rides." And it was true. And everyone thought I would never be able to train a dog to go to class with me.  Well, actually, I guess I can’t really take the credit for that.  I just got lucky, again.  Harley came that way.  (She also came with the name "Muffie," but we did something about that right away.) Harley was carrying a special soul and even my mother, a card-carrying Buddhist, agrees.  (And Mom doesn’t even really like dogs.  She loved Harley though.  She used to say that Harley was "yangban," or high class, because everything she did was so tidy and perfect and she carried herself like a lady.  It was true.) She said that maybe Harley was a person in her last life, who just messed up a little bit and had to come back as a dog, but as a dog with a nice cushy life.  And the reason she had to go so soon is that she had more than made up for whatever she did before.  Even though I have never subscribed to any religion, of any flavor, I think that I will meet Harley again.  My mother said Harley might even come back as my daughter.  It might almost be worth having a kid for that.  Right? Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.  While I was in Virginia during the weekend, I went to the animal shelter to see if I could love another dog. I played with a border collie cross they had there and while she wasn’t the dog for me, I think that I can love another dog.  (Actually I am pretty certain she was a collie/BC mix.  This shelter is notorious for horrifying breed misidentifications: the tag on the kennel said "German Shepherd/Cocker Spaniel mix."  !!!  Anyone looking for a nice BC cross in Northern Virginia?  Call Fairfax County Animal Control and ask them about Emma.) What I need to do is to find a dog (bitch, actually — I don’t know why — I like girl dogs) who has some of the qualities I loved in Harley without being anything like her.  I know I could not have another Pom.  After all, I already had the best one ever made.  I am contacting rescues for Shibas, Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn’t take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone. * By the way, if anyone wants an honest-to-God lurcher in the Philly area, they have a nice one at the Morris Animal Refuge.  Her name is Nadia and she is listed as a "terrier X" which I am sure she is, but I am certain the other half is whippet or greyhound.  She’s like a little golden wire-haired gazelle.  I can’t adopt from this shelter because they actually do call your landlord to see if you can have a dog.  But I figured someone who can might like Nadia. —   Melanie Lee Chang                        |  Repetition is the death   Departments of Anthropology and Biology  |  of art.   University of Pennsylvania               |

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.   So we will bring another into our house who will fill the common physical things that the loss of Schautzie has created, but they will never fill any of the loss that is there from not having our unique loving girl here with us any longer.  What they will do however is start to create another space in our lives which doesn’t exist right now that only they can fill. Gary

Oh Gary and Melanie, Both of your messages have me in tears. I know so well the pain. I am so sorry to hear about both of your dogs. You are right about never being able to replace the one and yet you have opened your heart up and your home to another who needs your love and devotion in exchange for the same. I had a terrible experience that occured in late August the pain is still very much there and will be for a lifetime. I have gone to the pet grieving group for kind support and it has helped, but it will never get me over what I did. Take care both of you and open your hearts up to another furface soon. Gwen

Response:

Melanie, I wish I could be lucky enough to return to this earth as your dog. :o ) Carol – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  And I had never in my life known a relationship with anyone — human, male, female, canine, whatever — like I had with Harley.  Most of my memories are happy ones.  I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.  Yeah, just a dog I would rescue from a burning building one million times over before I would risk singing a hair of my head over you. Harley was my first dog.  I guess I just got real lucky that I started out with such a special one.  For those of you who haven’t known us or heard the story, I actually found Harley on rec.pets.dogs (back when it was all one newsgroup).  So, this little corner of Usenet is pretty special to me for a number of reasons.  When I started looking for a dog in late 1993, I was thinking 80-pound malamute.  Back then, I thought if it didn’t weigh over 50 pounds, it wasn’t a dog.  (Isn’t that funny?) I posted something to the effect of "I’m starting graduate school in the fall and want to adopt a puppy.  I like [every huge spitz breed] and Border Collies.  I am going to take the puppy to school with me and have it sleep under the desk while I am in class."  After being roundly lambasted for my stupidity and naivete, I realized that my plan was a little bit unrealistic.  What puppy was going to sleep through class?  I also realized that with apartment living a smaller dog was going to be a better idea (mostly due to landlord restrictions — heh).  Still committed to the spitz concept, I started looking at smaller ones.  Pomeranians were a bit smaller than I had bargained for, but I liked that they were all spitz, just scaled down.  And, I had to admit, they were pretty damn cute. Then, one day, I saw a post on the newsgroup: "Pomeranian needs home." "A friend of mine is caring for a one-year-old spayed Pom dog, she is a doll.  She loves to cuddle, and go for rides." And it was true. And everyone thought I would never be able to train a dog to go to class with me.  Well, actually, I guess I can’t really take the credit for that.  I just got lucky, again.  Harley came that way.  (She also came with the name "Muffie," but we did something about that right away.) Harley was carrying a special soul and even my mother, a card-carrying Buddhist, agrees.  (And Mom doesn’t even really like dogs.  She loved Harley though.  She used to say that Harley was "yangban," or high class, because everything she did was so tidy and perfect and she carried herself like a lady.  It was true.) She said that maybe Harley was a person in her last life, who just messed up a little bit and had to come back as a dog, but as a dog with a nice cushy life.  And the reason she had to go so soon is that she had more than made up for whatever she did before.  Even though I have never subscribed to any religion, of any flavor, I think that I will meet Harley again.  My mother said Harley might even come back as my daughter.  It might almost be worth having a kid for that.  Right? Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.  While I was in Virginia during the weekend, I went to the animal shelter to see if I could love another dog. I played with a border collie cross they had there and while she wasn’t the dog for me, I think that I can love another dog.  (Actually I am pretty certain she was a collie/BC mix.  This shelter is notorious for horrifying breed misidentifications: the tag on the kennel said "German Shepherd/Cocker Spaniel mix."  !!!  Anyone looking for a nice BC cross in Northern Virginia?  Call Fairfax County Animal Control and ask them about Emma.) What I need to do is to find a dog (bitch, actually — I don’t know why — I like girl dogs) who has some of the qualities I loved in Harley without being anything like her.  I know I could not have another Pom.  After all, I already had the best one ever made.  I am contacting rescues for Shibas, Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn’t take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone. * By the way, if anyone wants an honest-to-God lurcher in the Philly area, they have a nice one at the Morris Animal Refuge.  Her name is Nadia and she is listed as a "terrier X" which I am sure she is, but I am certain the other half is whippet or greyhound.  She’s like a little golden wire-haired gazelle.  I can’t adopt from this shelter because they actually do call your landlord to see if you can have a dog.  But I figured someone who can might like Nadia. —   Melanie Lee Chang                        |  Repetition is the death   Departments of Anthropology and Biology  |  of art.   University of Pennsylvania               |

Response:

Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.

Both statements are true and separate.  We had to put our Schautzie to sleep eleven days ago.  There are two separate components that occur, the grieving over the unique life that has been lost, and the loss of the companionship and all the common physical things that go with having a good dog, the companionship, the areas of the house that just don’t look right without a dog lieing there, and millions of others.  In getting a new dog, those are the things we replace, not the unique life we were privleged to share. I went to the shelter a couple of days ago to pick up some German Shepherd Dog mugs that they had that no place else did.  In spite of the pain, I had to look at the available dogs that were there, dog after dog wagging and kissing and wanting what we had available, a home that could give them love and people to be with.  So we will bring another into our house who will fill the common physical things that the loss of Schautzie has created, but they will never fill any of the loss that is there from not having our unique loving girl here with us any longer.  What they will do however is start to create another space in our lives which doesn’t exist right now that only they can fill. Gary

Response:

I am completely overwhelmed by the kindness of everyone here.  It has meant so much to me to be surrounded (even virtually) by people who know how I feel.  Because, you see, I am a neophyte at losing a dog.  And I had never in my life known a relationship with anyone — human, male, female, canine, whatever — like I had with Harley.  Most of my memories are happy ones.  I am just having a hard time dealing with other people right now because the next person who tells me she was "just a dog" is going to get her throat ripped open.  Yeah, just a dog I would rescue from a burning building one million times over before I would risk singing a hair of my head over you. Harley was my first dog.  I guess I just got real lucky that I started out with such a special one.  For those of you who haven’t known us or heard the story, I actually found Harley on rec.pets.dogs (back when it was all one newsgroup).  So, this little corner of Usenet is pretty special to me for a number of reasons.  When I started looking for a dog in late 1993, I was thinking 80-pound malamute.  Back then, I thought if it didn’t weigh over 50 pounds, it wasn’t a dog.  (Isn’t that funny?) I posted something to the effect of "I’m starting graduate school in the fall and want to adopt a puppy.  I like [every huge spitz breed] and Border Collies.  I am going to take the puppy to school with me and have it sleep under the desk while I am in class."  After being roundly lambasted for my stupidity and naivete, I realized that my plan was a little bit unrealistic.  What puppy was going to sleep through class?  I also realized that with apartment living a smaller dog was going to be a better idea (mostly due to landlord restrictions — heh).  Still committed to the spitz concept, I started looking at smaller ones.  Pomeranians were a bit smaller than I had bargained for, but I liked that they were all spitz, just scaled down.  And, I had to admit, they were pretty damn cute. Then, one day, I saw a post on the newsgroup: "Pomeranian needs home." "A friend of mine is caring for a one-year-old spayed Pom dog, she is a doll.  She loves to cuddle, and go for rides." And it was true. And everyone thought I would never be able to train a dog to go to class with me.  Well, actually, I guess I can’t really take the credit for that.  I just got lucky, again.  Harley came that way.  (She also came with the name "Muffie," but we did something about that right away.) Harley was carrying a special soul and even my mother, a card-carrying Buddhist, agrees.  (And Mom doesn’t even really like dogs.  She loved Harley though.  She used to say that Harley was "yangban," or high class, because everything she did was so tidy and perfect and she carried herself like a lady.  It was true.) She said that maybe Harley was a person in her last life, who just messed up a little bit and had to come back as a dog, but as a dog with a nice cushy life.  And the reason she had to go so soon is that she had more than made up for whatever she did before.  Even though I have never subscribed to any religion, of any flavor, I think that I will meet Harley again.  My mother said Harley might even come back as my daughter.  It might almost be worth having a kid for that.  Right? Now I am starting the lonely process of finding another dog.  (Harley, forgive me.) So far I have a couple of leads.  It isn’t easy because half of me just wants to find any dog to fill the ache, and the other half is sure that no dog could ever compare.  While I was in Virginia during the weekend, I went to the animal shelter to see if I could love another dog. I played with a border collie cross they had there and while she wasn’t the dog for me, I think that I can love another dog.  (Actually I am pretty certain she was a collie/BC mix.  This shelter is notorious for horrifying breed misidentifications: the tag on the kennel said "German Shepherd/Cocker Spaniel mix."  !!!  Anyone looking for a nice BC cross in Northern Virginia?  Call Fairfax County Animal Control and ask them about Emma.) What I need to do is to find a dog (bitch, actually — I don’t know why — I like girl dogs) who has some of the qualities I loved in Harley without being anything like her.  I know I could not have another Pom.  After all, I already had the best one ever made.  I am contacting rescues for Shibas, Basenjis, and Sibes right now and haunting the local animal shelters.* Whether it takes two weeks or two months (or longer, if I can survive that long), I am looking for the RIGHT dog, so I guess I will have to be patient.  But I hope it doesn’t take too long.  My leash hand is empty. Thanks, everyone. * By the way, if anyone wants an honest-to-God lurcher in the Philly area, they have a nice one at the Morris Animal Refuge.  Her name is Nadia and she is listed as a "terrier X" which I am sure she is, but I am certain the other half is whippet or greyhound.  She’s like a little golden wire-haired gazelle.  I can’t adopt from this shelter because they actually do call your landlord to see if you can have a dog.  But I figured someone who can might like Nadia. —   Melanie Lee Chang                        |  Repetition is the death   Departments of Anthropology and Biology  |  of art.   University of Pennsylvania               |  

Response:

     I want to thank everyone for the postings and info.  It has been helpful.  I see my doctor tues. and go from there. I am having to switch doctors due to new insurance and don’t know if everything will be covered.  I will have to somehow open up to him and tell him all that has been going on.  I don’t know if I can, but I am going to have to try.  It is very hard for me to really open up to people.  I have been having panic/anxiety attacks, but they have worsened the last couple of days and can’t hardly sleep due to the fact that my grandmother just passed away Friday and the funeral is Monday.  I was the last person she responded to before she went into a coma.  I have been taking it pretty hard.  I

I am so sorry about the loss of your grandmother.  I remember that pain well. regards, julie

Response:

Hi Tammy, I am sorry for the loss of your grandmother. I grieved many years for mine as she was the one who actually raised me. I hope your appt. with your new pdoc goes well. It is hard to be trusting with another but IMO, it is essentail if you are to receive the best treatment possible. Peace, Lynda

Response:

I would fight the whole insurance thing.  Sometimes they will over right it because of special conditions.  I’m having to fight my insurance company for the same thing and basically told them that I would rather jump off a tall building than change doctors.  They don’t understand my illness and what it takes to keep me stable.  If they keep giving me shit I will go to the news and see that it is printed and aired.  Then lets see if they don’t let me switch doctors. sincerely lisa ann

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –      I want to thank everyone for the postings and info.  It has been helpful.  I see my doctor tues. and go from there. I am having to switch doctors due to new insurance and don’t know if everything will be covered.  I will have to somehow open up to him and tell him all that has been going on.  I don’t know if I can, but I am going to have to try.  It is very hard for me to really open up to people.  I have been having panic/anxiety attacks, but they have worsened the last couple of days and can’t hardly sleep due to the fact that my grandmother just passed away Friday and the funeral is Monday.  I was the last person she responded to before she went into a coma.  I have been taking it pretty hard.  I am scared to sleep, so when I do, it’s not very well.  The last several months I have been moody, but now it is worse. I don’t want to talk to people in person that much, but that is hard because of the job I have.

Response:

     I want to thank everyone for the postings and info.  It has been helpful.  I see my doctor tues. and go from there. I am having to switch doctors due to new insurance and don’t know if everything will be covered.  I will have to somehow open up to him and tell him all that has been going on.  I don’t know if I can, but I am going to have to try.  It is very hard for me to really open up to people.  I have been having panic/anxiety attacks, but they have worsened the last couple of days and can’t hardly sleep due to the fact that my grandmother just passed away Friday and the funeral is Monday.  I was the last person she responded to before she went into a coma.  I have been taking it pretty hard.  I am scared to sleep, so when I do, it’s not very well.  The last several months I have been moody, but now it is worse. I don’t want to talk to people in person that much, but that is hard because of the job I have.

Response:

I am 48. I’ve been DXed and treated since I was 21. Been Bi-Polar since I was 8, I think, looking back at my life. On March 26, 1996 I had a manic incident followed by a long period of depression. August 6, 1996 my Ex Wife threw me out with the trash. On Dec. 23, 1998 my Divorce was final. But I digress from my point. I managed to cope with this damned illness from 1972 until March 26, 1966. But on that date, a chain reaction started that knocked over my house of cards. I have been a mess ever since. No rest for the wicked I guess.         There is however, some hope, on June 17, 1999; I found a Kitty on the Beach.           Ralph – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – x-no-archive: yes Hi all, I am Jeri and a manic depressive.  Being over 40 years old now, and in treatment the last ummmmm about 24 years  I hope somehow I am able to reach out to others that understand, my cycling is getting more and mroeo rapid. My fiance came home three weeks ago to discover I had take "one too many things to help me sleep…….I slept for a week  LOL  He is feeling guilty, and confused now.  Tonight I went for an assessment (yeah right) at the local "hotel"  They said I should wait till I am in true crisis before coming in. Any of you been there?  Like I said, I have over and over…hope to meet friends here, and to share med advise (although each is different for the individual), and hopefull pull us one by one up…or start to notice when we forget to sleep for a few days LOL Now, yes I am being long winded, that will stop soon I promise. But first, I printed out that beautiful piece of poetry, as well as sent it to my family.  I hope there is not objections to my doing so.  But I know I can go to the basement and smile, I can go the (being discrete here) restroom and it is on the mirror for me to start each day with. Thank you so much for sharring it!!!! AKA  uniqflwr It isn’t unusual for Bipolar Disorder to worsen when one is around 40, give or take a few years. I’m 47 and my illness has become much worse in the past several years. Fortunately, there are currently more treatment options than ever before. Struck-in-the-head

Response:

Love it with all your heart, Ralph.  :) Linda Brite – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am 48. I’ve been DXed and treated since I was 21. Been Bi-Polar since I was 8, I think, looking back at my life. On March 26, 1996 I had a manic incident followed by a long period of depression. August 6, 1996 my Ex Wife threw me out with the trash. On Dec. 23, 1998 my Divorce was final. But I digress from my point. I managed to cope with this damned illness from 1972 until March 26, 1966. But on that date, a chain reaction started that knocked over my house of cards. I have been a mess ever since. No rest for the wicked I guess.         There is however, some hope, on June 17, 1999; I found a Kitty on the Beach.           Ralph x-no-archive: yes Hi all, I am Jeri and a manic depressive.  Being over 40 years old now, and in treatment the last ummmmm about 24 years  I hope somehow I am able to reach out to others that understand, my cycling is getting more and mroeo rapid. My fiance came home three weeks ago to discover I had take "one too many things to help me sleep…….I slept for a week  LOL  He is feeling guilty, and confused now.  Tonight I went for an assessment (yeah right) at the local "hotel"  They said I should wait till I am in true crisis before coming in. Any of you been there?  Like I said, I have over and over…hope to meet friends here, and to share med advise (although each is different for the individual), and hopefull pull us one by one up…or start to notice when we forget to sleep for a few days LOL Now, yes I am being long winded, that will stop soon I promise. But first, I printed out that beautiful piece of poetry, as well as sent it to my family.  I hope there is not objections to my doing so.  But I know I can go to the basement and smile, I can go the (being discrete here) restroom and it is on the mirror for me to start each day with. Thank you so much for sharring it!!!! AKA  uniqflwr It isn’t unusual for Bipolar Disorder to worsen when one is around 40, give or take a few years. I’m 47 and my illness has become much worse in the past several years. Fortunately, there are currently more treatment options than ever before. Struck-in-the-head

Response:

Welcome Jeri.  :)  We are happy to have you here.  Another shoulder for you… and us.  People to share your good times and your bad times. People who understand… REALLY understand.  I’m glad you found us. Please feel free to be long winded. If that’s what you need to share, that’s fine.   Can’t say as I ever went in for the "assessment" and was told to come back.  I was invited for an extended stay.  Life’s a bitch. I think its wonderful you found a poem that does that for you… which one were you referring to?  We have many poets here.  And they are all good. Stick around… it gets better. Hugs, Linda Briteyes

Response:

I’ll add my welcome to those you’ve already received.  I too am in my forties, and my disease has grown markedly worse in the last two years or so. You’ve found a good group here, for moral support, for information on this disease and medication.  Please feel free to write whatever you need to write. You may not always get the same people to respond, but you will get someone’s response.  People tend to come and go here, some lurk and some participate. We also have a Bipolar Cafe chatroom you might wish to get involved with.  If so, send me an email and I will send you a link to a website which explains how to access the Cafe.  You will meet alot of newsgroup regulars there. Once again, welcome aboard! LilySue

Response:

Which piece of poetry did you print out? — *moto* – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi all, I am Jeri and a manic depressive.  Being over 40 years old now, and in treatment the last ummmmm about 24 years  I hope somehow I am able to reach out to others that understand, my cycling is getting more and mroeo rapid. My fiance came home three weeks ago to discover I had take "one too many things to help me sleep…….I slept for a week  LOL  He is feeling guilty, and confused now.  Tonight I went for an assessment (yeah right) at the local "hotel"  They said I should wait till I am in true crisis before coming in. Any of you been there?  Like I said, I have over and over…hope to meet friends here, and to share med advise (although each is different for the individual), and hopefull pull us one by one up…or start to notice when we forget to sleep for a few days LOL Now, yes I am being long winded, that will stop soon I promise. But first, I printed out that beautiful piece of poetry, as well as sent it to my family.  I hope there is not objections to my doing so.  But I know I can go to the basement and smile, I can go the (being discrete here) restroom and it is on the mirror for me to start each day with. Thank you so much for sharring it!!!! AKA  uniqflwr

Response:

Hello passionflower.  Welcome. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi all, I am Jeri and a manic depressive.  Being over 40 years old now, and in treatment the last ummmmm about 24 years  I hope somehow I am able to reach out to others that understand, my cycling is getting more and mroeo rapid. My fiance came home three weeks ago to discover I had take "one too many things to help me sleep…….I slept for a week  LOL  He is feeling guilty, and confused now.  Tonight I went for an assessment (yeah right) at the local "hotel"  They said I should wait till I am in true crisis before coming in. Any of you been there?  Like I said, I have over and over…hope to meet friends here, and to share med advise (although each is different for the individual), and hopefull pull us one by one up…or start to notice when we forget to sleep for a few days LOL Now, yes I am being long winded, that will stop soon I promise. But first, I printed out that beautiful piece of poetry, as well as sent it to my family.  I hope there is not objections to my doing so.  But I know I can go to the basement and smile, I can go the (being discrete here) restroom and it is on the mirror for me to start each day with. Thank you so much for sharring it!!!! AKA  uniqflwr

Response:

Hi all, I am Jeri and a manic depressive.  Being over 40 years old now, and in treatment the last ummmmm about 24 years  I hope somehow I am able to reach out to others that understand, my cycling is getting more and mroeo rapid. My fiance came home three weeks ago to discover I had take "one too many things to help me sleep…….I slept for a week  LOL  He is feeling guilty, and confused now.  Tonight I went for an assessment (yeah right) at the local "hotel"  They said I should wait till I am in true crisis before coming in. Any of you been there?  Like I said, I have over and over…hope to meet friends here, and to share med advise (although each is different for the individual), and hopefull pull us one by one up…or start to notice when we forget to sleep for a few days LOL Now, yes I am being long winded, that will stop soon I promise. But first, I printed out that beautiful piece of poetry, as well as sent it to my family.  I hope there is not objections to my doing so.  But I know I can go to the basement and smile, I can go the (being discrete here) restroom and it is on the mirror for me to start each day with. Thank you so much for sharring it!!!! AKA  uniqflwr

Response:

Hi Peter, I just wante to say thank you, to everyone who responded.  Lynda, thank you for the links.  It helped, when I really needed it, it helped.  

I am glad that they were helpful to you. I just wish prayer and love was enough, always used to think that it

was  in this world. Never give up Peter…but please take care of yourself. Peace, Lynda

Response:

I just wante to say thank you, to everyone who responded.  Lynda, thank you for the links.  It helped, when I really needed it, it helped.  I just wish prayer and love was enough, always used to think that it was in this world. -Peter

Response:

Last night I was feeling really bad, ready to end it all.  I want to thank everyone who responded to my post.  I am feeling a little better today.  My daughter and I are getting along…sort of.  She is mad about some bangs that she got several months ago…blaming me for liking them, etc.  I think that she looks cute, but she gets mad if I tell her that.  I think that I may get her into counseling for her anger.  I’m not sure yet.  I’ll talk to my husband about that.   Talked to my pdoc last night, and saw my therapist today.  She reminded me that suicide would be the ultimate abandonment of my children…I know this, but at times like these, I just need to be reminded.  I will continue to fight against this depression, and hopefully set a good example for my children.  I love them very much and don’t want to hurt them.  They are very supportive of me when I am feeling down, even at their young ages.  I just hope that they are learning to fight against all odds, the way I feel I have to fight now. Again, thanks for the warm wishes, suggestions, and prayers.  They are much needed. Marette

Response:

I want to thank Kimberly, Daric, Roy, Morgan, Jenny and everyone else that offered their support and advice when I needed it the most.  I’m sorry that it took me so long to thank you, but I went into hospital…manic, yet suicidal. I guess that’s a mixed state.   For now, the cycling has stopped, my Zyprexa and Klonopin have kicked in, and I’m off to bed for (hopefully) a good night’s sleep. Again, thank you very much!!!!   {{{{{{ASDM}}}}}} Marette

Response:

I will start therapy tomorrow and then return to the doc on Dec. 2nd to see about the drugs. Last night was a very bad night…..all those nice little pills in my desk looked good. It doesn’t take mush sometimes to trigger the thoughts…..but it takes lots to make them go away. I ask myself may a time if I could really do it and I can never answer….I would never admit this to anyone outside of one of these boards because I don’t want to be thought of as crazy. I am afraid to tell the doc that the meds aren’t working. I feel guilt in doing it…..like he will think I am crazy that they should work or maybe I am just letting him down. I just want to sleep so much it is driving me crazy…..when will sleep come? Thank you Robert and Linda it is so nice to not feel alone for once in my life.

Response:

I was afraid to tell my doctors that my meds weren’t working. Three reasons… 1)  I wanted to feel better 2) I knew the drugs were supposed to work 3) I didn’t want to make the doctors feel bad about not helping me I realize that last one sounds stupid but hey it’s the truth.  I’ve evolved (somewhat) and even told my (former) psychiatrist that I didn’t feel any better at each appointment, and he kept saying "effexor is a very good drug, so is lithium so we’ll just keep you on it a little while longer."   Unfortunately he said the same thing at each visit and by the time had come for  me to write my spring finals, I was screwed. I hadn’t been able to study all term because, well, I don’t have to explain it to you guys.  I got a good psychiatrist in my home town over the summer, she immediately discontinued those drugs and switched me over to some other drugs.  Acknowledging that there is a pathway of figuring out which drugs and dosages work for each person and telling me not to give up hope because we would stumble across the right combination for ME.  And now I take 2000mg of Epival (sodium valproate) per day along with lamictal 100 mg per day and I’m doing much better.  I still missed my midterms this year but wrote them right after that when I started feeling better (Lamictal kicked in just in the nick of time.) All that aside, just remember to put yourself first, and others be damned!  At least when it comes to your health.  The doctors are there to help and serve you , not the other way around.  And they can’t do that if they don’t know that you’re not progressing.  So do what you deserve and tell your doctor how you feel. Peace Roz

Response:

— -judy ***To the world you might be one person, but to one person you might be the world.*** – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – It’s gotten nice in here, /me yawns and stretches and says I’m bored. Dare I wish for it, lol j/k people. I know it’s still a shock to your system Robert. Now, you know I think you are a real good guy, and everything, so in an attempt to make you feel better, here’s a little something to make the troll withdrawal less drastic…   What a Dreg you are. I am the foremost authority on bipolar disorder, and my doctor’s are world renowned specialists. They get all their information from me. When I’m not teaching at the university, I am fighting in the streets, still undefeated. My mob connections are ready to do my bidding. My 14" **** is being drained to begin a super race. My test scores are in the upper 99.99999999999999th percentile. Women cannot resist me. The FBI has tried to stop me, but have given up due to my genius ability to fool them. Blah, blah, blah, Tracy, blah, blah, Linda, blah blah, Judy, blah blah, La la, blah blah Hopper. There. I hope this makes you feel better. But one thing we will never know…."did Billy ever get his green socks back?"

Response:

(Actually I will not have to. MOTF will run to look it up so that he can look cool for the chicks)

Could you blame me? I’m single, tall,  healthy, of means, and doggone it, it gets lonely in the forest. Anyway, coolness is an art form.

Response:

Me too!!!  And I really needed it too.  Looking forward to more as I wade my way through over 500 posts.  Geez, go away for a few days… – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –   You guys are cracking me up!!!   Thanks…I really need a good hearty laugh! Love, Lynda ROFLO Good post Mark I feel so much better! Next time I’ll tell you how I accidentally invented Lamictal while making a new fat-free banana bread mixture. It would never have happened, had the Pope not called me for spiritual advice right as I was mixing the batter too close to my hardware shelf of miscellaneous chemicals. Mark "The new leader of ASDM, for the next 5 minutes" AMEN!!! You are so kewl Mark!!! Actually I think all our ASDM ans SSDM BP brothers are pretty special guys… (trolls excluded). You all have a great sense of humor and are able to laugh with us and you really do care…see, it shows  :)

– Peace, Gina "Feats don’t fail me now"                 -Barrere, George, Martin

Response:

<The story I heard second hand was that there was a infantry division <in the civil war that had stripes that looked like the indentations on <a bastard file, the division was made up from bastards hence the name. <Could be urban legend though so your mileage may vary. It is. I learned the origin of the name some time ago and can’t remember exactly what that was. I’ll see if I can find it again. (Actually I will not have to. MOTF will run to look it up so that he can look cool for the chicks). It has to do with the type of teeth the file has.

Response:

Ever think of that one? I mean, why else would a hardware item be given a profanity title? Someday you should stop by Ace hardware and ask them if they carry bastard files? They will say yes. Then, ask them where they keep the motherfucking hammers and the goddamn screwdrivers.  LOLOL!

The story I heard second hand was that there was a infantry division in the civil war that had stripes that looked like the indentations on a bastard file, the division was made up from bastards hence the name. Could be urban legend though so your mileage may vary. For email replies remove the **** from my email address.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Mark "The new leader of ASDM, for the next 5 minutes" I accidentally invented Lamictal while making a new fat-free banana bread mixture. Oranjkaat BOWS  I am not worthy!!! LOL  but only bows for five minutes. You know that would be really good if we could invent a milkshake drink like a health food shake or bar with our meds we could take on the run with us. The ingredients would list all our daily nutrients, vitamin A, B, C, D, E, Iron Protein etc., and depakote(fill-in-med-of choice)—fat free of course. Okaat

(In my best John Wayne voice) Weeell little missy, all ya need to do is get yourself a blender and a couple-uh eggs. Then just toss all that stuff in with some of old bessies 2% milk, and let er rip. After that, you’re ready to saddle up and hit the trail. ;^) El Marko

Response:

Warning! This post contains obscene language and is not suitable for children or sensitive adults. In response: Hmm, as far as the m-w link, I have it right here available with one click already. I set it up cause i’m a dictionary junkie. And, I have to first,  think how it must be spelled, and that  really sharpens my spelling abilliatty.<g And speaking of bastards, the dictionary says: Main Entry: 2bastard Function: adjective 1 : ILLEGITIMATE 2 : of mixed or ill-conceived origin <known for coining bastard words 3 : of abnormal shape or irregular size 4 : of a kind similar to but inferior to or less typical than some standard <bastard measles 5 : lacking genuineness or authority : FALSE But to me, I was thinking in the hardware store the other day while looking at a bastard file. It is flat on one side, and rough on the other. So I thought, hmm, the reason it is called a bastard file is because it is lacking definition on one side, same as the offspring of an unwed couple. Ever think of that one? I mean, why else would a hardware item be given a profanity title? Someday you should stop by Ace hardware and ask them if they carry bastard files? They will say yes. Then, ask them where they keep the motherfucking hammers and the goddamn screwdrivers.  LOLOL!

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – (special credit to Webster’s dictionary) ‘Tis a wonderful reference.. It’s fun to bastardize the definitions, isn’t it? BTW – Have you used QuickClick (http://www.nbci.com/quickclick).  With it installed, if you hold the alt key, then click with both mouse buttons at the same time on any word, you can bring up a quick link to the dictionary definition of any word on your screen (links to m-w.com site).  It’s a nifty little tool. -Rob

Response:

To be honest, I used my intellect, charm, wit, and most importantly – my good looks. -Rob

I have just read your response. I hope this anti-nausea med will be compatible with my neurontin, and these rubber hip waders won’t cause chafing. Main Entry: 1chafe Pronunciation: ‘chAf Function: verb Inflected Form(s): chafed; chaf

Asthma in adult life

Question:

Yes this is correct you never outgrow asthma. I have had it all my life. I am 46 and still fighting it daily. I had a period of time in my teen years where it was so much better that the drs had me deluded into thinking I was outgrowing it. Ha It came back with a bang in my 20’s. Sorry for the depressing news but your son will more than likely always be plagued with this curse.            Peggy

Response:

If he made it up, then so did my pulmonologist.  He is professor at a Chicago-area teaching hospital where much primary research is performed.  He explained that although children seem to ‘outgrow’ asthma, there can be recurrences later in life to varying degrees, sometimes more subtly than the original bouts, but there nonetheless (often attributed to bronchitis). Interestingly, he said that adult-onset asthma may have actually been present in the patient all along (at least histologically) but brought to the fore by environmental factors or infections. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Your doctor is wrong.  You never grow out of asthma.  What happens is that you stop having symptoms for several years.  You can expect it to return during or after his late 20’s. The idea that you can grow out of asthma is a myth. Did you just make this up yourself? Some people can and do outgrow asthma. Before you buy.

Response:

Hi Lisa, I’m going to NJH in Feb.2000, just found out the insurance approval and dates last night.  If you don’t mind a couple questions; any comments, suggestions, advice?  Did it help?  Was it worth the trip?  Thanks in advance. Lisa – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I went to the National Jewish Hospital in Denver for an Asthma evaluation in April 1992 and while there found a stat that said 90% of folks with childhood asthma grow out of it. I’m one of the "lucky" 10% who didn’t (I’m 30 and my asthma seems to only get worse). I couldn’t quote you the study, but if you contact the Hospital and ask around, you might get a better idea of recent studies that might be able to clarify the 90/10 deal. Good luck! :) Lisa — Starlight Bridals                  TOLL FREE!  888-VEILS-33 Affordable headpieces, veils, and more! Since 1995… http://starlightbridals.com I am looking for some help with the following: My son suffered from asthma as a young boy, from the age of 6 upwards and took ventolin for it. on one occasion requiring steroids to get over a bad spell. He is now 14 years old and seems to have grown out of it. (Doctors  said that this would be the case.) What I would like to know is has anyone completed any research that would confirm that he will not get a reoccurrence of asthma later on in his adult life.

Response:

I find it most interesting the mention about adult onset asthma as being present all along.  After reading the posts on this ng for the past several months, I often wonder if the recurrent bronchitis I had as a young child and early teen was actually asthma.  Also used to get SOB which was referred to as "anxiety". Hindsight is 20-20. Patrice – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – If he made it up, then so did my pulmonologist.  He is professor at a Chicago-area teaching hospital where much primary research is performed. He explained that although children seem to ‘outgrow’ asthma, there can be recurrences later in life to varying degrees, sometimes more subtly than the original bouts, but there nonetheless (often attributed to bronchitis). Interestingly, he said that adult-onset asthma may have actually been present in the patient all along (at least histologically) but brought to the fore by environmental factors or infections. Your doctor is wrong.  You never grow out of asthma.  What happens is that you stop having symptoms for several years.  You can expect it to return during or after his late 20’s. The idea that you can grow out of asthma is a myth. Did you just make this up yourself? Some people can and do outgrow asthma. Before you buy.

Response:

I find it most interesting the mention about adult onset asthma as being present all along.  After reading the posts on this ng for the past several months, I often wonder if the recurrent bronchitis I had as a young child and early teen was actually asthma.  Also used to get SOB which was referred to as "anxiety".

My medical history is pretty convincing that I had undiagnosed asthma as a child. In fact there is debate in the scientific community that the apparent increase in asthma is more the result of effective detection than any actual increase in incidence. No electrons were harmed in the posting of this message.

Response:

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – My son suffered from asthma as a young boy, from the age of 6 upwards and took ventolin for it. on one occasion requiring steroids to get over a bad spell. He is now 14 years old and seems to have grown out of it. (Doctors  said that this would be the case.) What I would like to know is has anyone completed any research that would confirm that he will not get a reoccurrence of asthma later on in his adult life. Actually, unfortunately there is now some evidence to suggest that at least some asthmatics that go into ‘remission’ as a child/teen may actually go out of remission and start having asthma symptoms again once they get into mid-adulthood [e.g. 40's and 50's]. SW.

I had asthma as a child and became asthma-free from about 15-30. After 30, it returned and I have not been able to get rid of it. I keep it under control with various inhalers, but I think that there is some evidence to show that my experience is not unusual.

Response:

You just described me.  However, it came back when I was in my 30s.  It still remains and I’m 53. JEB – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am looking for some help with the following: My son suffered from asthma as a young boy, from the age of 6 upwards and took ventolin for it. on one occasion requiring steroids to get over a bad spell. He is now 14 years old and seems to have grown out of it. (Doctors  said that this would be the case.) What I would like to know is has anyone completed any research that would confirm that he will not get a reoccurrence of asthma later on in his adult life.

Response:

Your doctor is wrong.  You never grow out of asthma.  What happens is that you stop having symptoms for several years.  You can expect it to return during or after his late 20’s. The idea that you can grow out of asthma is a myth. Did you just make this up yourself? Some people can and do outgrow asthma.

I don’t believe that this is a myth.  My Grandfather had severe asthma as a child and into his 20’s and he out grew it.  He is 79 now and has never had an asthma attack or any symptoms since his 20’s.  People can out grow asthma, there is such thing as "childhood asthma." Meghan Before you buy.

Response:

I am looking for some help with the following: My son suffered from asthma as a young boy, from the age of 6 upwards and took ventolin for it. on one occasion requiring steroids to get over a bad spell. He is now 14 years old and seems to have grown out of it. (Doctors  said that this would be the case.) What I would like to know is has anyone completed any research that would confirm that he will not get a reoccurrence of asthma later on in his adult life.

Your doctor is wrong.  You never grow out of asthma.  What happens is that you stop having symptoms for several years.  You can expect it to return during or after his late 20’s. The idea that you can grow out of asthma is a myth. No electrons were harmed in the posting of this message.

Response:

Your doctor is wrong.  You never grow out of asthma.  What happens is that you stop having symptoms for several years.  You can expect it to return during or after his late 20’s. The idea that you can grow out of asthma is a myth. is this purely anecdotal? i really would like to see some papers on this – if you can advise.

Send a reminder to me next week. No electrons were harmed in the posting of this message.

Response:

I went to the National Jewish Hospital in Denver for an Asthma evaluation in April 1992 and while there found a stat that said 90% of folks with childhood asthma grow out of it. I’m one of the "lucky" 10% who didn’t (I’m 30 and my asthma seems to only get worse). I couldn’t quote you the study, but if you contact the Hospital and ask around, you might get a better idea of recent studies that might be able to clarify the 90/10 deal. Good luck! :) Lisa — Starlight Bridals                  TOLL FREE!  888-VEILS-33 Affordable headpieces, veils, and more! Since 1995… http://starlightbridals.com – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I am looking for some help with the following: My son suffered from asthma as a young boy, from the age of 6 upwards and took ventolin for it. on one occasion requiring steroids to get over a bad spell. He is now 14 years old and seems to have grown out of it. (Doctors  said that this would be the case.) What I would like to know is has anyone completed any research that would confirm that he will not get a reoccurrence of asthma later on in his adult life.

Response:

Your doctor is wrong.  You never grow out of asthma.  What happens is that you stop having symptoms for several years.  You can expect it to return during or after his late 20’s. The idea that you can grow out of asthma is a myth.

is this purely anecdotal? i really would like to see some papers on this – if you can advise. Rich.

Response:

Your doctor is wrong.  You never grow out of asthma.  What happens is that you stop having symptoms for several years.  You can expect it to return during or after his late 20’s. The idea that you can grow out of asthma is a myth.

Did you just make this up yourself? Some people can and do outgrow asthma. Before you buy.

Response:

I am looking for some help with the following: My son suffered from asthma as a young boy, from the age of 6 upwards and took ventolin for it. on one occasion requiring steroids to get over a bad spell. He is now 14 years old and seems to have grown out of it. (Doctors  said that this would be the case.) What I would like to know is has anyone completed any research that would confirm that he will not get a reoccurrence of asthma later on in his adult life.

I have heard – and keep in mind this is ancedotal – many cases like this – not really sure what to make of it except be glad you have some period of freedom from asthma symptoms.  Both me and my brother are exceptions I guess – both got diagnosed with asthma at a very young age – approx 3 or so and neither one of us has outgrown it.  I am 29 he is 31.  Though I think my brothers asthma has gotten better over the years – and I would say that mine probably stayed the same or gotten worse.

Response:

I am looking for some help with the following: My son suffered from asthma as a young boy, from the age of 6 upwards and took ventolin for it. on one occasion requiring steroids to get over a bad spell. He is now 14 years old and seems to have grown out of it. (Doctors  said that this would be the case.) What I would like to know is has anyone completed any research that would confirm that he will not get a reoccurrence of asthma later on in his adult life.

Response:

My son suffered from asthma as a young boy, from the age of 6 upwards and took ventolin for it. on one occasion requiring steroids to get over a bad spell. He is now 14 years old and seems to have grown out of it. (Doctors  said that this would be the case.) What I would like to know is has anyone completed any research that would confirm that he will not get a reoccurrence of asthma later on in his adult life.

Actually, unfortunately there is now some evidence to suggest that at least some asthmatics that go into ‘remission’ as a child/teen may actually go out of remission and start having asthma symptoms again once they get into mid-adulthood [e.g. 40's and 50's]. SW.

Response:

My son suffered from asthma as a young boy, What I would like to know is has anyone completed any research that would confirm that he will not get a reoccurrence of asthma later on in his adult life.

All I can tell you is that I had asthma at a very young age which was severe enough to require hospitalizations, however I was so Young I don’t remember it.  I remember having bouts of bronchitis as I got older. Then They said I "outgrew" it. As I got older-30ish :) , I begain having the bronchitis again. When I was 35 it was full blown asthma. Over the last 6 years it has been off and on, but this last year I have had to go on full time meds which include inhaled steroids -Flovent, singulair and serevent, with Maxair as a rescue,  However , all is not lost……I hear that there are some people who never have a recurrence after puberty.

Response:

problems with voice

Question:

Thanks Pam. I will look into this. Interestingly I do get heartburn often but have never connected the two together.

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Your symptoms sound alot like GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease).  Go to http://www.heartburn-help.com/.  You can have heartburn without the burning and have problems with hoarseness and a lump in the throat feeling.  A gastroenterologist can treat you. Pam Does any one have any suggestions or even experience of my problem. I am 41 and have had asthma all my life, very bad when i was youger but now normaly  under good control. I use flixotide twice a day and ventolin as required which is not usualy very often these days. I’ve been on flixotide for the past maybe three years, before which I was on intal. I’ve been using ventolin since I was about 15. The problem is with my throat (or maybe voice box). What happens is I get periods when my voice becomes very hoarse or weak. If i try to speak sometimes virtualy nothing comes out, then if i clear it which is not always possible, it’s ok for a minute or so then it starts again. It feels like there is this huge blob of thick mucus or something stuck down there. This has been happening for the past 12 years on and of. I’ve asked my doctor on several occasions but to be honest he seems to be stuck, as was the ENT specialist he refered me to. Ive also tried eliminating various products from my diet, like cheese and milk to see if it’s possibly an allergic reaction. It may be something totally unrelated to asthma, but i’ve just got this feeling that there is a connection between either it and asthma or the medication for asthma. I would be gratefull for any suggestions or any similar experiences from any one in the group. Thanks in anticipation. Gary

Response:

I have the same problem with my attacks, I always lose my voice.  I went to a specialist and he told me it was because of the lack of oxygen getting through the voice box. Linda – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Thanks Pam. I will look into this. Interestingly I do get heartburn often but have never connected the two together. Your symptoms sound alot like GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease).  Go to http://www.heartburn-help.com/.  You can have heartburn without the burning and have problems with hoarseness and a lump in the throat feeling.  A gastroenterologist can treat you. Pam Does any one have any suggestions or even experience of my problem. I am 41 and have had asthma all my life, very bad when i was youger but now normaly  under good control. I use flixotide twice a day and ventolin as required which is not usualy very often these days. I’ve been on flixotide for the past maybe three years, before which I was on intal. I’ve been using ventolin since I was about 15. The problem is with my throat (or maybe voice box). What happens is I get periods when my voice becomes very hoarse or weak. If i try to speak sometimes virtualy nothing comes out, then if i clear it which is not always possible, it’s ok for a minute or so then it starts again. It feels like there is this huge blob of thick mucus or something stuck down there. This has been happening for the past 12 years on and of. I’ve asked my doctor on several occasions but to be honest he seems to be stuck, as was the ENT specialist he refered me to. Ive also tried eliminating various products from my diet, like cheese and milk to see if it’s possibly an allergic reaction. It may be something totally unrelated to asthma, but i’ve just got this feeling that there is a connection between either it and asthma or the medication for asthma. I would be gratefull for any suggestions or any similar experiences from any one in the group. Thanks in anticipation. Gary

Response:

Thanks Pam. I will look into this. Interestingly I do get heartburn often but have never connected the two together.

More links on GERD & asthma: http://www.ama-assn.org/special/asthma/library/readroom/40894.htm Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease and Asthma Diagnosis and Management http://www.ama-assn.org/special/asthma/treatmnt/updates/gerd.htm Asthma and Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease-GERD  Nov ‘97 JAMA http://www.vh.org/Providers/ClinRef/FPHandbook/Chapter04/09-4.html Gastroenterology: Esophageal Diseases Ellis – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Your symptoms sound alot like GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease). Go to http://www.heartburn-help.com/.  You can have heartburn without the burning and have problems with hoarseness and a lump in the throat feeling. A gastroenterologist can treat you. Pam Does any one have any suggestions or even experience of my problem. I am 41 and have had asthma all my life, very bad when i was youger but now normaly  under good control. I use flixotide twice a day and ventolin as required which is not usualy very often these days. I’ve been on flixotide for the past maybe three years, before which I was on intal. I’ve been using ventolin since I was about 15. The problem is with my throat (or maybe voice box). What happens is I get periods when my voice becomes very hoarse or weak. If i try to speak sometimes virtualy nothing comes out, then if i clear it which is not always possible, it’s ok for a minute or so then it starts again. It feels like there is this huge blob of thick mucus or something stuck down there. This has been happening for the past 12 years on and of. I’ve asked my doctor on several occasions but to be honest he seems to be stuck, as was the ENT specialist he refered me to. Ive also tried eliminating various products from my diet, like cheese and milk to see if it’s possibly an allergic reaction. It may be something totally unrelated to asthma, but i’ve just got this feeling that there is a connection between either it and asthma or the medication for asthma. I would be gratefull for any suggestions or any similar experiences from any one in the group. Thanks in anticipation.  Gary

Response:

Your symptoms sound alot like GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease).  Go to http://www.heartburn-help.com/.  You can have heartburn without the burning and have problems with hoarseness and a lump in the throat feeling.  A gastroenterologist can treat you. Pam

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Does any one have any suggestions or even experience of my problem. I am 41 and have had asthma all my life, very bad when i was youger but now normaly  under good control. I use flixotide twice a day and ventolin as required which is not usualy very often these days. I’ve been on flixotide for the past maybe three years, before which I was on intal. I’ve been using ventolin since I was about 15. The problem is with my throat (or maybe voice box). What happens is I get periods when my voice becomes very hoarse or weak. If i try to speak sometimes virtualy nothing comes out, then if i clear it which is not always possible, it’s ok for a minute or so then it starts again. It feels like there is this huge blob of thick mucus or something stuck down there. This has been happening for the past 12 years on and of. I’ve asked my doctor on several occasions but to be honest he seems to be stuck, as was the ENT specialist he refered me to. Ive also tried eliminating various products from my diet, like cheese and milk to see if it’s possibly an allergic reaction. It may be something totally unrelated to asthma, but i’ve just got this feeling that there is a connection between either it and asthma or the medication for asthma. I would be gratefull for any suggestions or any similar experiences from any one in the group. Thanks in anticipation. Gary

Response:

Gary: Your symptoms sound very much like mine.  I am 44 years old and have been fighting this problem for over six years now.  It seems like I am trying to talk through a huge gob of gunk and my voice does get weak sometimes.  I have been on allergy injections for over a year and they don’t seem to help.  I have also had CT scans, and taken just about every Rx you could imagine and nothing seems to help.  I am beginning to lose some of the range in my voice from the constant throat clearing. Question for you:  Does your problem seem to get worse after eating or drinking?  My problem is much worse after eating.  I posted to this group a few days ago (see "thick secretions") and some of the people suggest GERD which is something that I have not pursued to any great extent. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Does any one have any suggestions or even experience of my problem. I am 41 and have had asthma all my life, very bad when i was youger but now normaly  under good control. I use flixotide twice a day and ventolin as required which is not usualy very often these days. I’ve been on flixotide for the past maybe three years, before which I was on intal. I’ve been using ventolin since I was about 15. The problem is with my throat (or maybe voice box). What happens is I get periods when my voice becomes very hoarse or weak. If i try to speak sometimes virtualy nothing comes out, then if i clear it which is not always possible, it’s ok for a minute or so then it starts again. It feels like there is this huge blob of thick mucus or something stuck down there. This has been happening for the past 12 years on and of. I’ve asked my doctor on several occasions but to be honest he seems to be stuck, as was the ENT specialist he refered me to. Ive also tried eliminating various products from my diet, like cheese and milk to see if it’s possibly an allergic reaction. It may be something totally unrelated to asthma, but i’ve just got this feeling that there is a connection between either it and asthma or the medication for asthma. I would be gratefull for any suggestions or any similar experiences from any one in the group. Thanks in anticipation. Gary

Before you buy.

Response:

I do not have GERD but when I am experiencing an asthma attack and chest pain, my voice automatically becomes weaker and i just figured it was all due to the inflammation of my lungs, throat and anything else that is related.  When I get sick, it seems I get sick all over and weak and very tired. Always, pam – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Does any one have any suggestions or even experience of my problem. I am 41 and have had asthma all my life, very bad when i was youger but now normaly  under good control. I use flixotide twice a day and ventolin as required which is not usualy very often these days. I’ve been on flixotide for the past maybe three years, before which I was on intal. I’ve been using ventolin since I was about 15. The problem is with my throat (or maybe voice box). What happens is I get periods when my voice becomes very hoarse or weak. If i try to speak sometimes virtualy nothing comes out, then if i clear it which is not always possible, it’s ok for a minute or so then it starts again. It feels like there is this huge blob of thick mucus or something stuck down there. This has been happening for the past 12 years on and of. I’ve asked my doctor on several occasions but to be honest he seems to be stuck, as was the ENT specialist he refered me to. Ive also tried eliminating various products from my diet, like cheese and milk to see if it’s possibly an allergic reaction. It may be something totally unrelated to asthma, but i’ve just got this feeling that there is a connection between either it and asthma or the medication for asthma. I would be gratefull for any suggestions or any similar experiences from any one in the group. Thanks in anticipation. Gary

Response:

Gary, When my asthma is acting up, I misuse my voice because my lungs and sore diaphram are virtually useless.  I become hoarse, like Mother Angelica does on EWTN, and eventually lose my voice entirely.  If I’m having sinus problems and/or post nasal drip (sorry so gross), then the voice goes even faster.  Be aware of how you project your voice.  If  you can use some lung/diaphram function, then your vocal chords will not suffer longterm effects and you will have more voice longer.  Jill

– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Does any one have any suggestions or even experience of my problem. I am 41 and have had asthma all my life, very bad when i was youger but now normaly  under good control. I use flixotide twice a day and ventolin as required which is not usualy very often these days. I’ve been on flixotide for the past maybe three years, before which I was on intal. I’ve been using ventolin since I was about 15. The problem is with my throat (or maybe voice box). What happens is I get periods when my voice becomes very hoarse or weak. If i try to speak sometimes virtualy nothing comes out, then if i clear it which is not always possible, it’s ok for a minute or so then it starts again. It feels like there is this huge blob of thick mucus or something stuck down there. This has been happening for the past 12 years on and of. I’ve asked my doctor on several occasions but to be honest he seems to be stuck, as was the ENT specialist he refered me to. Ive also tried eliminating various products from my diet, like cheese and milk to see if it’s possibly an allergic reaction. It may be something totally unrelated to asthma, but i’ve just got this feeling that there is a connection between either it and asthma or the medication for asthma. I would be gratefull for any suggestions or any similar experiences from any one in the group. Thanks in anticipation. Gary

Response:

Does any one have any suggestions or even experience of my problem. I am 41 and have had asthma all my life, very bad when i was youger but now normaly  under good control. I use flixotide twice a day and ventolin as required which is not usualy very often these days. I’ve been on flixotide for the past maybe three years, before which I was on intal. I’ve been using ventolin since I was about 15. The problem is with my throat (or maybe voice box). What happens is I get periods when my voice becomes very hoarse or weak. If i try to speak sometimes virtualy nothing comes out, then if i clear it which is not always possible, it’s ok for a minute or so then it starts again. It feels like there is this huge blob of thick mucus or something stuck down there. This has been happening for the past 12 years on and of. I’ve asked my doctor on several occasions but to be honest he seems to be stuck, as was the ENT specialist he refered me to. Ive also tried eliminating various products from my diet, like cheese and milk to see if it’s possibly an allergic reaction. It may be something totally unrelated to asthma, but i’ve just got this feeling that there is a connection between either it and asthma or the medication for asthma. I would be gratefull for any suggestions or any similar experiences from any one in the group. Thanks in anticipation. Gary

Response:

Dexadrine Dose

Question:

I’m taking 400 mg Wellbutrin SR daily.  It has helped, but not enough I’ve now been taking 10 mg Dexadrine SR for three weeks.  The only difference I noticei is that when it wears off, my impulse control declines.   Would other Dexadrine users please  share your doses and experience?   Thank you.

Response:

Hi Starburst:                   Like you , I take Wellbutrin, 300mg/day; and Dexedrine 10mg. spansule’s once, or twice per day. I only take the second dose of dex if I need to focus, or be around a lot of people in the evening. Usually when the dex wears off (6~8 hours for me) my behaviour reverts to the unfocused, distractible, impulsive me. I tend to "diesel", like a car with the motor shut off that kepps chuggin & misfiring for awhile.     The Wellbutrin affects me differently. Firstly, it ‘feels’ like I still smoke cigarettes, but I don’t have to inhale it, nor the 200, or so, other toxic chemicals in cigarettes. I am more flexible, calm, & relaxed than I have ever been….in 49 years. I can sit still for more than 5 seconds, and I can shift my attention away from subjects that bother me (I have an Anxiety Disorder as well as ADHD/ADD), and I WORRIED about almost everything!.     I’ve been on the Wellbutrin for a year, and the Dexedrine spansules for nearly 3 years.     If you want, or need, more info, please let me know. davadd — "I know you understand what YOU THINK I said: I’m not sure you realise, however, that what you heard is NOT WHAT I SAID!"

I’m taking 400 mg Wellbutrin SR daily.  It has helped, but not enough I’ve now been taking 10 mg Dexadrine SR for three weeks.  The only difference I noticei is that when it wears off, my impulse control declines. Would other Dexadrine users please  share your doses and experience? Thank you.

Response:

I take 15mg spansules of Dex twice daily and have some 5mg tablets in case I forge tto take the spansule, or just need it for a few hours. hope that helps Julie

Response:

Would other Dexadrine users please  share your doses and experience?

Glad you asked =) I just now came here to specifically share an experience I’ve been having with Dex all summer. Of course, I got distracted by the postings, but that’s not unusual for someone with adhd ;) I used to take 15mg t.i.d. That was a 10mg spansule and a 5mg tab three times daily. Worked wonderfully until asthma and allergies hit me really really hard last winter. I’m just now feeling like the ashtma is under some bit of control, but to acheive that, I have to inhale nebulized medicines a few times per day. At first, I could not tolerate dexedrine at all with these nebulized medicines, but lately I’ve been managing a 10mg spansule in the morning. Today I tried two, bad move. This is what happens: a 10mg spansule ends up feeling like I took 3 or 4 at once and it lasts an incredibly long time. I know that I swallow a good bit of this nebulized stuff and think it must interact with the dex and cause it to be more potent and last longer. Unfortunately it also brings out more of the CNS side effects — racing heart, shaking etc. It’s a side effect of the nubulized stuff anyway, but with too much Dex I get a severe headache and increased CNS side effects. Ok, had to share that, but I suppose you’re not asthmatic and nebulized medicines are not interferring. So, I’ll share some of my experience with Dex prior to the great asthma attack. . . Normally, a 10mg spansule alone would not work for me. It was so slow to start and just wasn’t quite enough. When I added a 5mg tablet to it, the difference was amazing. It kicked in right away (but, and please note this, not with the intensity that Ritalin or Adderall "kicks in") and lasted a good 41/2 or 5 hours. My doc was, of course, worried that I might be abusing it, so he agreed to let me try out this dosage t.i.d. and had me in his office once a week to check on me. Once I got a job and my own apartment, he was satisfied that the dosage was working fairly well for me since those were *major* accomplishments for me. Well, I still have a bottle of (both types of) Dex left from six months ago, so it’s pretty certain I didn’t get addicted to it as all the scare mongors will claim will happen to you. Just had to add that ;) When I was taking Dex regularly, I got to the point very quickly where I didn’t know whether it was working or not. But people who know me in real space have commented that there is a *huge* difference <g Now that I’ve been off Dex for a while, I really notice a sense of relief and relaxation and organizing of my thoughts and emotions when I take it. Of course, there is the nebulized stuff interferring and possibly making the effects of Dex seem different to me now than they were in the past. I don’t take any antidepressants. It could be possible that Wellbutrin is interferring somehow with the Dex you take. But I wouldn’t know much about that since I’m not a doctor. That said, if I were you, I would consider getting with your doc and making a dosage adjustment and see if it helps. Might be a good idea to first get other non-add people who know you to tell you if they see any change. And be observant of things around you, are more things getting done that didn’t used to? * Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet’s Discussion Network * The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet – Free!

Response:

behavioural changes in 5 yr old

Question:

I’m new to this group so please forgive me if this subject has been talked out. Has anybody noticed behavioural changes in their children which may be associated with asthma in general, prescribed treatments, reduced lung function or any other aspect of the disease? As our daughters asthma has increased in severity her behaviour has changed. She has trouble concentrating, her attention span is nil, and her normally cooperative nature has been extinguished.  She no longer gets along with her siblings and rarely seems happy.  A flare up of her asthma seems to exacerbate all this. She has had three courses of Prednisone in the last year and has been on Ventolin and Beclovent regularly for two years.  Could it be the side effects of the inhaled steriods?  Are there any legitimate studies supporting this conjecture?  Could it simply be exhaustion from reduced lung function?  Or a psychological response to the daily intrusion of treatment and visits to the hospital?  Are there proven links between inhaled allergins and behaviour? Any shared stories would be of great interest to us. Trevor Gray

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’m new to this group so please forgive me if this subject has been talked out. Has anybody noticed behavioural changes in their children which may be associated with asthma in general, prescribed treatments, reduced lung function or any other aspect of the disease? As our daughters asthma has increased in severity her behaviour has changed. She has trouble concentrating, her attention span is nil, and her normally cooperative nature has been extinguished.  She no longer gets along with her siblings and rarely seems happy.  A flare up of her asthma seems to exacerbate all this. She has had three courses of Prednisone in the last year and has been on Ventolin and Beclovent regularly for two years.  Could it be the side effects of the inhaled steriods?  Are there any legitimate studies supporting this conjecture?  Could it simply be exhaustion from reduced lung function?  Or a psychological response to the daily intrusion of treatment and visits to the hospital?  Are there proven links between inhaled allergins and behaviour?

Of course your daughter’s behavior has changed!  She has an illness which deprives her of oxygen, requires a lot of doctor / hospital visits, makes her feel not-very-well a lot of the time, and limits her life.  Heck, that would make anybody cranky!  It sure made me that way until we got my asthma under control; and, it had the same effect on my ward when she was ill.  I think that you will find that, as you get the problem under control, her behavior and outlook will improve.  One of the things that I found with my ward was that giving her as much control as possible over her own care helped immensely.  She was responsible for doing her peak flows, taking her medicine, etc.  Obviously, I kept a close eye on it; but, her being responsible for remembering for herself made a major difference. Chris Owens

Response:

- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’m new to this group so please forgive me if this subject has been talked out. Has anybody noticed behavioural changes in their children which may be associated with asthma in general, prescribed treatments, reduced lung function or any other aspect of the disease? As our daughters asthma has increased in severity her behaviour has changed. She has trouble concentrating, her attention span is nil, and her normally cooperative nature has been extinguished.  She no longer gets along with her siblings and rarely seems happy.  A flare up of her asthma seems to exacerbate all this. She has had three courses of Prednisone in the last year and has been on Ventolin and Beclovent regularly for two years.  Could it be the side effects of the inhaled steriods?  

Steroids have been known to cause changes in mood, and albuterol (Ventolin) has been known to cause panic attacks. Your doctor should be informed on these side-effects; if not, either consult another doctor or a psychiatrist (a psychiatrist is an M.D. and should be familiar with side effects of medications that affect mood). Joan

Response:

Trevor, My son is 6, has had asthma, RAD, reflux, since birth and we are now looking into learning disabilities and emotional problems.  He is depressed and has low self esteem.  I finally got his doctors to listen to me about this and he’s going for an evaluation, neuro and psych. He has been through a lot, illnesses, loss of oxygen, hospitalizations, testing upon testing, medications after medications.  I feel it eventually effects them and causes other problems.  So we are on another road but whatever will help my son, I will do. Gina

Response:

We have a 4 year old with cough variant asthma, and when his asthma is active his moods become much more pronounced.  We have never been able to definitively link it to the asthma or the meds, and its probably both, but more particularly in him: the asthma.   Tough as it seems, being calm and reassuring helps both the asthma and the moods.  If that doesn’t work, try a walk, a smile and a hot bath.  Asthma is serious, but so is mental health.  And altough I haven’t seen the studies I can definitely say that panic attacks in parents lead to panic attacks in their children Bill.

Response:

Hi Trevor, Can’t tell you about my kids… only about what were my feelings after my first asthma attack. I was 9 y old and had a really bad attack, making the doctor stay all night home near my bed ! First of all, I didn’t understand what was happening… and my mother asking me all couple of minutes how I was doing was REALLY hard : that meant 2 things for me : 1) I couldn’t "slow down" ("be zen" like I would say today) to breath better because any word I had to say, or any head movement was too much fatigue, 2) What happenned had to be really serious… first time a doctor stayed near my bed that long…may be I wouldn’t see the next day Remember, I don’t want to make you anxious, all that stuff was only what was going on within this litle boy’s head. I have shorten the story a lot, but still remember it very well (I am now 43). I remember also this was the first time I had to command myself "breath in slowly", "breath out slowly"… something that usually works automaticaly. It really made me fear a lot what happened. But the worst stuff were all persons around me told me things like "all is OK", "sleep and you’ll be better tomorow" and so on. All had a nice voice, all were nice to me. BUT NOBODY told me WHAT WAS GOING ON, so I had the worst ideas in mind, and was sure to die in that night, and at this age, I knew the word "death", but I was unable to put an image on it, so my fantasy could speed up. I am still here, so time passed, and I couldn’t tell all this to my parents because I thought (and still think) they couldn’t be able to manage nervously the stress to explain such things like death and why I couldn’t breath, and what could happen now, and what could happen at the next attack, and why it struck me… and so on. I  assume nobody who didn’t experience it himself could imagine how many questions little kids have in mind, and how many LOGICAL answers they need… BTW, something like a sixt sense tells them really fast what is wrong when adults says something !!! But even at 9, 10 or 12, I probably would have been unable to find the words to ask these questions, and this made my behaviour change with all people around me, something like an armor to protect myself. I exactly remember I would have like my parents answered all my questions without I have to ask them… and I was something upset they didn’t… probably sort of mixture between the feeling they were not concerned about me and they didn’t understand me or didn’t care enough (of course I was wrong) ! I ONLY NEEDED TO UNDERSTAND WHAT HAPPENED, I also needed TO KNOW THIS WAS NOT A PUNISHMENT OF SOME GOD (crazy what kid’s fantasy could find…) and I HAD TO KNOW HOW AN ASTHMA ATTACK COULD PASS OFF in order to get my own marks, to know what happens next. For ex. at 14 or 15 year, and another attack, my mother asked me if I was OK (I hated this : didn’t she see what happened ?). I only told her : don’t bother untill my lips are not blue, all is OK ! This answer made her like crazy with fear, but I didn’t realize why, because I had found out this was one of the serious "benchmarks" I had put on the illness ! I really hope all this will help you little bit to understand your kid… but remember all kids and persons are different, and what I had experienced will not fit to everybody. Best regards Roland PS sorry for the poor language… some lexicon helped me, but it’s rather difficult to pass the right ideas when you don’t find the precise words !

Response:

Has anybody noticed behavioural changes in their children which may be associated with asthma in general, prescribed treatments, reduced lung function or any other aspect of the disease?

I noticed that my 7-year-old son became markedly "hyper" when taking nasal steroids, but I haven’t noticed it with the inhaled steroids.  You should ask your doctor about this, and possibly try changing medications.

Response:

Our son was diagnosed with asthma when he was 2 1/2 and was prescribed ventolin and becotide.  He continued with this treatment for about 18mths without no problems, then all of a sudden his behaviour started to change. He couldn;t concentrate, bad tempered and we found him generally very un-co-operative. We mentioned this to our doctor and it was suggested that he was experiencing side effects to the ventolin.  His medication was changed and now he is a totally different child.  Friends of ours had similar problems and when we told her our outcome she also discussed this with her doctor with exactly the same results as us. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – I’m new to this group so please forgive me if this subject has been talked out. Has anybody noticed behavioural changes in their children which may be associated with asthma in general, prescribed treatments, reduced lung function or any other aspect of the disease? As our daughters asthma has increased in severity her behaviour has changed. She has trouble concentrating, her attention span is nil, and her normally cooperative nature has been extinguished.  She no longer gets along with her siblings and rarely seems happy.  A flare up of her asthma seems to exacerbate all this. She has had three courses of Prednisone in the last year and has been on Ventolin and Beclovent regularly for two years.  Could it be the side effects of the inhaled steriods?  Are there any legitimate studies supporting this conjecture?  Could it simply be exhaustion from reduced lung function?  Or a psychological response to the daily intrusion of treatment and visits to the hospital?  Are there proven links between inhaled allergins and behaviour? Any shared stories would be of great interest to us. Trevor Gray

Response:

Does anybody get…

Question:

The ER doc was wrong.  You cannot feel bronchospasm because there are no sensory nerves there.

There is referred pain, however. It’s a fact that I get a very sore sensation in my upper back when I am suffering an attack. This is not due to muscles straining to breath because it occurs even when my PF is still very good. Jo.

Response:

The ER doc was wrong.  You cannot feel bronchospasm because there are no sensory nerves there. There are other sources of pain from an asthma attack.  Muscles get sore from doing work they were no designed for, and you can even tear cartilage or crack a rib. You might be better off if you referred this question to your regular doctor.

   I hope you have better Doctors there than they do here in Montreal! I have asked several Doctors about it and the only answer I got was when I was 16 and the paediatric pulmonologist told me it was puberty. HA!!! Other than that they ask me if it occurs during or after exercise, I tell them even when I’m at rest, and they scratch their chins with one of those Hmmm…s. That’s a specialist for ya.    I know the difference between muscle pain, and what happens during or pre-attack. The pain is extremely sharp, and runs across the mid part of my lung. It hurts like hell, but can be over with in moments. I’m just glad to know that I’m not the only one who gets it. I was starting to think I was weird(medically I mean, I don’t mind being strange in other ways). Tina in Montreal

Response:

   Does anyone here get a sharp and/or cramping chest pain in one or both lungs as a precurser to an asthma attack? — Tina in Montreal

Response:

   Does anyone here get a sharp and/or cramping chest pain in one or both lungs as a precurser to an asthma attack? — Tina in Montreal

I get a sharp pain on both sides of my chest before I have an attack…But if it’s going to be a bad attack I also get it on my back where my lungs would e.. Brittney Lyn

Response:

I don’t have the typical severe attacks associated with Asthma, but I do experience the chest pain – cramps quite frequently (almost daily).  Haven’t figured out a way to stop them yet except to quit breathing, but I’m not too crazy about the side effects of that course of action. -Kevin – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –   Does anyone here get a sharp and/or cramping chest pain in one or both lungs as a precurser to an asthma attack? — Tina in Montreal

Response:

That is actually quite common. — Good Luck, CBI, M.D. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text –   Does anyone here get a sharp and/or cramping chest pain in one or both lungs as a precurser to an asthma attack? — Tina in Montreal

Response:

Hi my husband , son, and I all get this type of pain in the chest with asthma attacks.  It can start mild and get relly bad to the point you can barely take a breath in .  Actually I first experienced this type of attack theis year, because I am a adult asthma onset person.  The first time I had this I had pneumonia, and was convinced I was having a heart attack.  It was bad..I put myself on oxygen , took inhalers for the heck of it, and called 911.  The ER doc said this was bronchospasm,and that is what it felt like.  Wonderful…..

Response:

Hi my husband , son, and I all get this type of pain in the chest with asthma attacks.  It can start mild and get relly bad to the point you can barely take a breath in .  Actually I first experienced this type of attack theis year, because I am a adult asthma onset person.  The first time I had this I had pneumonia, and was convinced I was having a heart attack.  It was bad..I put myself on oxygen , took inhalers for the heck of it, and called 911.  The ER doc said this was bronchospasm,and that is what it felt like.  Wonderful…..

The ER doc was wrong.  You cannot feel bronchospasm because there are no sensory nerves there. There are other sources of pain from an asthma attack.  Muscles get sore from doing work they were no designed for, and you can even tear cartilage or crack a rib. You might be better off if you referred this question to your regular doctor.

Response:

I haven’t had a really bad asthma attack in many years, but I remember as a teenager I had absolutely horrible chest pain during attacks. I could spend maybe one hour in a hay barn before it was too hard to breathe (Dad wasn’t exactly the sensitive sort — "Shut up and go put hay down for the cattle"). I always said it felt like there was a huge, heavy anvil sitting on my chest. I could only take very light, shallow breaths or the pain was too great (especially breathing out). It was not from sore muscles, torn cartilage, or cracked ribs. I would recover by the next morning and be fine. Mary – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Hi my husband , son, and I all get this type of pain in the chest with asthma attacks.  It can start mild and get relly bad to the point you can barely take a breath in .  Actually I first experienced this type of attack theis year, because I am a adult asthma onset person.  The first time I had this I had pneumonia, and was convinced I was having a heart attack.  It was bad..I put myself on oxygen , took inhalers for the heck of it, and called 911.  The ER doc said this was bronchospasm,and that is what it felt like.  Wonderful….. The ER doc was wrong.  You cannot feel bronchospasm because there are no sensory nerves there. There are other sources of pain from an asthma attack.  Muscles get sore from doing work they were no designed for, and you can even tear cartilage or crack a rib. You might be better off if you referred this question to your regular doctor.

Response:

Help my mother is on a ventilator

Question:

Donna – I can only imagine how frightening this must be for you.  Please know we are ALL thinking about you, around the world.  And praying for your Mom’s fast recovery. I have to agree with an earlier post – TAKE CARE OF YOURSELF.  Yes, be there for your Mom.  And take good care of yourself.  That’s probably exactly what SHE would like you to do, too.  So spend time with her, and also get REST, eat good foods and an occasional ice cream (!), and take a walk every day.  Even a short one.  Hot baths are good.  Stupid TV shows.  REST.  If you take good care of yourself you can take good care  of her. Now I’m off to take care of ME.  LOL.  Take a HUGE hug from across the ocean. (San Francisco) -Joopie

Response:

I have been on a vent. before.  I remember a little bit but not much.  It was hard to communicate so most of the time I just kept my eyes closed. They gave me a medicine called versed and it made me feel like I was dreaming most of the time. I remember people coming to see me and them talking but I don’t remember what they said.  It was nice to have them come. I remember that when I was off the vent. and the tube was pulled I thought I had only been on overnight but it was 7 days.  So keep talking to your mother and don’t worry about what you say. Let us know how things are. Pam

Response:

I’d like to thank you all for the emails I received and the replies to my message in this newsgroup about my mother who is on a ventilator. The emails have meant a great deal to me and were very helpful. Hearing stories of people who have been on ventilators and lived to tell the tale is very encouraging.  When I searched the net for such stories all I found was horror stories of people dying when the ventilator was removed, so it was getting all a bit depressing. My mother is getting much much better.  Her carbon dioxide levels (which got as high as 114) are now about 35 and today she actually tried to breathe for herself.   They are reducing the levels of drugs and sedation and may even remove the tube tomorrow (Thursday) – which means she will have been on the ventilator for a week. My mother was one of the lucky ones – one of the doctors said to me early on when her co2 levels were rising and things were looking bad, that most people in intensive care had 5 or 6 problems, but my mother only had one problem and that was asthma.  She just had one long asthma attack and we just had to wait for it to pass. I’ve been amazed to witness what happens in an intensive care ward and just how carefully the patients are monitored.  The ventilator really is an incredible machine, it keeps people alive and stable even though they can’t breathe for themselves.   When you first see someone on a ventilator all you want to do is cry because it looks so frightening, but all the medical equipment is there for a purpose and once you understand what it all does it is not so bad. I am looking forward to seeing her tomorrow.  I took this week off work (I work mon, tue & wed), but my children have still being going to daycare so I can see my mother (children cant really visit in ICU). Tomorrow to see her the social worker arranged two of the "Cuddle Mums" who normally cuddle premature babies in the maternity hopsital to come and look after my children (aged 7 months & 2.5) in the waiting room of ICU from 11.00 -12.00.  I’m just hoping that I will be able to see her then as they might be taking the ventilator out at that time.  Quite often when you go there you have to spend most of the time you can see them (visiting hours are only 11-12, 2-8) waiting outside while they do things to them, like turn them, bath them, physio, doctor visits etc). I guess I will wait and see.  I won’t be able to visit her again until Friday night (as my husband goes to college Thursday night and therefore can’t look after the children).  I might talk to the social worker about more cuddle mum time. Anyway, thank you all again. Donna

Response:

Hi Donna, I’m in this group because my daughter has asthma.Fortunately for me, I’ve never been in that situation, so I don’t know anything about it. But, since this group is a "support" group, I wanted to give you some! I’m sure your mother knows your there even if she appears sedated. I know your heart breaks just watching her there. I remember the first time I had to take my daughter to the emergency room and it was the first time she was given a nebulizer treatment. Watching my terrified 2 year old little angel laying on the bed with the mask on was heart wrenching for me. Oh now I’m getting teary eyed just thinking about it! I’ll say a prayer for your mother and please let us know how she’s doing. Donna Donna

Response:

Donna, I have never been on a ventilator myself, but I have cared for many patients (some of them friends and co-workers) who were. I am a respiratory therapist, the person who adjusts the dials and manages the machine.Later on, your mother may not be able to remember your being there at this time but I’m sure that she is aware of it now. Think of the many things that happen to us during childhood that we can’t quite remember as adults, but they meant the world to us when they happened. If you don’t know what to say to her, play her favorite music, or read her a book. Just talk to her, she hears you, even if she can’t respond. I hope your mother improves quickly. Post a message to let us know how she is. Penny Gagne Plouff RRT – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – On Wednesday when I rang my mother she said she had the flu and wanted to sleep all day.  My 2 year old daughter had a high fever so I gave my mother little thought until the next morning when she said she wanted to go to the hospital.  I went over to her house, found she could barely move and barely breathe.  We got as far as my car bonnet, then the nextdoor neighbours rang the ambulance and it came and took her away.  I followed the ambulance to the hospital – they only let me see her for a minute.  When they let me in again after about an hour they told her she was being admitted to intensive care with severe asthma.  They would not let me see her in intensive care, but later that day I got a phone call that she was going to be put on a ventilator. Ofcourse I had no idea what a ventilator was – I mean it just sounds like a hyped up nebulizer. They described it to me and how many tubes there were and how she would be sedated.  I didn’t get to see her until today (Saturday) and all I did was cry.  The people were were really nice and explained the purpose of all the equipment. Has anyone out there been on a ventilator for asthma?  If so, what do you remember?  Do you remember when people came to visit and talked to you?  They told me she was on light sedation and that her eyes opened when they moved her.   How long were you on it?  They initially told me my mother would be on it for two days, then it was five days now it is unknown.  They basically said it is one long asthma attack and she wont get off the ventilator until it is over.  The level of co2 on the monitor varies from 75-85 and they said a normally person would be about 45. I can’t think of anything cheery to tell her at all – I just hold her hand and talk to the nurse about all the equipment. I guess I better go now, I don’t want to tie up the phone line too long unless the hospital rings.   I guess also that I am glad I live in Australia where we have free healthcare – I dread to think that it would all cost if we had to pay for it. Donna

Response:

<snip Has anyone out there been on a ventilator for asthma?  If so, what do you remember?  Do you remember when people came to visit and talked to you?  They told me she was on light sedation and that her eyes opened when they moved her.  

I have never been to hospital with asthma let alone been on a ventilator.  However I used to work in an ITU and everyone acted as if the patients could hear them, as many correctly report what was said when they later recover full conciousness.  Sedation is common with ventilation.  I’m not sure of all the reasons. <snip I can’t think of anything cheery to tell her at all – I just hold her hand and talk to the nurse about all the equipment.

Please don’t worry about what to say.  Sit with her and hold her hand. Tell her you care.  Tell her the tennis scores if she likes tennis. Tell her about what is happening outside.  Say anything to her!  Just being there with her is the best, and only thing you can do.  However do please look after yourself as well.  Try to eat good food, sleep and take some excersise every day.  Just a 20 minute walk in a park or whatever. I guess I better go now, I don’t want to tie up the phone line too long unless the hospital rings. I guess also that I am glad I live in Australia where we have free healthcare – I dread to think that it would all cost if we had to pay for it.

My own sentiments on living in the UK. I hope your mother is OK. Donna

– Surfer! http://www.nevis-vieww.demon.co.uk http://www.nevis-vieww.demon.co.uk/flash Hopeful anti-spam: alter double ‘w’ to single ‘w’ to view site & send Email.

Response:

On Wednesday when I rang my mother she said she had the flu and wanted to sleep all day.  My 2 year old daughter had a high fever so I gave my mother little thought until the next morning when she said she wanted to go to the hospital.  I went over to her house, found she could barely move and barely breathe.  We got as far as my car bonnet, then the nextdoor neighbours rang the ambulance and it came and took her away.  I followed the ambulance to the hospital – they only let me see her for a minute.  When they let me in again after about an hour they told her she was being admitted to intensive care with severe asthma.  They would not let me see her in intensive care, but later that day I got a phone call that she was going to be put on a ventilator. Ofcourse I had no idea what a ventilator was – I mean it just sounds like a hyped up nebulizer. They described it to me and how many tubes there were and how she would be sedated.  I didn’t get to see her until today (Saturday) and all I did was cry.  The people were were really nice and explained the purpose of all the equipment. Has anyone out there been on a ventilator for asthma?  If so, what do you remember?  Do you remember when people came to visit and talked to you?  They told me she was on light sedation and that her eyes opened when they moved her.   How long were you on it?  They initially told me my mother would be on it for two days, then it was five days now it is unknown.  They basically said it is one long asthma attack and she wont get off the ventilator until it is over.  The level of co2 on the monitor varies from 75-85 and they said a normally person would be about 45. I can’t think of anything cheery to tell her at all – I just hold her hand and talk to the nurse about all the equipment. I guess I better go now, I don’t want to tie up the phone line too long unless the hospital rings.   I guess also that I am glad I live in Australia where we have free healthcare – I dread to think that it would all cost if we had to pay for it. Donna

Response: